3 ms·
Libertarians don't need to build fake islands (and all the safe waters in which to do so long-term are already claimed). No, there is Vanuatu, the libertarian d
by vacri 15y ago
Libertarians don't need to build fake islands (and all the safe waters in which to do so long-term are already claimed). No, there is Vanuatu, the libertarian dream state.
Forget the usual cry of 'Somalia!' for libertarians. Vanuatu gives them what they want - miniscule government with few services offered, small police which doubles as the military. There is no income tax unless you own rental property. Defense is sorted as it's not strategically located against other countries. It's a tropical paradise and the people rate as the happiest in the world.
If libertarians really were going to spend resources on an island, why not save themselves some dosh and go to Vanuatu? I mean, apart from libertarians pretty much all having income reliant on high-tech skills that won't get much demand in an agrarian society.
There are places for libertarians to go in this world to experience what they claim they want, that aren't war-torn Somalia. They won't do it, because deep down they really want the goodies that come along with a society with complex government. If libertarians won't move to one of these countries, there's no way this fake island is anything but a pipe dream.
- arethuza 15y agoWhat about Monaco, which is already full of the very wealthy, has no income tax and is a bit more conveniently located: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monaco http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monaco
- david927 15y agoI live next to Monaco and the word on the street is that it has only a few years left of tax haven status.
- yummyfajitas 15y ago..deep down they really want the goodies that come along with a society with complex government. Which goodies, specifically? Also, since most government programs are excludible (e.g., don't pay SS taxes, you don't get SS when you are old), do you feel libertarians would choose not to exit if given the option?
- vacri 15y agoI'm not getting into a dot-point argument with a libertarian. Been there, done that, bought the t-shirt. In my experience, libertarians are very bad at seeing the gestalt. They're also great at false dichotomies and selective reasoning. I'm not interested in another dot-point yawnfest. What I am saying is that there are places on Earth that conform much, much better to stated libertarian ideals than modern industrialised democracies. Some of them are paradises; it's not just Somalia on offer. If libertarians really wanted to opt out - the options are there already. And yet libertarians aren't leaving in droves. Why would a fake island be any more successful?
- Czarnian 15y agoOff the top of my head, I'd say the internet which you are ironically posting this on. The electric lines that are powering your computer. The sewer pipes that carry your waste away from your living space. The streetlamps you travel under at night. The legal system that protects your property from anyone who wants to take it from you. Should I go on? You know who didn't invent any of those things? The folks living in the liberterian paradise of Vanuatu.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoThe internet and electric lines are provided by Time Warner and ConEdison, respectively. As far as I'm aware, few libertarians have any beef with streetlamps or preventing violence. Of course, like most people, you avoided the main issue - the majority of the US government (65%, see my other post on this topic) is not preventing violence or providing roads. It's redistributing wealth. To bring up 35% of government spending while ignoring the other 65% is disingenuous.
- vacri 15y agoYou don't have to be libertarian to be interested in reducing government waste.
- Czarnian 15y agoIf that's the question you wanted answered, it should have been the question you asked. Instead, you asked which goodies are provided by a society with a complex government structure. Leaving aside the direct governmental involvement in the creation of the internet. Leaving aside the governmental influence in promoting the widespread use of electricity in the early 20th century. Time Warner and ConEdison don't exist without the complex governmental structures that define a corporation and provide the framework for them to operate. There is a reason why corporations don't exist in places like Somalia. There is a reason why corporations who incorporate in places like Bermuda don't actually do anything in those places. It's no coincidence that the most technologically advanced nations on the planet are also the ones with the most complex governmental structures. They are inextricably linked. Without one, you simply don't have the other. There's also the matter of the impact complex governmental structures have in protecting your private property. The little old lady at the county records office provides far, far more protection for your property than any gun ever will. Your private property exists because the government provides the framework for it to exist. Without things like car titles and property deeds, how long do you think it will be before someone just comes along and drives you out of your home so they can have it? If libertarians ever really thought about how much of their comfortable existence relied on the government they hated so much, their heads would explode.