4 ms·
One demonstration from 1999 narrated by Yeager appears to show an early concept of cloud computing, in which a user could access online applications or "apps" t
by barrkel 15y ago
One demonstration from 1999 narrated by Yeager appears to show an early concept of cloud computing, in which a user could access online applications or "apps" through an Enron network
A user accessing applications via a network is an innovation in 1999? Try 30 years earlier with Telnet, and probably many other examples.
And yet another presentation from 2000 includes a demonstration of an on-demand movie service similar to those available on most cable TV systems today
The Wikipedia article on VoD cites existing commercial services already having launched in 1998.
I don't doubt that there were a lot of smart people at Enron; but whether they were ultimately producing value is in doubt. These examples don't seem to provide much evidence.
- tptacek 15y agoI guess I take your point, but "cloud computing" today is very much not the same thing as "cloud computing" in '00. To build a streaming testbed network in '00, we had to buy physical colocations in data centers around the world, and we were a tiny company. Everything has precedent in something else, but that doesn't make everything a CICS mainframe.
- Retric 15y agoSure, but the super computer crowd had long separated most of the physical hardware and even data center that something runs on in 00. Compared to that even EC2 is still a crappy service that forces you to micromanage things. There are plenty of awesome services are built on top of EC2, but 'modern' cloud computing infrastructure still sucks from both a cost and stability standpoint.
- tptacek 15y agoI'm just saying "cloud computing" connotes something more than just having servers attached to networks.
- Retric 15y agoI am referring to automated billing of arbitrary computing resources based on usage from a large pool spanning several computer architectures and computing locations. Now it's not LINUX boxes, but that's because they focused more on latency and bandwidth than 'modern' cloud system providers do.
- barrkel 15y agoI understand what you're saying, but I don't think you're suggesting that Enron had 2011-style cloud computing in 2000.
- tptacek 15y agoI'm suggesting that's what he's talking about when he says "cloud computing". I have no idea what they actually had working.
- mmahemoff 15y agoTrue, this was hardly revolutionary in 1999. The difference today is apps can be used by consumers and SMBs via the public internet, because most of them now have fast, always-on, connections. But in 1999, enterprises could already use apps on their intranets; Enron was not alone here. (And what's up with "apps" in quote marks? Online applications would do fine, it's not like Enron invented the App Store!)