3 ms·
Society and legislators should only forbid harmful action. Not doing something helpful is very different than doing something hurtful. Compelling helpful actio
by s1artibartfast 4y ago
Society and legislators should only forbid harmful action. Not doing something helpful is very different than doing something hurtful.
Compelling helpful action leads to all kinds of absurd conclusions.
For example, that we should we compel doctors to work more hours because anytime they spend at home is to the detriment of their patients.
- whakim 4y agoObviously not. If doctors can't take care of their patients within a normal working day, the answer is to have more doctors rather than make the existing ones work unsustainably long hours.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI wasn't suggesting that we do so, I was pointing out the absurdity of saying that not doing something for social benefit is the same as harming Society
- whakim 4y agoYou stated categorically that "society and legislators should only forbid harmful action" rather than "compelling helpful action" and then chose a particularly nonsensical example of "compelling helpful action" to prove your point. There are plenty of (much more realistic) examples of "compelling helpful action" which don't lead to "absurd conclusions."
- s1artibartfast 4y agoYes, I think it is a categorical truth. Yes, I chose an extreme and absurd example to illustrate the point. I said as much in the post. I agree that there are many realistic examples of compelling action. If you provide some I would probably disagree that the government should be doing them.
- CogitoCogito 4y agoIt seems to me like the EU considers companies making their own proprietary phone charger connectors as “harmful”. So I’m having trouble understanding what you take issue with here.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI'm saying that it isn't harmful and they shouldn't be making that law. Claims that apple chargers are harmful are logically bankrupt. If I like tuna sandwiches, am I harmed if a restaurant doesn't have it on the menu? Of course not! They are literally doing nothing to me. I don't have to eat there any more than I have to buy an iPhone.
- CogitoCogito 4y ago> I'm saying that it isn't harmful and they shouldn't be making that law. It appears the legislators in question disagree with you. I guess you’re free to contact them and try to convince them of your beliefs.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoYes, this is how free democracies work. People can disagree, criticize, and convince.
- baq 4y agoPlenty of folks in this thread disagree with you, not only the EU legislative branch. You seem to be missing the fact that we have a society here and it demands concessions and compromises to be part of one.
- s1artibartfast 4y ago>You seem to be missing the fact that we have a society here and it demands concessions and compromises to be part of one. No reason that society has to demand this concession. Society will not crumble if Apple has unique connectors. Apple isn't hurting anyone. I prefer live and let live, over trying to squeeze ever concession I can out of people.
- funklute 4y ago> Compelling helpful action leads to all kinds of absurd conclusions. No it doesn't. Besides, "not doing something helpful" vs "doing something hurtful" is often simply a matter of perspective. > For example, that we should we compel doctors to work more hours because anytime they spend at home is to the detriment of their patients. To use your own language, this example is completely absurd. Here is your logic applied to forbidding harmful actions: "Setting speed limits on roads leads to all kinds of absurd conclusions, for example that we should forbid people to walk too fast in their homes."
- JAlexoid 4y agoCool. As soon as Apple relinquishes all monopoly on IP, then we can talk about if governments can interfere here. These companies hold a craptonne of legal power to force me and you. I'm sorry that I have zero regrets when it comes to just a common standard... Just like I have zero regrets that all power outlets in EU are 220v/50Hz