4 ms·
The IA has really lost its reputation as an archive by choosing to remove content down for political purposes. They see themselves as publishers rather than an
by Gigachad 4y ago
The IA has really lost its reputation as an archive by choosing to remove content down for political purposes. They see themselves as publishers rather than an archive.
- NavinF 4y agoWhat did they remove?
- violan 4y agoEvidence of unsavoury and most likely illegal behavior of a man with powerful friends in the tech industry. If you know the right people with the right political views, even the IA will capitulate.
- cormorant 4y agoI attempted to google to guess what you meant. I found: (1) they recently removed KiwiFarms; (2) in 2020, they began labeling certain pages with "fact checks"; (3) they remove content by request of the site owner or by copyright complaint. Of those, (2) seems the most political, but it's not removing content. Was there something else you had in mind?
- Dalewyn 4y ago(1) is egregious if the goal is an archive of the internet. An archive should have everything of what is being archived, legalese notwithstanding: The good, the bad, the beautiful, the ugly, everything. E v e r y t h i n g . If it doesn't have everything, it's not an archive.
- detaro 4y agoof course "not visible in the wayback machine" doesn't mean "they don't have it".
- Gigachad 4y agoRemoving kiwi farms was a bad decision. The copyright and site owner did not request it and the content was not illegal. So the IA is picking content to delist based on their own feelings rather than simply archiving.
- auveair 4y ago> the content was not illegal The content was clearly libelous and defamatory, which is pretty illegal. In some countries it would also count as harassement.
- ryeights 4y agoLibelous/defamatory content is not illegal in the same vein as pirated movies or CSAM, in that the Internet Archive would be criminally liable for hosting it. I wouldn’t imagine it’s illegal for IA to host a snapshot of a defamatory news article, for example.
- huffals 4y agoThe content was embarrassing and revealing for the people it concerned (hence efforts to remove it through any means necessary), but not libelous or defamatory - it consisted of archived material of their own words.
- bityard 4y ago> The content was clearly libelous and defamatory, which is pretty illegal. That is incorrect. In the US, the _act_ of libel is illegal and the author of it can get into legal trouble. And a publisher might if they knowingly published false information, which is harder to prove. But the libelous _content_ itself is not illegal and is in fact protected by the First Amendment.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoHad to look up what Kiwi Farm even is/was. > Supporters of the Drop Kiwi Farms campaign celebrated the Internet Archive’s decision. “Internet heroes right here,” tweeted Yonah Gerber, who urged the Archive to remove the site. Kiwi Farms is known for collecting and publicizing personal details about targets it holds in contempt, many of whom are transgender women like Sorrenti. While the site ostensibly discourages direct harassment, Sorrenti has faced swatting attacks and persistent threats during her campaign, and other targets have had similarly ugly experiences. Kiwi Farms has been allegedly linked with three suicides, including an emulator developer who blamed the site for a relentless harassment operation soon before their death. [1] Yeah, I have to say that I recognize nuance and am okay with archive.org nixing content like the above. [1] https://www.theverge.com/2022/9/7/23341051/kiwi-farms-internet-archive-backup-removal https://www.theverge.com/2022/9/7/23341051/kiwi-farms-intern...
- readsadhours 4y agoThey also remove legal pornographic content https://archive.org/post/1053748/porn-on-ia-wtf https://archive.org/post/1053748/porn-on-ia-wtf https://archive.org/post/1123868/no-bdsm-allowed https://archive.org/post/1123868/no-bdsm-allowed I think that puritanism and archivism are not compatible. They also removed ISIS stuff https://archive.org/post/1033012/constant-removal-of-isis-videos-and-publications-from-internet-archive https://archive.org/post/1033012/constant-removal-of-isis-vi... Removing evidence of war-crimes and disallowing future historians from accessing such content in the future is not a policy that I would expect from an archive.