18 ms·
Anti-pattern theater: how to get women to quit
- watmough 15y agoThis is some awesome writing. Bookmarked.
- qzio 15y agoI agree, why the f are your comment down voted?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- andrewflnr 15y agoI didn't downvote (can't actually), but some possible reasons are: * The writing style was not considered relevant to the conversation about sexism. * No one is interested in the GP's bookmark list.
- watmough 15y agoDarn, this article got posted about the same time I submitted a link. I did post that, since I did get bogged down for an hour or so reading the other posts on the site. The author appears to be a female sysadmin, in Ireland, with some time in Google, or a contractor for Google. Really excellent stuff, and you know, sorry for my irrelevant comment, but something, any comment can serve to get a deserved link up onto the front page.
- andrewflnr 15y agoI don't think comments on submissions reflect their ranking, unless this FAQ is not the whole story: http://ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html http://ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html
- VladRussian 15y agoWhile R&D at Google may be a geek's heaven, the Operations at Google is a hell, an ITIL hell, 200% Dilbert [the ITIL's blueprint is the Britain's state healthcare IT by IBM in the 1980ies]. No wonder that she's snapped.
- fondue 15y agoSomething similar happened to my wife. The President of their company would breeze by the lab. In an effort to keep employee salaries down he would casually mention how everyone in the lab was easily replaceable. I have no idea how one would casually mention this but he somehow managed to work it into the conversation. Needless to say everyone there in the lab got the impression that they weren't wanted. I think in the span of twelve months everyone woman there quit and moved on to better jobs. When my wife moved on she found a job with double the salary and a company that really appreciates her.
- pkteison 15y agoWhat does "you are all easily replaceable" have to do with gender? It sounds like the president is just a bean counting jerk, no gender involved.
- cowardoftheday 15y agoHe was purposefully creating an anecdote to illustrate what's wrong with the OP's conclusion.
- jamesbritt 15y agoSuch stories give the impression that you can say the exact same thing to both men and women, but women will by and large interpret it (or at least act on it) in a way quite different from men. I find that hard to believe. For myself (a guy), if I worked someplace where I was often reminded how replaceable I was I;d be looking for a new job all the time. Likewise, if I was often told I was being "too emotional" I'd wonder if a) it was possibly true, and b) consider that perhaps I need to work someplace where my personality is a better fit. In general, if you want to make anyone quit, keep telling them they are easily replaceable, or frequently lob baseless subjective criticisms at them.
- true_religion 15y agoWhy is that hard to beleive? Society in general treats boys and girls differently from the day they are born. Why should it be expected that this divergence in nurture ought to produce similar results? I think that in contemporary society, men and women are different---not due to simple biology but due to upbringing---and while this difference isn't what's reflected in so-called 'common sense' psychology, it is a valid difference worth exploring through science.
- davidhansen 15y agoI'm pretty sure the author reached an entirely fallacious and baseless conclusion. My understanding of the events are thus: 1. An authentication daemon crashes periodically due to a bug. 2. "S" discovers that rebooting the daemon's host prevents this from happening for a while, and does so. 3. The author is paged( 5 times ), discovers the problem, and writes a kludge script to keep the systems running until the bug can be fixed. 4. During the post-mortem meeting, she identifies "S" for his role in the events. 5. A thin-skinned manager suggests the author was too hard on "S". 6. The author, without any evidence, concludes that the manager said this because she is a woman, and is hellbent on "pushing [her] out" of the team. The reality is that thin-skinned managers and managers overly sensitive to maintaining office decorum exist everywhere, and they don't do this based on your sex. Citing anecdotal evidence, I can say that having a penis does not shield you from accusations of being "too hard", and that hearing this from managers, coworkers, or employees, likely has nothing at all to do with sexism or a desire to "push out" women.
- briantrice 15y agoYou don't seem to appreciate the amount of forethought she not only felt she had to commit to, but self-control to execute her communication that way, and that it still didn't work. Only an idiot would provide "evidence" to a subordinate that they were trying to push them out, in any case. Discrimination is very hard to prove, and it's easier to just "get away".
- cperciva 15y agoI'm not sure what you're saying here. People who are discriminating against women avoid given evidence of that fact, so a lack of evidence of discrimination is evidence of discrimination?
