2 ms·
>closed firmware seems not nearly as bad for libre/open software as closed drivers If I take my highly complex, proprietary driver, put it in a little ARM chip
by wongarsu 4y ago
>closed firmware seems not nearly as bad for libre/open software as closed drivers
If I take my highly complex, proprietary driver, put it in a little ARM chip in my device, and provide a dumb and simple driver that interfaces with that chip instead, is anything won? Sure, the proprietary code is out of sight and out of mind, but it's still there and you still can't modify and improve it.
- Laaas 4y agoDepending on the design of the hardware, you can limit its capabilities and e.g. prevent it from doing arbitrary read/write on RAM. https://www.pine64.org/2020/01/24/setting-the-record-straight-pinephone-misconceptions/ https://www.pine64.org/2020/01/24/setting-the-record-straigh...
- mindslight 4y agoYes, that's called a "peripheral" and there are many of them. From a software freedom and security perspective, a peripheral that gets its firmware loaded by a Free host is basically the same [0] as a peripheral that has its firmware stored in flash. The FSF chose an ultimately weird stance based on a copyright perspective [1], but it's time to move forward. In an ideal world, all peripherals (all devices) would also be running Free software. But we're not in that world, so we've got to eek out the Free domains we can, and isolate the non-free parts through well defined interfaces ... and additionally in this world of assumed ubiquitous connectivity, by denying them unfettered Internet access. [0] Flash is actually worse if you're sharing that peripheral with an untrustable host, since the firmware can be changed without your consent, or frozen against your desires. Whereas loading a stateless peripheral from the host chooses the specific firmware image every time. [1] It's cool to be able to definitively say "this whole installation image is redistributable purely under Free licenses", but I'd say it's not the most important thing for user empowerment.