3 ms·
> "Gun buybacks are a fantastic way of showing, number one, that your policies don't work, and, number 2, you're creating perverse demand. You're causing people
by kube-system 4y ago
> "Gun buybacks are a fantastic way of showing, number one, that your policies don't work, and, number 2, you're creating perverse demand. You're causing people to show up to these events, and, they don't actually reduce crime whatsoever."
Of course, criminals aren't going to turn in their guns. Gun buybacks have always just been useful for their second order effects -- forgotten guns in attics being stolen, found by kids, etc.
Yes, people take advantage of these events. There's not much of a way to filter participants by intent. People turn in broken or rusty junk that is not of danger anyway. Doing it with a junk plastic gun is not much different than doing the same with junk guns made from other materials. But the bottom line is I don't think anyone ever thought that the results of these events would be 1-for-1 removal of crime guns off the street.
- wyldfire 4y ago> I don't think anyone ever thought that the results of these events would be 1-for-1 removal of crime guns off the street. I don't think I would've guessed it but apparently firearm deaths exceed motor vehicle traffic deaths in the US. Score one for auto safety. But regarding "stolen, found by kids, etc." -- there's lots of accidental deaths and injuries from kids finding guns. So I think you're right -- that's exactly the kind of thing buybacks help reduce. Motor vehicle traffic deaths Number of deaths: 40,698 Deaths per 100,000 population: 12.4 All firearm deaths Number of deaths: 45,222 Deaths per 100,000 population: 13.7 Source: National Vital Statistics System – Mortality Data (2020) via CDC WONDER
- thatswrong0 4y agoIn the US, 60% of firearm deaths are from suicide. There are, on the other hand, ~430 accidental firearm deaths per year. Not saying reducing accidental deaths isn't a good thing, but in terms of efficacy, the dollar spent per reduced death, I feel like there might be better ways other than a buyback program.
- core-utility 4y agoFor anyone curious, 40% of 45,222 is 18,089
- kube-system 4y agoMental health treatment is of course the best way to prevent suicides, but when people are in a suicidal mental state, they're a lot better off if they don't have grandpa's heirloom shotgun lying around.
- wyldfire 4y ago> In the US, 60% of firearm deaths are from suicide. How many suicide deaths would happen with fewer firearms available? I suspect a large portion of the suicide victims may not even be the owner/purchaser of the firearm used. Among all the methods, suicide by firearm is awful because it's so effective. Without an available firearm, attempting suicide by another method might be something that could be recoverable with some intervention after the attempt. Seems like a buyback could reduce the opportunity for deaths and injuries due to suicide attempts.
- agensaequivocum 4y agoSouth Korea has a much higher suicide rate and virtually no firearms.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ihattendorf 4y agoThat's irrelevant. How do you know it wouldn't be higher if there were more firearms? Too many variables.
- aksss 4y agoThe US has only very recently started to eclipse other developed nations in suicide rate, and you can probably point to twenty years of war and the 2008 financial collapse as having a significant role to play in this. Maybe social media too. But gun ownership (access to firearms) is not in any way correlated with high per capita suicide rates. For many decades you might have been able to show inverse correlation. If people want to suicide, they'll suicide.
- Dracophoenix 4y agoThe firearm numbers don't distinguish between suicides, accidental deaths, self-defense, and homicides whether intended or negligent.
- cronix 4y agoWe also had a lot of lockdowns/work from home/etc in 2020, which prevented a lot of people from driving, probably lowering that driving stat. It would be interesting to get statistics for a non-covid year.
- autoexec 4y agoBecause of covid some places stopped requiring kids to pass a driver's test to get a license. Some only had to have a parent sign off that their child was a good enough driver. I wouldn't be surprised if that had an impact on the number of accidents.
- nsxwolf 4y agoThe reduction in accidents and suicides from gun buyback programs sounds essentially impossible to measure. These programs cost money so they should be justified with real evidence. I understand it isn't very much money, and studying it would likely cost orders of magnitude more. There's other costs though, like an erosion of belief in government competence.
- core-utility 4y agoIf all it takes for a "forgotten" attic gun to be secured is something to trigger those gun owners to take action on securing them, a simple ad campaign would be a lot cheaper than $500 gift cards.
- kennywinker 4y ago> a simple ad campaign Ads of course are free and universally effective, as we all know.
- core-utility 4y agoThe gun buyback surely had ads just to get people to even show up, not yet including the staff time of people working the event and the gift cards.
- Volundr 4y agoI think the point is someone is a lot more likely to take action over $500 than just hearing an add on TV.
- kennywinker 4y agoWhy bother advertising your gun buyback? Just have someone scam you with 3d printed guns and let the free publicity roll on in
- kube-system 4y agoLocal news typically covers "community events" like these as a matter of news, rather than advertisement. Whereas PSAs are paid.
- kube-system 4y agoI wouldn't expect a $21,000 ad campaign to have much effect either.
- aksss 4y ago> criminals aren't going to turn in their guns The programs often encourage them to through "no questions asked"/amnesty policies. These programs are a great way to launder a dirty gun, but criminals are hardly likely to turn in a "clean" gun.
- kube-system 4y agoCriminals might be dumb, but they're not dumb enough to hand a murder weapon to a cop regardless of what they say.
- zanderz 4y agoA shoulder mounted anti-tank rocket was once turned over at a gun buyback in San Francisco: https://abc7news.com/san-francisco-gun-buyback-bazooka-guns/2789856/ https://abc7news.com/san-francisco-gun-buyback-bazooka-guns/... I think it is probably worth a lot of taxpayer money to get that off the streets. More broadly, without wading into 2nd amendment arguments and just viewed as a public health issue, it seems possible that fewer guns in the general population equals fewer gun deaths. Whether these buybacks make any dent at all is a different question - one that would likely be easier to answer if political pressure hadn't halted government studies of gun safety https://www.npr.org/2018/04/05/599773911/how-the-nra-worked-to-stifle-gun-violence-research https://www.npr.org/2018/04/05/599773911/how-the-nra-worked-...
- kube-system 4y ago> I think it is probably worth a lot of taxpayer money to get that off the streets. That AT4 is a single-shot disposable weapon, cannot be reloaded, and is not reusable.