- briantrice 15y agoThe idea of evidence is not implied by the article, only by the commenter above. She is describing her experience, and it jibes with other women's experience whom I have heard. If you don't accept the validity of the viewpoint, just do that as such.
- philwelch 15y agoIf you have a chip on your shoulder in re sexism, you will perceive every negative interaction through that lens. Alternatively: > How do you piss off a technical woman so she will leave your team? It's easy. Just go and lob a few complaints about her behavior that would never apply to a guy. The easiest one of these is to say "you're being too emotional". Who's going to argue against that? Making claims like that, in effect, is simply a unilateral claim of immunity against the accusation of being too emotional: it gives one the license to be as emotional as one likes, with any criticism conveniently pre-framed as sexism.
- ams6110 15y agoGeneralizing, this applies to any "-ism", e.g. racism, sexism, antisemitism, etc. While I would never claim these no longer exist, in modern western society they are not the primary or even a significant factor in how a person is judged or treated at work.
- kstenerud 15y agoI'd argue that her monotone, 20 questions-style responses were counterproductive. You can see her boss having to fish for information, when all she had to do was: B: So I was looking at the pages from this weekend and it looks like we had something bad on Saturday. What happened? W: There were too many queries failing in the Netherlands. I got a bunch of pages in the middle of the night and finally tracked the problem down to a bug in the new authentication daemon. B: So is it working now? W: It's working under a kludge. I wrote a restart script for it, but we need to get a patch to fix it for real. B: When did this start? W: Sometime before my shift. B: Who was on call then? W: S. He rebooted the machines and the problem went away, but it came back again during my shift so I put in the auto restart as a stopgap measure until we could get a real fix. Her treatment of S is harsh because she doesn't couch what she says at all to protect him, like you normally do in order to promote office harmony. It's obvious that she's frustrated from her previous dealings with certain people, and their alleged sexism (which, unfortunately, is not demonstrated in her recounting). Unfortunately, her response is to attack a hornet with a sledgehammer (with corresponding collateral damage) and then blame the result on sexism.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- lhnz 15y agoMy own strategy would probably be to slowly create talking points about empathising with the user and the good it does to products. This is fairly subtle and you're unlikely to be called out on it. Eventually your detractors will be playing in your frame when they next try to argue that you're 'too empathetic/emotional'. That or just leave.
- r00fus 15y agoBingo. If you can't find a way to tie any honest but possibly harsh comments back to either getting work done on time, customer satisfaction or (ultimately) the company's fortunes, you might be in the wrong. As it appears that the blog author was in the right, framing is critical to put attitude in perspective. I'm not a woman, I have been in situations similar to these and made similar responses and gotten different but functionally similar reactions (i.e., don't put blame where it belongs, you might make the incompetent person feel bad). After trying to connect the success of that particular task to the project success and company welfare and getting nowhere, I eventually left.
- shasta 15y agoIronically, this blog post brings to mind a different female stereotype: too much drama.
- Tichy 15y agoI wonder if the women who complain about bad treatment in IT also read Dilbert. Just as a basic impression of what it is like to be male in the industry.
- roguecoder 15y agoBecause Scott "men are genetically programmed to rape so we shouldn't really blame them" Adams wouldn't possibly infuse his strip with sexist, martyr-complex, responsibility-avoiding, self-serving cultural portrayals. Nope, definitely not. Not saying the tech industry is a bed of roses. But "this sucks for everyone" doesn't mean "so she shouldn't complain". It means "we should fix this for everyone." Women have all the problems men have there, plus they are isolated, subject to sexist behavior and criticized heavily if they ever speak about their experiences. This is a case of "yes, and..." not "yes, but..." If men don't like the way other men are treating them it is not women's responsibility or even possibly under their control. It definitely shouldn't be proposed as an excuse to dismiss or ignore women's feedback on how men treat them (which is both women's and men's problems, and is under men's control).
