3 ms·
It makes no sense because there is no single aquifer, nor is there any economic way of connecting all aquifers in the state. Most of the state has aquifers whi
by lazide 4y ago
It makes no sense because there is no single aquifer, nor is there any economic way of connecting all aquifers in the state.
Most of the state has aquifers which have plenty (an excess) of water, and these are drawn on by wells sunk by the owners of the property.
Others have no aquifers, or fossil aquifers being drawn far more rapidly than they are being replenished - often by folks who own the land under them, and paid for the wells.
Then there are seasonal sources and water storage (aka rivers and dams), but depending on the timing of a specific storm (or not), they'll usually have too much or too little water some of the year, and the inverse other parts of the year.
Also, water has vastly different levels of utility and availability depending on purity and the time it is needed among other factors, which directly impact the actual costs involved in delivering it.
Someone getting bulk (untreated) water that is overflow from a dam during spring flood season has made tradeoffs that make no sense for someone in the city who needs smaller amounts of drinkable water, but must have it 24/7/365 - and those differences drastically reduce the cost to deliver it.
And lastly - who is paying this money to whom?
Right now, everyone pays the water district that has either bought the land and sunk the wells, or who turns around and pays various different water sources for the water (all at different prices based on quality and time of year) and then treats it as necessary based on those factors for the customer.
Depending on the time of year and circumstances, the actual marginal cost for a gallon of water can vary from free to very expensive, and can vary completely at the same time of year for different people in different parts of the state.
And since there is no one party who owns, delivers, or controls water, there is no one person who gets paid anyway.
What's the proposal - every gallon must cost $1?
What about folks on their own private wells? Do they send a check to the state franchise tax board if they don't otherwise need to pay anyone? Do they get to deduct the maintenance and electricity costs they currently pay themselves?
Who is going to even check a 'meter' there, since they literally don't have one now?
Even when they're in Redding, and it's literally a rainforest?
California has incredibly diverse and often rough terrain with widely different rainfall, geological conditions, and ability to support life of all kinds. From the Mojave desert, which is one of the driest deserts in the world (2-6 inches of rain per year), to Tahoe averaging 52", to the lost coast [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lost_Coast https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lost_Coast] / Redding area which gets 100-200"/year (yes, 8-16ft of precipitation per year).
And over a distance, and with large mountain ranges, that make it difficult and prohibitively expensive to arbitrarily move something as heavy as water around in random ways. It's over 1000 miles from North to South, 500 east to west, and almost 15,000 feet of elevation difference in the state.