3 ms·
You don't "trust" science, it is even the entire point of science to be distrustful: To be ever skeptical of and verify any claims, and always be on the lookout
by Dalewyn 4y ago
You don't "trust" science, it is even the entire point of science to be distrustful: To be ever skeptical of and verify any claims, and always be on the lookout for better theories and findings.
If you "trust" science, you're just being religious. The people who don't just immediately take the words of the CDC or WHO at face value are more scientific than the people who do.
- jfengel 4y agoParanoia is not science. Skepticism is not the same as paranoia. Science is full of trust. Science is rarely replicated from first principles. There just isn't time. The further away one gets from one's own field, the more one relies on the experts in that field. People who mistrust the CDC and WHO, but accept anything about physics, chemistry, or anything else that isn't their specific area of research, aren't being "skeptical". They're just being ideologically biased, affirming their preconceptions without applying that same skepticism to the theories that support their ideologies. The overwhelming number of virologists, epidemiologists, doctors, and public health experts listen to what the CDC and WHO says because they do know what they're talking about. And they listen as the information changes, because they change their minds when the data available changes. What do you do?
- Dalewyn 4y ago>What do you do? I take their words with a grain of salt just like with anyone else. Blind trust in science is no different from religious worship.
- Certhas 4y agoWho said the trust is blind? It is utterly impossible to "think for yourself" when it comes to modern science. To fully understand the thinking and evidence that goes into some of these statements might take decades. You should trust it because all parts of the chain of arguments are being critically looked at by experts all the time. If you distrust scientists just like you distrust priests, it is your blind distrust that's deeply irrational (under the guise of rationality no less).
- peteradio 4y agoIt's quite straightforward to trust Physics and Chemistry that delivers verifiable product. It's another thing to trust Sociology and Medicine with a track record of deceit, hubris and strong political coupling.
- jfengel 4y agoSociology, maybe. Medicine, certainly not. Relevant XKCD: https://xkcd.com/1520/ https://xkcd.com/1520/ Medicine is demonstrably saving lives year on year. Some plagues have been entirely eliminated; for others we're on the verge of stamping them out. Medicine is a more complex science than physics or chemistry, with more variables leading to more room for errors. But nobody seemed to think medicine was political until it coincided with a political ideology that happened to have a penchant for declaring sciences "political" whenever they didn't want to accept them.
- peteradio 4y agoThe practice of national medicine necessarily becomes a cross of the disciplines Sociology and Medicine. I don't doubt medicines complexity or its ability but its not acting alone here. You are not prescribing well tested vaccines in a vacuum, you are best guessing and ramrodding via the sociological practice of "nudge".