- Tichy 15y agoI am not even a Dilbert fan, it just came to mind as an easy way to get an impression. (Office Space, on the other hand...). It just sometimes seems as if when women say "men", what they mean is actually only the top 5% of alpha males they actually recognize as men. The rest of the male population and their plight does not even register on the radar. Yes, the problems should be fixed for everyone, and I also can imagine there are problems specific to women. Not sure they are always sexist, though. For example I also face problems as a father when I take care of my child alone at times. It occurred to me it might have parallels to the situation of women in IT. Namely, usually mothers meet other mothers (on the playground, at home, wherever). Now, if I want to meet other kids on my "daddy day", I feel a bit awkward. I haven't created the same networks that my wife did - hooking up with mothers starting from birth courses to frequent playground and mother group visits. I suppose I could call her "other mother" friends and visit them with my son, too. But it would feel a bit weird, at least at first (haven't actually tried it yet), because I am not directly their friend, I am only the friend of their friend. I wouldn't blame it on sexism, though, it is simply evolved historically, because they went to more kid related courses than I did. Even if I change the diapers once per day and my wife does it 6 times a day, it creates a distortion. I am all for fixing the problem, but blaming the wrong reason is very counterproductive to that. Just saying "it must be sexism" prevents people from looking at other possible causes.
- mebesilly 15y agoWhat a drama queen. She would be hell to work with.
- true_religion 15y ago> Just go and lob a few complaints about her behavior that would never apply to a guy. The easiest one of these is to say "you're being too emotional". I'm nor sure this would never apply to a guy. Saying someone is illogical or "motivated by emotion, not reason", or is "overly sentimental" seems to be a common attack during geek flamewars. It's also a fairly common attack during corporate shark feeding frenzies. That it was once used to attack women in general (as opposed to individually) actually makes it more tenous to use it as an attack against a woman. The speaker in that case can be accused of being sexist, whilst if they called a man "emotional", it would force someone to address the accusation itself.
- jeltz 15y agoAnd as a bonus when used against a man you will at the same time question his manliness. So actually I think this low blow argument might be even better used against men, but works against women. And for the specifics of the article. I see no explicit accusation of being emotional. "I was being hard on S" does not necessarily mean that the people being hard on another is emotional, since it could also mean almost the opposite: that you do not care about people's emotions. And this argument ("being too hard on") can be and is used on men. I do not see how this article relates to sexism, rather it relates to various low blow tactics in corporate politics.
- VladRussian 15y agoit is clear that author's emotions are out of control in both cases - during the described incident and when she writes the post. She fails by refusing to recognize that. High-tech jobs are very stressful (after all, each of us is immensely smart and is surrounded by morons :) and managing and controlling the stress is a part of the job. Failure to do so is a professional failure, especially when it is support/operations type of the job. Instead of recognizing her problem and trying to deal with it, the author pulls the sexism card. Next time her boss and others may be not that fortunate, and it may cost them job, reputation and/or lawsuit.
- wtvanhest 15y agoIt seems overly emotional to me to write this article. (Maybe it is perfectly sensible, but to me, it seems overly emotional).
- tkellogg 15y agoI agree. I found the article very informative. I will have to try this new social pattern at my job to get rid of that bitchy UX designer.
