4 ms·
I absolutely agree. However at least here in Norway, I think we spend too much of the time focusing on useless details. For example, non-trivial part of our No
by magicalhippo 4y ago
I absolutely agree.
However at least here in Norway, I think we spend too much of the time focusing on useless details. For example, non-trivial part of our Norwegian classes was filled with language history, like the art periods and when various authors lived and so on.
I get that it's nice to know a bit about this, to be able to place them in roughly the right period, but giving a 14 year old a "wrong answer" on a test because the kid doesn't know the exact year some author was born, or failing to list all the authors in some romantic-period clique, is frankly stupid.
Meanwhile, far to little time was devoted to practical writing. Like, say, an email. We spent just a few hours writing reports and similar non-prose, compared to several semesters full of language history, learning about the romanticism and realism periods etc.
I see so many of my colleagues and customers who couldn't write a coherent email if their life depended on it, and can't help but wonder if some of that history time at school had been better spent on practical matters. If a kid wanted to really study language history, they can very well learn this later.
- arolihas 4y agoDo your colleagues and customers still grasp the finer points of language history? Even if school spent more time on how to write basic emails, I'd suspect it still wouldn't sink in for many children because many of them wouldn't care to apply it. It should only take a couple hours for an educated adult to learn how to write a coherent paragraph. If your coworkers still can't be bothered, then I don't see how forced education would help anyway.
- magicalhippo 4y agoFair enough, but language history certainly didn't make them any better at it. And memorizing details can be a lot harder and thus more demotivating. It surely can't get much worse if they actually tried teaching kids to write better non-prose.
- arolihas 4y agoI'm not familiar with the Norwegian education system but didn't you have classes that required writing essays or at least short answers? If kids go through over a decade of schooling and still cannot write a coherent message well into adulthood, something is fundamentally flawed.
- magicalhippo 4y agoSure, but I think non-prose is different enough that it's worth spending more time on it. We did have a bit of it, but pretty insignificant compared to the rest. When I got to high school, nobody in my class could write a half-way decent report for example. Just the basics of what a report even was and what it was supposed to contain. I got the equivalent of a D and the teacher said I had done "by far the best in class", the rest got F's and NR. None of us in class had come from the same junior high schools, so wasn't that. Most of my colleagues seem to have no issue telling a story, but many seem to have problems forming a coherent argument, or asking a non-confusing question, in writing. Again, don't think it would have hurt to have more non-prose experience in the basic education.