4 ms·
> I see that there are certain situations where ex post, you get some weird outcomes where _hypothetically_ ranking your preferred candidate lower would have he
by crazygringo 4y ago
> I see that there are certain situations where ex post, you get some weird outcomes where _hypothetically_ ranking your preferred candidate lower would have helped your candidate.
It's not even that strong -- it's outcomes where ranking your second-most preferred candidate above your preferred one will help get that second-most preferred candidate elected, as opposed to a third one you detest -- if you know your most preferred candidate won't be elected.
Which makes sense, of course. But it's also "cheating" to manipulate the system if those aren't your actual preferences, and it wouldn't even work in practice because you'd have to know how everyone voted in the first place to know if it was worth it.
You're right, it seems fair to me too in this instance.
- ClayShentrup 4y agoOf course it works in practice. You just vote for the stronger lesser evil candidate, for the same reason my aunt voted for Biden even though she preferred Warren. This is called compromise strategy. The opposite strategy would be like if Trump supporters voted for Warren to advance the weaker candidate against their guy. The same strategy works in any kind of runoff method including instant runoff voting.
- BuyMyBitcoins 4y agoWhat you mentioned is something closed primaries are designed to counteract.
- fdsjgfklsfd 4y agoClosed primaries are the reason we have a polarized two-party system.
- BuyMyBitcoins 4y agoStates with open primaries suffer from the same polarization. I think the root cause of a polarized two party system goes much deeper than that.