3 ms·
Refining critical thing and awareness of the world only seems necessary due to deficiencies in the public education system. High school is a joke and we should
by Retric 4y ago
Refining critical thing and awareness of the world only seems necessary due to deficiencies in the public education system. High school is a joke and we should fix that rather than suggest everyone needs to get a collage degree.
- guhidalg 4y agoI've had this thought before, that high school should be good enough to not require higher education. However I think as I've grown older I recognize that public education in the US primarily serves as day care and secondarily as an education. This is why schools have gifted programs, some students are there to learn and they are encouraged to go as far as they can, but some students are just there because its compulsory. I don't have a solution, just an observation.
- thrown_22 4y ago
- bradlys 4y agoYes - it is a daycare. However - maybe we improve it from a daycare to a place of learning. That’s why we could make high school more intensive and less daycare like.
- guhidalg 4y agoI agree with the intent, but I don't believe simply improving schools (what does that even mean? higher teacher salaries? higher standards? more funding?) will improve overall societal education. Where I grew up (Georgia, USA), there were several incentives to doing well in school: - Your driver's license was revoked if had too many unexcused absences - State scholarships were only available above a certain GPA - The state academic summer camp program was only available if you were selected by your teachers based on your performance Only one of these incentives applied to the general population, the rest only applied to motivated college-bound students. I believe we should have more incentives for all students to learn in school that affect the students instead of the school. If you punish the schools for the student's performance, you'll get the current US education system. Some ideas: - Performance-based tuition or school lunch prices: The range cannot be too high or people will, rightly, complain that this negatively affects poor people. Make it something small but symbolic. - A personalized excise tax on parents based on the child's school performance. Again, don't make it too large, just large enough. - Reintroduce recess and socialization opportunities for students during school based on performance. If people start skipping, suspend their driver's license.
- BizarroLand 4y agoHonestly, American Grades 10-12 are a waste. Sure, you learn some important fundamentals for college but outside of that meh. At least in my experience I would have far preferred being able to jump straight into college and have gotten the first 2 or so years out of the way in lieu of whatever passes for high school education. I would be far ahead of where I am and have benefited much more from the opportunity, but today you can only do such a thing by getting your GED (with parental permission) and being an incredibly driven and self-promoting autodidact with a lot of parental support. It's a farce.
- sethammons 4y agoCounter point, i found those grades as great prep for college. I took mostly AP courses. I was able to test into Calculus 3 at my university and found university to be quite easy. Grades 4, 5, and 6 were a waste. Literally the same content for three years that could have been covered in half a term. We need better self-paced systems.
- barry-cotter 4y ago> High school is a joke and we should fix that rather than suggest everyone needs to get a college degree. If the school leaving age has been raised to 18 you need to have something for everyone up to the age of 18 to do, or at least 90% of the people. There are a lot of people who are capable of passing a test for the bottom quintile of 18 year olds at 14. Quality, rigour, universality, uniformity. Choose.
- Retric 4y agoMany systems have multiple paths for a high school equivalency, this lets a higher standard exist than than bottom 10%.