- gordonguthrie 15y agoThis discussion is quite amazing. Someone with a high-quality technical blog writes a post about sexism. Magically a huge stream of comments arrive: "the author reached an entirely fallacious and baseless conclusion" "without any evidence, concludes that the manager said this because she is a woman" "Whether or not this incident was motivated by sexism, there's absolutely no indication, based on the facts presented, that it was." "then she is overreacting. Not because she's a woman, mind you. Because she really is too touchy about this" "she's raging over and reading so much into a statement that is, by normal standards, extremely neutral, leads me to believe that even if she has been directly accused of being too emotional in the past, then maybe there's something to the accusations" "Playing the sexism card every time you run into a bad manager with a dysfunctional team seems like wasted effort to me." "to look for gender based explanations just seems overly paranoid" "It can only be used on women who give a crap about being viewed as emotional." "I can claim that my business partners are space aliens who read my thoughts and are plotting to colonize the planet all day long, but as long as there's no shred of evidence of this, the fact that nobody appreciates the lengths I go to wear tinfoil hats and research anti-alien combat techniques is meaningless" "it's related to "W" being a bit of a jerk than it is "W" being female" "If you have a chip on your shoulder in re sexism, you will perceive every negative interaction through that lens" "that, in effect, is simply a unilateral claim of immunity against the accusation of being too emotional: it gives one the license to be as emotional as one likes" "It's obvious that she's frustrated from her previous dealings with certain people, and their alleged sexism (which, unfortunately, is not demonstrated in her recounting). Unfortunately, her response is to attack a hornet with a sledgehammer (with corresponding collateral damage) and then blame the result on sexism." "this blog post brings to mind a different female stereotype: too much drama" "that author's emotions are out of control in both cases - during the described incident and when she writes the post. She fails by refusing to recognize that" "It seems overly emotional to me to write this article. (Maybe it is perfectly sensible, but to me, it seems overly emotional)." The actual article begins with the paragraph: "How do you piss off a technical woman so she will leave your team? It's easy. Just go and lob a few complaints about her behavior that would never apply to a guy. The easiest one of these is to say "you're being too emotional" This entire discussion is unbelievable - Rachel By The Bay ought to be a respected member of this community based on her blog - instead she is being attacked in a bizarre way.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- mkopinsky 15y agoFor further context, see http://rachelbythebay.com/w/2011/06/04/fireandforget/ http://rachelbythebay.com/w/2011/06/04/fireandforget/ "Fire and Forget, or Sexism in Software Engineering".
- waveman 15y agoHer complaint here, one of many many complaints of sexism, seems to be that her manager is unhappy that she loads him down with complaints and too much detail that he doesn't want to know. She puts this down to sexism. It's not clear why this is sexist. She is wasting his time. If he is like most managers he is very pressed for time and he doesn't need his time wasted. In this case, sexism is a redundant explanation because other, better, simpler explanations are available. in Bayesian theory this is technically called "explaining away" and it is a good thing. Fact A is not evidence for claim B if explanation C is better. http://www.cs.ubc.ca/~murphyk/Bayes/bnintro.html http://www.cs.ubc.ca/~murphyk/Bayes/bnintro.html
- wpietri 15y agoNote that you've gone from "It is not clear to me that it is sexist," to "She is wrong about the explanation." That something isn't clear to you only means it isn't clear to you. She is in possession of an enormous volume of information about the situation. You aren't. The reasonable conclusion isn't "sexism is a redundant explanation"; it's "perhaps she has not revealed the information the led her to her conclusion". Now ask yourself: why did you so quickly leap to the particular erroneous conclusion that sexism was not the problem? There are a lot of erroneous conclusions to come to. Or you could have come to none at all.
- parfe 15y agoAh sexism. I love it when I sees it. This thread just oozes it! In fact, most of the posters here write with the exact sexist bent the writer warns about. * Explain she overreacted; tell her she is wrong. * Claim her feelings have no merit; tell her she is wrong. * Tell her you know how she should feel; tell her she is wrong. * Flatly deny she encountered sexism; tell her she is wrong * Change the discussion to center on men; minimize her response by associating it with a trivial issue "everyone" has to deal with
- dlitz 15y agoHow do you suggest that a non-sexist person should deal with a situation like this, without privileging the claims of the writer?
- roguecoder 15y agoEngage with behavior, not state of mind. "Your report was factually incorrect in X, Y and Z respects" would be fine. If by "too emotional" they meant "was yelling at me in the hall" then the correct response is "the way you are speaking to me is unacceptable" and to take it up with HR. If she's wrong, that's what they should be engaging with. If she's treating them badly, that's what they should be engaging with. If they are just providing excuses not to take her seriously, they aren't dealing with a situation at all; they are just being jerks. Basically, any approach should lead to concrete suggestions for changed behavior that would improve the bottom line of the company. "You are too emotional" is neither actionable nor measurable, so it is entirely unhelpful. "You were rough on S in there" is also neither actionable or measurable: if she didn't get any of the facts wrong and S looked bad, it's S's fault he acted in ways that looked bad, especially if she was responding to direct questions. Any culture that prioritizes covering up responsibility rather than failing transparently, finding the root causes and fixing them is doomed in the long run anyway.
