4 ms·
The EU member states used to be in near constant war for centuries, starting two world wars in the process. Economic entanglement was one of the major factors t
by wongarsu 4y ago
The EU member states used to be in near constant war for centuries, starting two world wars in the process. Economic entanglement was one of the major factors that finally lead to a lasting peace. Applying the same concept to Russia was reasonable.
With another Russian leader it might have worked. But Putin, for whatever reason, chose potential glory over economic prosperity. A move so foreign to European democracies that we refused to see it coming.
- ChuckNorris89 4y ago>Economic entanglement was one of the major factors that finally lead to a lasting peace. There couldn't possibly be anything more false. This horse has been beaten to death already and should just be let to die. European countries had entangled economies and were still going to war with each other. France and Germany were each other's biggest trading partners and that didn't stop them fighting each other in WW1 or WW2. The reason why we have had peace after WW2 is the implementation of fully fledged democracies with separation of powers in the major European leaderships along with US peacekeeping and the Marshal plan. Russia was not a democracy anymore after the 1993 coup since the president there could do whatever he wants without the parliament able to stop him and therefore should not have been trusted as a fair trading partner.
- throwaway894345 4y agoI'm not sure why this was downvoted, this is largely the right answer. The US has had troops all over the continent and the USSR was an external, existential threat against which they were united. People weren't worried about their stock portfolio, they were worried about the Soviet Union nuking their cities.
- hef19898 4y agoAgree with everything except the last sentence: that the Russian invasion failed so hard is partially due to the support Ukraine got since 2014 and still gets. For me, it was more like preparing for the worst while hoping for the best. Because who wouod have thought anyone would be stupid enough to lanch a major land war, in Europe, against a well prepared country that can easily be supplied by its allies, an invasion that was signaled light years in advance? So yeah, it was a surprise that it actually happened, and it hit a rather well prepared Ukraine.
- linuxftw 4y ago> Putin, for whatever reason, chose potential glory over economic prosperity. He stated his reasons. He believes there was a western-backed military coup in 2014. Ukraine failed to implement the Minsk agreements. Ukraine is attempting to join NATO. He believed an assault on the breakaway republics was imminent. He believes Ukraine is harboring literal Nazis, committing crimes against humanity against ethnic Russians. Those are more or less the stated reasons. IMO, Ukraine was a vassal state, much like Puerto Rico to the US. Maybe the relationship wasn't so formalized, but Russia viewed Ukraine as theirs one way or another. For some reason, people in the western world operate on some kind of technicality system, as if words on paper make a difference.
- throwaway894345 4y ago> For some reason, people in the western world operate on some kind of technicality system, as if words on paper make a difference. Yes, we call this "rule of law" and it works really well in the west.
- linuxftw 4y agoDoes it though? [1] We have pretend rule of law. We pretend the law matters, and we pretend to follow it. In any case, Putin argues that the war (or in his parlance, SMO) is legal under UN precedent in Yugoslavia, that a breakaway republic may be recognized even if the former nation dissents. IMO, this whole ordeal could have been avoided, but Western backed Ukraine decided it was better to fight than capitulate to Russia's demands. 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legality_of_the_Iraq_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legality_of_the_Iraq_War
- piva00 4y agoYou are probably well aware but this is exactly the lines being sold by the Kremlin. Ukraine, as we can see in reality, isn't Russia. Don't identify as Russia and has not been wanting to be part of Moscow-ruled territory for a few decades. How exactly could this whole ordeal been avoided? Letting Putin continue the dismantling of Ukraine through civil wars and separatist movements?
- throwaway894345 4y agoThis is the whole point--you can't bank on 'economic entanglement' with a dictatorship because the dictator may or may not care about the economy (beyond its ability to finance his war, anyway). Moreover, Europe continued to increase its economic exposure to Russia while Russia was publicly decreasing its exposure to the west (this has been Russian policy since the west sanctioned Russia for invading and annexing Crimea almost a decade ago). Even if you believe in "economic entanglement" (and I doubt it was as potent as NATO, etc), surely it only works if the dependency is mutual.