3 ms·
The Battle for the Soul of the Web: DWeb vs. Web3
- Comevius 4y agoAll kinds of unfettered, capitalist, libertarian networks whether they are centralized or decentralized sooner or later end up being owned and controlled by a handful of oligarchs. The solution to empowering individuals is accountability. We should be given tools that let us keep each other in check. Checks and balances are the basis of democracy itself. The web should be governed, with a constitution and a set of evolving laws commissioned by an educated, well-informed citizenry. Decentralized networks are the very definition of muddied, lawless waters that are only capable of serving an oligarchy. Libertarians tend to think that lawlessness equals individual liberty, but they are sorely mistaken, because oligarchy is tyranny, even when it's dressed as a free market economy or today's web, both are controlled by a handful of companies that blindly chase their short-term interests throwing you, your rights and your future under the bus. The bottom line is that we need a system that incentivizes people to plant trees under whose shade they will never sit. That's the soul of a democracy, and that's how you build the future of the web, not by bringing it back to lawlessness. Despite what nostalgia tells you the 90's web sucked too, only people with a specific background, education, and middle-upper income were truly a part of it. The hacker culture back then was really just a bunch of rich kids playing with their expensive toys. The same people later went on to create our beloved tech companies, which explains a lot. I also think that most decentralized projects exist not for their touted merits, but because the rest of the market is saturated. Amazon and it's cohorts already own everything, so now we have a bunch of venture capitalists drooling for a new space to exploit, but they have to exploit it fast and hard because most decentralized projects are unable to provide any actual value. You can only woe people for so long with promises, except if you manage to create a religion, which is definitely one of the goals here. Tap into those post 2008 fears and lack of trust, the inequality, climate change and all the misery and play people like the fiddle. Worked for the conservatives and libertarians like a charm, granted they worked hard on destroying our institutions so they can claim that they are not working. Oldest trick in the book.
- dangerface 4y ago> The solution to empowering individuals is accountability. We should be given tools that let us keep each other in check. Funny the commies had the same solution for their starving population.
- Comevius 4y agoLiterally every organized society does this. A policeman or a tax auditor literally have power over you right now. The devil however is in the balances. The difference between the commies and their oligarchic hellscape and a democracy is that in a democracy you are not lorded over by party functionaires like a medieval peasant. The kind of checks and balances I'm talking about is heavy on the balances.
- dangerface 4y ago> in a democracy you are not lorded over by party functionaires Every democracy in the world is ruled by party politics, left right, blue green these are parties not policies. Politicians all go to the same private school thats heavily financed by their party. The term checks and balances is a very American thing no other democracy has it and America is not even a democracy its a republic. For example the only check and balance on the UK parliament is the unelected house of lords who get their place because they are born into an oligarchy, besides that the only other check is the crown.
- Comevius 4y agoChecks and balances are about the concentration of power, it's not just an American thing. The separation of powers is a closely related concept. Never said that the United States was a democracy, although it is both a democracy and a republic, although the difference between these is specific to the country due to a historic compromise. As far as the state of that democracy goes the United States is considered a flawed democracy. I think that's generous considering how much influence billionaire oligarchs wield in the country, how large inequality is, and given the lack of educated, well-informed citizenry with the media being controlled by said oligarchs and education is being held back for political purposes, so that the people are easier to control.