2 ms·
> Looking around in the EU There's your problem. Europe doesn't generalize, and that's my entire point. Nowhere does. Europe benefits from warm winds. Often Lo
by godelski 4y ago
> Looking around in the EU
There's your problem. Europe doesn't generalize, and that's my entire point. Nowhere does. Europe benefits from warm winds. Often London is warmer than NYC despite being the significantly further north. The benefit here is lots of wind and far milder climates. It is the reason Europeans frequently don't have air conditioning (changing) but most Americans do. The US is warmer on average but also, generally, has larger seasonal swings in temperature. Hydro power is also notoriously non-homogeneous (especially considering environmental factor). For example, a significant part of the US (the part almost no one lives in) is a giant desert.
> Countries that push more heavily for nuclear seem to neglect renewables and countries investing in renewables often care little for expanding nuclear.
Can you give an example of such a country? France is one of the lowest emitters in Europe (even with current issues). France and Sweden draw significant amounts of power from hydro and nuclear. France, currently, is getting ~100gCo2eq/kWhr (and previously was <30) while Germany is 210. Britain is 180, Spain is 230, Portugal is 330, Italy is >300, and Poland is >500. If your concern is with France I believe you need to get your priorities straight. The majority of Europe emits multiples of times that of France and it has been this way for decades. So I'm not sure why you feel you need to pick on them. When the other countries are producing less (or even in the same ballpark) then we can talk.
My entire argument is that this heterogeneity makes the problem of choosing the right power source rather difficult. You can't just look up average (or median) prices and apply them unilaterally. Doing so comes off as extremely naive because, again, first order thinking is not helpful here. Complex problems require complex solutions.
And I need to make this absolutely and abundantly clear: I AM NOT SAYING NUCLEAR EVERYWHERE. I explicitly said we should build as much renewable as possible. I will not be upset if the total amount of nuclear power, globally, is zero. If you believe anything less, I think you gravely misread my comment. I think you may have missed this point and confused my being okay with nuclear as being a nuclear bro. So there really isn't much to argue with here (besides calling the kettle black) because I'm not nuclear gung-ho. Forgive me, but it is often frustrating that when I make the slightest argument in favor of nuclear I get responses as if I proposed a nuclear vs renewables argument. Again, I explicitly stated that this is not the case.
- pfdietz 4y agoNuclear is not a solution. You can't power energy-intensive industry with it; you'll be outcompeted by some other country where solar is cheap.
- godelski 4y agoWould you mind reading what I've said instead of assuming a position? We have a good faith rule on HN and you're violating it.
- cycomanic 4y agoI don't understand your argument. The EU is significantly smaller than the US and the US has much more climate variation across its area. Moreover integrating the EU energy grids is more difficult considering they are separate countries. Still it's happening and not due to government policies, but because it is good investment to connect e.g. Norway to Germany. In the US it could be much easier to build an integrated grid. There have been many simulations that showed one could fulfil the US electricity needs based on renewables and overprovisioning alone. Any storage makes it actually cheaper.
- godelski 4y agoI don't understand your argument tbh. Europe is roughly the same size as the US and is about twice as dense. The density means that power demand is significantly higher and you need more frequent generators. The increased sparsity and climate variation of the US makes it more difficult to build a grid all together. But both the US and EU have interconnected grids so I'm not sure what you're saying here. No one was arguing against interconnected grids. I was arguing that you don't want to generate power in California and use that power in Maine. Maybe that's the issue? While this is possible, you not only are losing a lot of power in transit, Maine would be at serious risk for power outages. Both distance and climate variation play a role here as both these factors make it easier for a grid to go down. Let's say there is a 1% chance of outage per 100 miles of grid. Well you got about 2500 miles to cross. Also, the US is federated. I'm not sure if the politics make it any easier than in Europe. In our example Maine is beholden to at least 10 states. If something happens you know those states are demanding they get power first. The federal government (president) isn't just a dictator who can make the states act uniformly and in the best interest of the country as a whole. It's really best to think of the US as somewhere between a country and the EU itself. It was set up to be more like the EU in the first place but power has consolidated over time.