4 ms·
'integrating' is a complex way of saying 'stuff leaks across a boundary slowly, and eventually when enough has leaked it triggers the spore to wake up'
by londons_explore 4y ago
'integrating' is a complex way of saying 'stuff leaks across a boundary slowly, and eventually when enough has leaked it triggers the spore to wake up'
- taneq 4y agoNothing wrong with that, after all that’s how the good ol’ 555 timer works!
- taeric 4y agoYeah, this feels dangerously close to claiming a woman's body is counting the months/days before they deliver a baby. And, to be fair, I think the actual research was more about modeling how it works. Not claiming that they count, per se. That is, just because you can model something mathematically, does not mean that the thing being modeled is the same as doing the math. Falling is not the same as calculating an equation, as it were.
- uoaei 4y ago> That is, just because you can model something mathematically, does not mean that the thing being modeled is the same as doing the math. Falling is not the same as calculating an equation, as it were. This feels like a false dichotomy. The two calculations demonstrate essentially the same function, but one is performed using physical dynamics (the accumulation of something on one side of a boundary) implemented in an analog computer (overcoming an activation potential) and the other using an abstracted representation (program) implemented in a digital computer (transformations via mathematical analysis).
- taeric 4y agoI wanted to say "but one isn't a calculation, per se. It is a physical process that can be modeled as a calculation." That said, I don't think I get the point you are driving to. Saying I have 1 apple and you give me another, is very akin to 1 + 1 = 2. Yet, calculating 1 + 1 = 2 in a computer is not "the same" as getting another apple in person. (And that is ignoring all of the data that is thrown away by "1 apple." How many grams/atoms/etc.?) I grant there is a fun view of reality being a simulation. But even then, there is a difference between simulating something, with all that implies in regards to data you have thrown out, and the thing you are simulating within that simulation. They may be equivalent in some consideration, but I find it a huge stretch to claim they are the same.
- danuker 4y agoYour comment made me realize a chemical reaction is an analog computer computing every parameter of the chemical reaction at once.
- gilded-lilly 4y agoYour comment made me realize the universe is a quantum computer calculating the position of every sub atomic particle in real time.
- mjan22640 4y agoIt might only appear real time from within the simulation.
- uoaei 4y agoThat is precisely my point...
- danuker 4y agoIndeed. Your comment prepared me for the experience, but the ball did not drop in my case until taeric's comment (which incidentally missed your point). To taeric: Anything IS an analog computer of itself. Doing it for real completely bypasses the need to simulate.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mellavora 4y ago> That is, just because you can model something mathematically, does not mean that the thing being modeled is the same as doing the math. Falling is not the same as calculating an equation, as it were. Interesting. The other reply to this, along with its subthread, assumes that "calculating" means "calculated using a digital computer". Does anyone know what I do in my head when I calculate 4 + 4 is 8? Does anyone know what they do in their own head to calculate 4 + 4? Is that process the same as 2 + 2? as 38 + 153?
- taeric 4y agoFew people know what happens in a computer to calculate the same. And that it is potentially very different depending on what the instructions are used to do it. :D
- im3w1l 4y agoStuff leaks across the boundary in a stimulus dependent manner though. So it's basically setting dStuff / dt = Stimulus. Monitoring stuff-levels then allows it to monitor area under stimulus curve. Quite fascinating if you ask me.
- tantalor 4y agoArticle mentions "short nutrient pulses result in step-like changes" which implies a discrete event, not like continuous leakage. I wonder about distribution of the sizes of those pulses. If all the pulses are basically the same size, then a trigger over the total is indistinguishable from "counting" the number of pulses. Otherwise, yeah it's not really like "counting" at all.
- samatman 4y agoI'm pretty sure (having read the same two paragraphs as anyone else) that the pulses were caused artificially in the experiment. The pulses let them demonstrate that the spores can passively soak up potassium to a certain threshold, then activate. The interesting part being that the process doesn't cost the spore energy. This is more like measurement than counting, imho. Something of an osmotic thermostat, ionostat perhaps.
- kazinator 4y agoThat's in the sense of mathematical integration; e.g. integrating op-amp, etc.