4 ms·
1. There's no extra money - poorer people just consume less. 2. Because companies just take all of the difference as extra revenue, and prefer to increase sala
by tsimionescu 4y ago
1. There's no extra money - poorer people just consume less.
2. Because companies just take all of the difference as extra revenue, and prefer to increase salaries (if not just keep everything as profit) rather than reducing prices.
Note that I'm not claiming that increased money supply doesn't cause inflation. It obviously does. I'm claiming it's not the only cause of inflation. It's sufficient, but not necessary for inflation to happen.
- JamesianP 4y agoIt's not so simple though since there's indirect effects that immediately follow. 1. Everyone consume less. Even rich people have to buy less of something else to pay for the higher-priced gas. So demand goes down elsewhere driving down other prices. 2. If margins or salaries increase then it increases the incentive for competition to enter the market and compete on price.
- tsimionescu 4y ago1. Rich people already have much more income than they consume, they would likely only reduce investments/savings. 2. It takes a very long time to create a new manufacturing business, and it's hard to know how gas prices will evolve in 2-5 years time (which is a decent conservative estimate on when you would be able to start selling your products if you start today).
- WalterBright 4y agoReducing investment/savings reduces demand, as they are the source of funds for businesses to spend. Reduced demand reduces prices. Any economic theory that denies the Law of Supply & Demand is false.
- tsimionescu 4y agoAgain, reducing demand only reduces prices if there is enough supply. If the demand already exceeded supply, then changes in demand don't do anything to price unless and until demand once again drops below supply. Not to mention, if you think companies use all their funds every year, you're again using a very bizarre economic model. Companies often accrue money as cash savings to be used at later dates, taking it out of the economy until then.
- magicalhippo 4y ago> So demand goes down elsewhere driving down other prices. Right, but given that those other things were non-essentials, it surely don't matter as much? I mean, you need food. You don't need a lap dance. So you stop spending money on lap dances, using it on food instead. Prices on lap dances go down. But you still need food, not lap dances, so the reduction in price for a lap dance doesn't make you suddenly start buying lap dances.
- JamesianP 4y agoStrippers need to eat too though. Maybe I missing your argument. Isn't the point of lowering one's lap dance prices to get more customers to buy them?
- tsimionescu 4y agoThat's the hope, but it doesn't mean it will happen. There is no law that says you'll find a price point that keeps your business afloat: changing economic conditions can just tank your business; the less critical the good or service is, the more likely it is to happen.
- JamesianP 4y agoOk. Now the stripper can't afford to buy food and there's less demand for essentials after all. I'm still not getting how this helps?
- tsimionescu 4y agoJust because the stripper can no longer afford food doesn't mean that food sellers will be able to lower their price. Supply issues can't be solved by price changes. Taken to the extreme, people will die of starvation until the population adjusts, so still in the long run demand and supply will meet at the price point.
- JamesianP 4y ago
- WalterBright 4y agoWhen people consume less, prices drop. Again, it's the Law of Supply & Demand. In physics, when momentum is not conserved, I don't have to work through the math to show it is wrong. I know it is wrong. When conservation of energy is denied, I know it is wrong. When someone claims a perpetual motion machine, I know it is wrong. Analogously, when a theory requires denial of the Law of Supply & Demand, I know it's wrong. This thread is chock full of weird economic theories of every description. The LoS&D is a wonderful tool to easily diagnose false economic theories.
- tsimionescu 4y ago> When people consume less, prices drop. Again, it's the Law of Supply & Demand. No, they don't: not if supply is inelastic. The law of supply and demand says that the price of a good will tend to the price at which supply meets demand. If supply has a maximum, so does demand: any change in theoretical demand above that max will do nothing to affect the price. If the entire economy produces 10 gallons of oil per day, the fact that today 100 people wanted 1 gallon each, while yesterday 1000 people wanted 1 gallon each, will do nothing to affect the price: I'm still only going to sell to the 10 highest bidders. Of course, if suddenly only 9 people are left using oil, I will indeed be forced to lower my price - but until then, lower demand will have no impact. You seem to be basing your opinions on some other "Law" of Supply and Demand that somehow claims that Supply will always rise to meet Demand. That "Law" is simply false, and you should discard it.