5 ms·
This legislation would have been stupid at any other time in the history of hardware. It will prove to be stupid now as well. There is no reason to think the US
by roenxi 4y ago
This legislation would have been stupid at any other time in the history of hardware. It will prove to be stupid now as well. There is no reason to think the USB-C is the peak of technical achievement or even consistently a local optimum design choice.
The EU has enough problems right now, they don't need to try and help Apple design iPhones.
- nolok 4y agoThis is not about making the best technical choice, this is about ecology and limiting waste, which frankly is a very important and urgent issue. They let the industry regulate itself before regulating, Apple didn't play ball, leading to samsung saying either regulation or we do our thing too, so, regulation. I prefer a slightly worse technical solution and a regulation that needs to be updated every few years, than every phone going back to the waste hell that used to be the cellphone charger/cable market.
- roenxi 4y ago> This is not about making the best technical choice... Thank goodness for the EU parliament, protecting their citizenry from accidentally being exposed to the best technical outcome? Wouldn't want that. If people can't confidently say that the EU is making the best technical choices then the EU shouldn't be legislating technical outcomes. And they can't say that, because this isn't going to be the best choice - the best choice is flexible and context dependent. There are going to be better options than USB-C in some use cases. Possibly many use cases as technology improves. The legislators can't see the future - if they could they'd make better decisions. I bet this doesn't have any material difference on waste. People will still lose and throw charges out at the same rate they always have. And manufacturers are going to turn out to be less efficient, the market is absolutely cut-throat at dealing with manufacturing processes that generate unnecessary waste. It won't be better than it is now, and they've locked out anyone doing a cheaper and less material-intensive charger than USB-C.
- nolok 4y ago> Thank goodness for the EU parliament, protecting their citizenry from accidentally being exposed to the best technical outcome? Wouldn't want that. That is a nice way to completly miss the point and how we got there, but you do you. > I bet this doesn't have any material difference on waste. I bet it does, you're again missing the point, it's about not going back to what we had before, and what we have now made a significant different to what we had before. > the market is absolutely cut-throat at dealing with manufacturing processes that generate unnecessary waste. Ah ah ah ah. Pretty much every phone until very recently had a paid of low quality headphones that were instantly thrown out or put in a box and forgotten, and it only disapeared because jack is going away, so your own exemple doesn't work. > There are going to be better options than USB-C in some use cases. Possibly many use cases as technology improves. The legislators can't see the future - if they could they'd make better decisions. Yes, so the regulation will need to be kept up to date, just like regulations on things like food, pesticides, industrial processes, ... Still, parliament recognized the inferiority on the technical level of a system driven by regulation in this specific case and offered manufacturers to handle it themselves without involving them, but they couldn't (more specifically, apple refused). Anyway, each his point of view, these people are elected and I personnaly consider this a big issue that I'm glad to see resolved by my representatives.
- roenxi 4y ago> Ah ah ah ah. Pretty much every phone until very recently had a paid of low quality headphones that were instantly thrown out or put in a box and forgotten, and it only disapeared because jack is going away, so your own exemple doesn't work. On what basis do you believe that? It probably isn't true, and nothing about this legislation will change the situation. They're still going to include headphones with the phone if they think it makes sense to. > I personnaly consider this a big issue that I'm glad to see resolved by my representatives. There is a land war in Europe right now, that triggered an energy crisis which could see governments toppled and reformed. We've already seen some pretty impressive elections in Italy and Sweden for example. I put it to you that while you might see headphone jacks as a big issue worthy of their time you're a bit out of touch and your representatives could end up getting you killed if they agree with your priorities.
- capableweb 4y agoIs there something in this regulation that says it can never be changed to something else in the future? Why do you assume USB-C will remain the standard for all future? Seems likely if something else pops up in 2030 that is way better, there is nothing to suggest a new regulation couldn't be made.
- roenxi 4y agoHow will they figure out that there is a better standard in the future? Certainly not with a study in the EU. They're going to have to send investigators to more advanced foreign countries to figure out what charger to use.
- Heliosmaster 4y agoWhy do you think an investigation has to be done on devices available to the public? Prototypes exists.
- roenxi 4y agoWhy bother? The competition can't out-compete because it'll be illegal. And the most likely outcome of a prototyping project is people will say "looks nice" then not bother to seriously consider it. The EU is never going to produce a charger that isn't backwards compatible with USB-C. They'd better hope nobody comes up with a cheaper alternative that catches on in Asia.
- DocTomoe 4y agoPrototypes came up with Micro-USB and USB-C before either were released to the public, which then - in millions of tests - realized these are nimble things that break easily as compared to the rather robust Lightning connector. Creating something in isolation, with virtually no chance of it becoming "allowed" by an hostile state actor is nice, expensive, and thus won't happen. If you want to figure out if an idea works, lots and lots of field tests are what you want.
- Nextgrid 4y ago
- hyperman1 4y agoThere is no reason the EU can't upgrade to a new standard, or the USB consortium can't create a backward compatible upgrade. My USB 1.0 keyboard from long ago still works, BTW. Meanwhile, I have a box full of chargers for all kinds of old stuff. Replacing them all with 1 standard is great. And USB is doing just that, not only for cell phones but for all kinds of gadgets. Even if I only require an USB micro and an USB C charger, that's a ton of chargers not in my house, and a ton of time not hunting around for the right one. The main problem here is Apple. The EU went to all cellphone makers and told them to either agree to a standard voluntarily, or the EU would decide from them. This kind of process is quite normal for technology decisions in europe, BTW. Most manufacturers agreed on an USB variant( might have been micro at the time, don't know if C already existed ). Apple refused to join the club or come with an other acceptable proposal. If a kid refuses to play along, the adults have to force the situation. The kid might not like the result and whine a bit afterwards. What surprises me is that it took so many years before this happens.
- roenxi 4y ago> This kind of process is quite normal for technology decisions in europe, BTW. Europe is technologically backwards. They got destroyed by Shenzhen and Silicon Valley because their bureaucrats keep rolling in with this sort of idiocy. They feel a need to bring this backseat design process because their local companies aren't up to the challenge of competing with more-nimble American megacorporations. Their phone company (Nokia) was the market leader until they got wrecked by an inability to innovate. This policy will make that outcome even more likely for European companies. Then to add insult to injury, Huawei comes along and showed that they could operate at any standard you care to ask them to. If you get outcompeted by authoritarians and communists, it is worth asking what is wrong with your economic policies.
- tapoxi 4y agoWeren't they wrecked by Elop betting on Windows Phone? The MeeGo-powered N9 recieved positive reviews.
- 4y ago