- bermanoid 15y agoSo you really think that she did encounter sexism, based on her description of the dispute? Because that's where I question her. This situation reeked to me of one engineer trying to shovel shit onto another one, and the response seemed to be that of a more level headed manager trying to defuse the situation so that nobody ended up fired. Which is not something that I'm willing to pin on sexism without some evidence. Especially having been the relatively-level-headed manager (in a male-v-male situation) in the unfortunate position of being between one engineer and his rival, which is unfortunately not a very rare situation, given the types of personalities that take on sysadmin jobs. It's not pleasant, and given the expense of finding new engineers, trust me, you're willing to do anything to avoid having to fire the (seemingly competent, despite the intra-office-feuds that might arise) ones that you have, including telling the better sysadmins to shut the fuck up and stop complaining about their colleagues.
- waveman 15y agoI read her blog because it has some interesting ideas. However it reminds me of PZ Myers' blog in some ways. There is the same repetitive theme of how stupid all these people are compared to moi. "Within six months, they had an actual user-affecting outage directly attributed to things on that team. We hadn't had any of them during my tenure running that service." "As I've said before, enjoy your pages, guys. " Maybe this is just typical sysadmin arrogance / all users are ID10Ts. I also see signs of a paranoid attitude: "I knew it was going to be a disaster and they'd use it against me". Playing games of passive-aggressives: "I was going to be cold and dry and only answer exactly what was asked of me." Really if you drop of load on a co-worker in a team meeting you are going to get some blowback. Her blog is also full of complaints of women not being treated fairly eg: http://rachelbythebay.com/w/2011/11/23/hiring/ http://rachelbythebay.com/w/2011/11/23/hiring/ (has to walk across the road to get to her car) Unleash the white knights!
- adaml_623 15y agoYour last comment about origAuthor desiring a secure environment to work in and extending that desire to the carpark is a bit rubbish. If your employees have to be at work after dark then you should definitely organise safe conditions for them to get home. Women are more sensitive to this because they get attacked/raped by strangers a lot more often than men. It's the real world. You have to deal with it. HNers should be able to deal with it when they realise they are wrong and need to change their thoughts and behaviour.
- DanBC 15y ago> Women are more sensitive to this because they get attacked/raped by strangers a lot more often than men. Men are much more likely to be the victim of violence from strangers than women. The vast majority of violence (including sexual violence and rape) against women is from people they know; "friends", husbands, colleagues. This is a minor point though; I do agree that employers need to provide a safe environment for employees, and that women feel more at risk in dark car parks.
- gordonguthrie 15y ago
- Scootah 15y agoI worked in helpdesks for just shy of a decade, from office junior in a dev shop, to level 1 in a dialup ISP, then through pretty much every available tech role up to microsoft tech lead at for a top 5 in the world hosting company and senior tech escalation for a top 5 in the world domain registrar. I've been working as an IT contractor in enterprise (government, large industrial, large corporate) environments for the last 5 years. I've personally seen - a boss with a policy to only hire ugly or fat girls, because pretty girls distract the geeks - a level 2 engineer passed over multiple times for promotions, because she wouldn't say fuck in the presence of three or more members of the senior engineers group - a systems engineer bumped to team lead, then project lead, then solutions architect, generally held to be the best boss anyone in her group had every worked for and one of the highest delivering tech leadership resources in the company, quit and start a business outside of IT when guys who were consistently performing below her metrics in other teams were getting better bonuses and better base salaries, and she was being told that there wasn't money to go around for her. - an enterprise architect come back from maternity leave (10 months) where she had been effectively part timing (10 to 30 hours a week) because the incompetent guy who'd taken over from her was hopeless and kept calling her for help, who was told that because she'd been out of the current technology scope for so long she'd have to go back to the help desk for 6 months to come up to speed and she'd then be eligible to apply for a promotion, if she did a good job. The incompetent guy who'd been badgering her for her time through her maternity leave was made permanent in her old job. - Company christmas parties organized behind the girl's backs - so that they could be held at a strip club, while the girls got stuck holding the fort while everyone else got paid to go to the pub. The christmas party incident, the three girls who got stuck in the office were told to their face that it was a random selection and they just happened to come up. Three girls in a pool of 40 resources, and they happened to all come up? For a party that they hadn't been told about, at a strip club? I worked with a girl once who probably wasn't as talented/knowledgable as most of the guys in the tech pool. But she was by far the hardest worker. Absolutely crushed our ticket system metrics consistently. But could never get a promotion. At first it was just air excuses 'oh, Dave just deserved it this time.' and things that were maybe plausible. Then they got thin - guys with less experience who weren't very good and way under performing compared to her getting promotions? They just did better in the interview. She started to get pissed about it - as she was passed over for about a dozen different promotions opportunities when the majority of her peers in the tech pool agreed that she should have had the promotion - she worked her ass off. Then she got a reputation for being hard to work with and a complainer - because she had the temerity to be pissed about the blatant discrimination. Any guy who had to put up with that crap would have been just as hard to work with. My experience has certainly been that competent girls get fucked over in IT. And yeah, everyone in IT will be on the shitty end of a bad management decision if you hang around long enough. But almost every IT job I've had, and every competent girl I've worked with has had a laundry list of bullshit like that. When your job is diagnostic investigation and repair - you learn to start looking for linking factors and commonalities. You get good at root analysis. It's not hard for anyone who isn't an asshole to see that the crap women go through in enterprise IT, almost certainly has something to do with their gender.
