4 ms·
Left-leaning columnist and economist wins Nobel? Doesn't seem very surprising to me given the history of the Nobel committee in the soft sciences and humanitie
by DanielBMarkham 18y ago
Left-leaning columnist and economist wins Nobel?
Doesn't seem very surprising to me given the history of the Nobel committee in the soft sciences and humanities. It will be interesting to see how history views Krugman's accomplishments. I know some of their laureates, like Arafat, didn't hold up so well.
- ajross 18y agoKrugman is much, much more than a liberal columnist. He got the column because, unlike most pundits, he has a long track record of interesting work in his field, and, unlike most eggheads, a knack for and interest in explaining those issues to the public. If you're reading him only via links from redstate.com or whatever, you're very much missing the point. And when did Yasir Arafat win the Nobel prize in Economics? You do realize that the selection committees are entirely different organizations, right? Must everything be a political swipe at conservatives? Isn't it possible that every once in a while one of those lib'ruls might actually produce something useful and be rewarded for it?
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoJust waitin' on history to tell. You can return to your ranting now.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoOr you can take out your frustration by modding me down. Look. Here's another one for you.
- davidw 18y agoWhy are we talking about leftists and economics and stuff in this thread? Oh, right - it's completely off topic argument bait. Here's a libertarian economist on some of Krugman's work: http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2008/10/pauls_nobel_nic.html http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2008/10/pauls_nobel_nic.... As a non-economist, one of the ways that I look at their work is to observe when they go 'against the grain' politically: when the left-wing ones argue for free markets, and when the right wing ones argue for intervention.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoI'm going to attempt rational discourse. So far you guys don't seem to like it so much. I'm not an economist. I don't read the guy. I'm sure he's the bees knees and the next best thing to sliced bread. I simply make the observation that the word is out that the Noble prize is a little myoptic. I've also heard that Krugman has become a reliable shill for the left. So when I heard he got the prize, I laughed. It seemed funny to me. Maybe I'm completely wrong. Glad to admit it. Let's let history be the judge. Or -- you can accuse me of trolling and downmod the crap out of my comments. I'm not looking for an argument. If you can understand that, we can talk reasonably. If not -- well, you always have that little down arrow to click on, right? That beats saying something intelligent. Thanks for the reply.
- aswanson 18y agoOut of curiosity, what exceptions do you take to left-leaning ideology? From an economic, social, or military standpoint do you find major problems with it, and why?(Just trying to drive understanding, not argument.)
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoPersonally I find the left and right very willing to take away my freedoms. The right wants to take away my freedoms to protect me and to keep our nation's religious heritage. The left wants to take away my freedom in the name of the greater good, the environment, redistributing wealth, and being "fair" ("fair" is a word that is used to evoke emotional a response) I don't listen to talk radio, I don't visit those sites that were mentioned, and I don't subscribe to anything more political that RealClearPolitics.com. So my comments were in no way meant to be controversial. I thought I had a right to share my amusement (and ignorance, for that matter) In my opinion, we do the best when we get both sides arguing with each other to find solutions in most of the problems we have. As such, I treasure dearly both my conservative and liberal friends -- ideologies are never completely correct, but honestly comparing different opinions kicks ass, whether its politics or startups.
- ajross 18y ago