2 ms·
While you’re generally correct, there is a procedural reason why the Section 230 issue comes up first. Section 230(c)(1) is a cut and dry immunity. It says: “No
by rayiner 4y ago
While you’re generally correct, there is a procedural reason why the Section 230 issue comes up first. Section 230(c)(1) is a cut and dry immunity. It says: “No provider or user of an interactive computer service shall be treated as the publisher or speaker of any information provided by another information content provider.”
If the provider meets the requirements of section 230, then there is no lawsuit, period. By contrast, the 1A analysis is fact-specific. “Kill all infidels” is protected, but “kill @throwaway81523 when he walks home from work on Tuesday at 6:30 pm” probably isn’t.
In a lawsuit cut and dry immunities can be addressed at the motion to dismiss stage. More fact specific inquiries often can’t be decided until later, on summary judgment.
- selimthegrim 4y ago1A didn’t stop the Smith or McCarran acts