- Zeus-TheTrueGod 15y agoWhy women don't create the own development companies ? This way they can not blame each other in "sexism" and other actions.
- Confusion 15y agoInterestingly, she assumes and reinforces the stereotypes herself: Just go and lob a few complaints about her behavior that would never apply to a guy. The easiest one of these is to say "you're being too emotional". This is plain false. Guys also catch flack for being too emotionally invested in something all the time. Someone proposes a solution, you criticise it and they get overly defensive? Someone reports on an issue and is really harsh about the person that caused it? Someone's performance goes subpar, but when confronted, they are afraid to tell you what's wrong? That's all emotion and they will all be called out for it by a decent manager. Here's what you do. After the meeting, you get her on chat and you say "wow, you were really hard on S". Here she again assumes guys never get this line from their manager, which is again plain false. Good managers will call guys out on internal rivalries, lack of empathy or whatever other emotional reason there was for 'being really hard on X'. These kinds of statements reinforce the stereotypes, because they reiterate the perceived status quo, where guys are non-emotional and thus never criticised for it. That whole line of reasoning is just wrong for anyone that wants to push for more equality. More equality does not mean showing women are more like the stereotypical men: it just as often means showing that men are more like stereotypical women.
- AndyKelley 15y agoAfter consuming this article, the update, and the comments here, this is the take on the situation I'm walking away with: 1. The manager was unjustified in saying that W was "too hard on S". 2. Based on the story in the article, it's not fair to say that the manager's unjustified statement was based on sexism. There isn't enough evidence to conclude that. 3. Rachel very well might have experienced sexism in the situation she wrote about and various other ones, and Rachel simply didn't explain it well enough in her article, or could only remember this ambiguous example where it's not entirely clear that there was sexism.
- msellout 15y agoFor those of you who believe that the incident described is not not one of sexism: the author's purpose is to describe an incident and explain to you that it is, in fact, sexism. Her goal is that you watch yourself more closely that you do not create an incident similar to the one she described. Whether or not the incident described was, in fact, sexism, it could have been and similar events should be avoided.
- wccrawford 15y agoAt my previous job, people would get mad at me for 'throwing someone under the bus' because I would simply tell the facts about a situation, and it ended up being that someone else screwed up. Apparently I was supposed to keep quiet and take all the wrath on myself instead. That's what's happening here. I'm male, she's female, and it happened exactly the same way. She's taken a common (and bull) occurrence and decided it's sexist, when it's not. It's just a bad situation, possibly with a bad company. What they're really telling her is that she should have taken one for the team, and they would have expected any other team member to do the same. She actually succeeded in her 'show no emotion' gambit, but had no idea she had done so. I actually agree with her that women are accused of being emotional more than men are, and it's due to stereotypes. And I agree with comments here that say men are just as emotional about their work. I certainly am. But the problem isn't that women are told they are too emotional. It's that mean are -not- told that. And they need to be.
- cafard 15y agoAt best, I'd say that there must be some context missing.
- blangblang 15y agoReplacing all forms of "woman" with the appropriate form of "employee" and neutering pronouns doesn't seem to change the story at all.