3 ms·
Interesting, but having watched both (and been involved a little bit in sketch comedy), it really does just feel like coincidence. You think, let's do a sketch
by crazygringo 4y ago
Interesting, but having watched both (and been involved a little bit in sketch comedy), it really does just feel like coincidence.
You think, let's do a sketch with the Charmin bears. Their main defining comedic characteristic is... their whole life is toilet paper. Conflict is introduced when... one member wants to change/escape. Therefore one needs to reject the limiting toilet paper life for a contrasting, expressive life of... art/theater/dance. A choice usually made when... choosing where to attend college. And the Dad can't accept his son like that... but in the end he does.
It's just the kind of paint-by-numbers logic of sketch comedy. If you asked 10 improv teams or sketch writers to start with the premise of a family of Charmin bears, I wouldn't be surprised if half of them came up with the exact same thing.
And having watched both sketches, they're otherwise entirely different in execution, tone, and everything else.
So yeah it's funny to joke that SNL stole your idea, but basic premises are a dime a dozen, and then the logic of comedy usually leads them to very similar places. Which is actually kind of why good improv teams work so well -- the logic of comedy keeps things running smoothly, as (trained) improvisers can easily see where things are going and contribute accordingly.
- ShamelessC 4y agoThis is all covered in the linked video, fyi.