3 ms·
I first used an Alto around 78 so it’s interesting they had an “ad” in 79. Perhaps it was part of the internal bake off. Over lunch a few years later Alan tol
by gumby 4y ago
I first used an Alto around 78 so it’s interesting they had an “ad” in 79. Perhaps it was part of the internal bake off.
Over lunch a few years later Alan told me about trying to get Xerox to sell Altos. There was a bake-off back in NY between the Alto and a orange-screen fixed-character machine (perhaps running CPM?) with no mouse, no network, no bitmapped display, just a small screen. No laser printing. Anyway the latter won.
A few years later Alan was on a plane and when talking to his seat mate found they’d both worked for Xerox — in fact that guy had made the decision or at least was in on it! So Alan asked how the decision had been made and the guy shrugged and said “well they were basically the same, so we went with the one that was cheaper to make”.
- andrekandre 4y ago> “well they were basically the same, so we went with the one that was cheaper to make” wow, i wonder if thats a case of business people don't understand technology, or just a bad case of communication/marketing to execs?
- space_ghost 4y agoCalling those two machines the same would be like calling a Curtiss JN-4 and a Messerschmitt ME 232 "the same." Sure, they both fly and use fixed wings to attain lift, but that's where the similarities end. That's some spectacular failure of leadership. O_O
- gumby 4y agoIt looks that way in retrospect (and looked that way to me at the time!) but here’s a bit of sympathy for the decision: 1 - in those days executives, and even other white collar “professionals”, typically male, didn’t type. They had secretaries who took dictation, typed things up, made corrections, and then used, Xerox photocopiers to make copies which would be distributed. So the use case wasn't clear. 2 - for all of those reasons they probably looked at specs (screen? Yep. keyboard? Yep. Network? What's that?) and thought they were making a shrewd decision. And perhaps they were: nobody even knew they needed a WYSIWYG editor much less mail (and this was Xerox, a paper management company -- why would they embrace electronic mail?). Microsoft swooped up Simonyi and he rewrote his Bravo editor as the original version of Word (the only part of office originally written by Microsoft?). The Alto wasn't as expensive as the later Star (also a failure) but I think each one cost about 10K in 1980 dollars. As far as I know the only Altos and Dovers outside PARC were MIT, Stanford and the White House. Probably CMU too.
- ncmncm 4y agoBoth had buttons and a monochrome screen, and ran programs. What got my attention was how slowly text was painted on the screen, in the ad. I wonder if that was artificial. People used to be weirded out by computers being "too fast". They thought it must be taking a shortcut and not processing everything it ought to. Coders had to insert delay loops so it would look like something was happening. Yes, really true. My employer in 1982 bought a Xerox CP/M machine, thinking it ought to have some PARC mojo. Probably that one.
- gumby 4y agoBy today's standards it was slow, but the video looked slow to me too. I remember it as faster and I know the last time I typed at one (at the LCM about five or six years ago) it didn't seem that slow to me. If you read Butler Lampson's paper on the design of the Alto you'll see it was an amazing machine. Super screen-oriented (i.e. human-oriented): the bus clock was 3/2 the screen refresh speed, so the majority of the bus bandwidth was spent refreshing the screen! Absurd and crazy at its time, but of course now we realize that it was brilliant. All built out of a handful of MSI and SSI TTL parts IIRC. Actually the paper is by Thacker, McCreight, Lampson and Sproull. Really a great read.
- ncmncm 4y agoIt did a very great deal with amazingly little physical hardware. As much as people complained about its performance, I would have been proud to have designed it.