6 ms·
Paul Krugman wins economics Nobel prize
- JoelSutherland 18y agoI had the opportunity to hear Krugman speak in 2004 before the election. What I found surprising was how much he seemed to value his column. It certainly seemed like he thought it was much more important than his academic work.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- j2d2 18y agoHe has a far larger audience via his column.
- walterk 18y agoI think it's extremely important to have academics in constant communication with the public. Keeps them grounded and their language plain, while the public can continue to engage with academics long after they've graduated.
- Prrometheus 18y agoI can't find any fault in Krugman's academic work. I haven't read it, though it sounds fascinating. He is held in high regard in the academy, and I believe he is as talented as other people say he is. His NY Times column, however, I feel fit to judge as shrill, unimaginative, vanilla leftism. I'm sure he understands all the criticisms that other economists would level at the policies he supports. The flaws are glaring. Now, it is perfectly honest to acknowledge the existence of those flaws and argue that the benefits of the policy outweigh the drawbacks. However, it is not honest to pretend that such criticisms do not exist. I could read similar opinion pieces from any leftist without a PHD after his name. The point of reading someone so lettered is that his opinions should be well-argued and therefore interesting, even if you disagree with him. That is rarely the case with Krugman. I have no doubt that his work in economics will be remembered 50 years from now, and his columns will be long forgot.
- chaostheory 18y ago1) He didn't win a Nobel prize; it's actually the Sveriges Riksbank Prize http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nobel_Prize_in_Economics#Relation_to_the_Nobel_Prize http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nobel_Prize_in_Economics#Relati... 2) As someone who advocated the flawed (and now admittedly failed) bailout scam, I'd have to question this
- marvin 18y agoWe don't know whether the bailout plan has failed yet. Calling it a scam is certainly premature.
- chaostheory 18y agoNot really. I call it a scam because it's not limited to just 700 billion. It's an unlimited raid on the treasury, and even the modified plan still doesn't have enough transparency. It gives the executive branch even more power. To me this is just politics, since the prize was awarded by one of the central banks to someone strongly advocating their policies...
- mynameishere 18y agoIf it works, it's still a scam.
- zandorg 18y agoAlso, there is no Maths Nobel. The closest thing is Economics, which is what John Nash won.
- echair 18y agoThe closest thing is the Fields medal.
- nostrademons 18y agoFields is structured differently than the Nobel prizes though - only once every 4 years, and only to mathematicians [edit: not] over 40.
- larryfreeman 18y agoI have long admired Krugman's analysis. I haven't read his academic work on economics of scale but if it is of the same quality as his articles, the nobel prize is well deserved.
- nostrademons 18y agoIt's funny, I remember someone saying "If Paul Krugman hadn't started spewing about politics in the NY Times, he probably would've won the Nobel Prize." Looks like he won it anyway...
- anamax 18y agoSince some of the folks who decide the Nobel winners have been quoted that other decisions were made as a "kick in the leg" at the Bush administration, Krugman's political columns probably helped him.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoLeft-leaning columnist and economist wins Nobel? Doesn't seem very surprising to me given the history of the Nobel committee in the soft sciences and humanities. It will be interesting to see how history views Krugman's accomplishments. I know some of their laureates, like Arafat, didn't hold up so well.
- ajross 18y agoKrugman is much, much more than a liberal columnist. He got the column because, unlike most pundits, he has a long track record of interesting work in his field, and, unlike most eggheads, a knack for and interest in explaining those issues to the public. If you're reading him only via links from redstate.com or whatever, you're very much missing the point. And when did Yasir Arafat win the Nobel prize in Economics? You do realize that the selection committees are entirely different organizations, right? Must everything be a political swipe at conservatives? Isn't it possible that every once in a while one of those lib'ruls might actually produce something useful and be rewarded for it?
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoJust waitin' on history to tell. You can return to your ranting now.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoOr you can take out your frustration by modding me down. Look. Here's another one for you.
- davidw 18y agoWhy are we talking about leftists and economics and stuff in this thread? Oh, right - it's completely off topic argument bait. Here's a libertarian economist on some of Krugman's work: http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2008/10/pauls_nobel_nic.html http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2008/10/pauls_nobel_nic.... As a non-economist, one of the ways that I look at their work is to observe when they go 'against the grain' politically: when the left-wing ones argue for free markets, and when the right wing ones argue for intervention.
- mingyeow 18y agoi love paul krugman. completely logical , insightful, and comprehendable
- michael_nielsen 18y agoTo those people wondering about the influence of politics on Krugman's prize: (1) Krugman won the John Bates Clark Medal for economics in 1991. This is a Prize given every two years to an American Economist under 40. It's often considered harder to win than the economics Nobel, and is a significant predictor of who actually will win the Nobel. Note that this was largely before Krugman got involved in politics, and past winners include Milton Friedman. I doubt his politics helped him win this one. (2) By most measures of citation impact, Krugman is one of the world's leading economists. E.g., http://ideas.repec.org/top/top.person.nbcites.html http://ideas.repec.org/top/top.person.nbcites.html Citations are, of course, an imperfect predictor of the significance of someone's work, this is just an additional data point. I doubt his involvement in US politics had much impact on the prize.
- aneesh 18y agoHis involvement in politics is largely limited to the past several years. His main contributions to economics, arguably, have come far before that. He's the author of the foremost textbook on international trade (Krugman+Obstfield), and developed models of international trade that every economics major knows (or should, at least).
- rcoder 18y agoAnyone here who hasn't read Krugman's paper on the economics of interstellar trade owes it to themselves to do so: http://www.princeton.edu/~pkrugman/interstellar.pdf http://www.princeton.edu/~pkrugman/interstellar.pdf I've never laughed so hard that coffee went up my nose while reading an econ paper prior to coming across this one. (Okay, and maybe the first version of the Paulson bailout, but that was a very different sort of laughter.)
- antiform 18y agoThis is GOLD. "First Fundamental Theorem of Interstellar Trade: When trade takes place between two planets in a common inertial frame, the interest costs on goods in transit should be calculated using time measured by clocks in the common frame, and not by clocks in the frames of trading spacecraft." and the final line for the kicker: "Those of us working in this field are still a small band, but we know that the Force is with us."
- alaskamiller 18y agoI find it despicable that people are burning other people's karma for simply voicing their opinions on a freakin' message board.
- aswanson 18y ago"I can forgive Alfred Nobel for having invented dynamite, but only a fiend in human form could have invented the Nobel Prize."
- startingup 18y agoThere is a different strand of criticism of Krugman (and the neo-Keynesians in general) that is quite apart from his politics. At some level, this is a criticism of the modern economic profession itself, and its worship of mathematical models. This is conceptually analogous to but quite distinct from the Wall Street addiction to quantitative/stochastic modeling, which is behind much of the present mess. Krugman represents the pinnacle of that mathematical tradition. To be fair, Milton Friedman, ideologically the polar opposite of Krugman, has also faced similar criticism.
- mhartl 18y agoIf you've followed Krugman for long, you've seen this coming for quite a while. The possibility of his winning an economics Nobel have been rumored for years. The interesting thing to me is that, when reading his columns, I often get the sense that Krugman doesn't really believe in economics. He talks a good economics talk, but he hasn't internalized its lessons. He's like a brilliant Christian apologist who doesn't believe in Christ.
- mhartl 18y agos/have been/has been