6 ms·
"Background scanning" sounds more nefarious than what's probably really going on -- which is probably either generating thumbnail previews (for Finder) or index
by crazygringo 4y ago
"Background scanning" sounds more nefarious than what's probably really going on -- which is probably either generating thumbnail previews (for Finder) or indexing (for Spotlight), both of which are desired. Or maybe malware scanning to put files in quarantine if they point to dangerous content? macOS is also becoming more intelligent about text in images, e.g. it OCR's images so you can select text. I don't know if it indexes text in images for Spotlight the way Google has already done in Drive for years.
But I wouldn't be surprised if it fetches URL's in QR codes in order to index the title text associated with the URL for Spotlight. It's not so different from when you text someone a URL in Messages, it automatically shows a title and thumbnail to both parties. Or, if it's just a shared "preview" library used across thumbnails and iMessage.
I'm not sure what to think about it. Previews, smart text, showing URL information on hover, prefetching, indexing, etc. -- it's all pretty standard stuff. On the other hand, it does feel a little weird for previews on a local filesystem to query the internet -- we're totally used to it in e-mail and messaging though. But, I used to keep bookmarks as URL (.url) files. It would seem natural for a thumbnail of the page to show up in Finder (though I don't think it does this?).
As for it being an "attack" to get someone's IP -- seems like that ship has long since sailed, as it's common for any messaging and e-mail client to already show previews. If you need to protect yourself against all of those, you pretty much need to figure out what level of Little Snitch or turning off internet or airgapping is required for your security concerns.
- smoldesu 4y agoI feel like there are better ways to do this, to the point that this 'feature' actually looks really out-of-place. Why wouldn't you get these thumbnail previews when you actually scan the QR Code? You're going to be fetching/caching the favicon and framebuffer for the page anyways, there's literally no reason not to get that data at runtime rather than 3 hours later. It's not exactly malicious, but weird "we know better than you" behavior like this ultimately drove me away from MacOS as a daily-driver.
- grooot 4y agoThere is absolutely nothing malicious that has been shown.
- vorpalhex 4y agoScanning your images and followong links in them without user consent is pretty malicious.
- grooot 4y agoWhat are you talking about? It sounds like you don’t understand what is going on here. Perhaps you think some data is going to Apple?
- vorpalhex 4y agoHaving read the article I entirely understand what is going on here. Do you expect your images to be scanned on disk and the links in them to be opened, leaking your ip? What if you do something as simple as screenshot an address bar in a browser? Save a menu QR code? Now you are sending out traffic, accidentally, with your full ip to random places due to a service Apple inserted that you have no knowledge of.
- grooot 4y agoDo you seriously believe that your IP is private? Do you know every site that has received your ip address? I think the honest answer to both of these questions has to be no.
- _justinfunk 4y agoI think the idea is that it is a way for your IP address to leak without a user-initiated request. I could send you a QR code that I've setup specifically to get your IP address.
- 4y ago
- LeifCarrotson 4y ago> Why wouldn't you get these thumbnail previews when you actually scan the QR Code? These aren't scanned, they're located inside .png image files you can download or generate locally on your computer. > You're going to be fetching/caching the favicon and framebuffer for the page anyways, there's literally no reason not to get that data at runtime rather than 3 hours later. No one asked the OS to fetch the favicon/framebuffer. Also, I would prefer the favicon of an image containing a QR code to be a thumbnail of the QR code, not the page it points to. I expect this delay is not a nefarious Little Snitch bypassing tool but a search cache update process that only runs when the computer is very idle. Better to run background tasks lazily than every time you commit an image that might contain a QR code to the filesystem.
- smoldesu 4y agoThat's definitely a more sane analysis of the situation, thank you for your two cents. In general, these things frustrate me just as much as they did on Windows. I don't want random processes jumping up to use 100% of my CPU for no reason. I can't even count the number of times my Mac gets pinned by mdworker processes running in the background. It's reminiscent of pulling my hair out trying to understand why OneDrive or Edge is pinning one of my cores even though it isn't open. My overall gripe is this pattern of behavior. I'd rather spend 2-5 seconds waiting for my QR code to load instead of my OS deciding to randomly cache it at some indeterminate point. Maybe other people disagree, though. Us HN users don't really tend to reflect the opinions of Joe Shmoe and his feelings towards modern computing.
- fishywang 4y ago>It's not so different from when you text someone a URL in Messages, it automatically shows a title and thumbnail to both parties. And that's how the pegasus/etc. pwned iPhones
- grooot 4y agoIt was before the zero day was closed.
- fishywang 4y agoso you are saying apple is doing something they already knew is a bad idea?
- grooot 4y agoNo. I’m saying your information is outdated and wrong.
- fishywang 4y agohow can you be so confident that it's "closed"? the last time apple announced the high protection mode for state sponsored targets in new ios (whatever it's called), they disable all auto previews in that mode. if they are as confident as you are that it's "closed" that doesn't seem necessary?
- nixpulvis 4y agoAutomatic link following is pretty bad, nefarious or not. Intent is kinda beside the point of issue here; it's not like we're trying to sue Apple... Or maybe we should group up a massive list of poor decisions into a formal complaint?
- rcarmo 4y agoRegardless, theis shouldn't happen. Indexing the URL, fine. Fetching it is a very poor idea and a can of worms.
- michaelcampbell 4y ago> which is probably either generating thumbnail previews (for Finder) or indexing (for Spotlight) Neither of which require, nor to be honest even makes any sense to, go to the URL that the QR code represents.
- divbzero 4y agoOP reached a similar conclusion farther down in the Twitter thread: facebookexternalhit/1.1 Facebot Twitterbot/1.0 What. "This is the iMessages app's crawler [...] Apple has chosen to use this useragent in their iMessages app to ensure the unfurling of the URL and the rich preview works more often than not."² ² https://webmasters.stackexchange.com/a/138992 https://webmasters.stackexchange.com/a/138992