3 ms·
You're heavily speculating about a person, just to write - essentially - a fictional story you happen to like. Your comment is ageist, nothing else.
by Tomte 4y ago
You're heavily speculating about a person, just to write - essentially - a fictional story you happen to like. Your comment is ageist, nothing else.
- brudgers 4y agoThat's the kind of comment stories like this attract.
- dekken_ 4y ago> Your comment is ageist, nothing else. False, this is your opinion, they were careful not to state what is, but what might be the case.
- faeriechangling 4y agoI mean it’s literally true the comment is ageist, it’s transparently and shamelessly ageist.
- logicalmonster 4y agoHow many news stories from ArsTechnica even mention the subject's age in the first place? Can you please let me know specifically what about my comment was ageist, and specifically shamelessly so? I think I was very reasonable and respectful and clearly indicated that my post was speculation. Thanks Faerie. PS: As an aside, to be very pedantic, the word ageist is a subjective term, not objective. You can say that 2+2=4 is literally true, but can you fairly say that anything is literally ageist when that's subjective? Just something to noodle over about what that word even means.
- faeriechangling 4y agoAgeisms definition if we search “define ageism” is prejudice or discrimination based on age. Saying a 5 year old would be a bad theoretical physicist or that a 90 year old would make a bad NFL linebacker both would constitute prejudices based on age by the strictest definition. Your respectfulness or lack thereof is almost totally irrelevant to if your post is ageist. I don’t see “ageism” as a very useful word anyways since my attempt to narrow the definition makes it painfully subjective.
- logicalmonster 4y ago> Saying a 5 year old would be a bad theoretical physicist or that a 90 year old would make a bad NFL linebacker both would constitute prejudices based on age the way I see it. It seems like most people would agree with your examples. Do you view this sort of ageism filter as a useful tool for understanding the world? Does the word ageism automatically imply a negative connotation then?
- cm2012 4y agoIt's fine to be ageist against someone who is 84 years old. There are severe cognitive declines that almost no one avoids at that age. It is irresponsible to hire an 84 year old for any important job.
- logicalmonster 4y ago> It's fine to be ageist against someone who is 84 years old. There are severe cognitive declines that almost no one avoids at that age. It is irresponsible to hire an 84 year old for any important job. Would you turn down getting lectures from Donald Knuth even if he's older than dirt? Using age as one tool to understand a complicated world with incomplete information seems fair, but I think you have to judge the individual on their own merits and abilities or you can miss out.
- xdavidliu 4y ago> Would you turn down getting lectures from Donald Knuth even if he's older than dirt? There's a difference between giving lunchtime lectures and teaching an entire course while assigning grades that affect the careers of young people.
- P5fRxh5kUvp2th 4y agoKnuth was the first thing that popped into my head, thanks for posting this so I didn't have to.
- coffeeblack 4y ago“almost no one” You managed to contradict yourself within the same sentence.