7 ms·
If you ever have a friend or family member who is trying to get around wetland conservation laws, they are contributing to the shrinking of our river systems.
by hinkley 4y ago
If you ever have a friend or family member who is trying to get around wetland conservation laws, they are contributing to the shrinking of our river systems.
Water retention capacity in upper watersheds directly contribute to average river flow, which is very easy to show by the behavior of streams. Deserts are self-reinforcing systems where the heat pushes clouds up or away from them. Wet, cool forests draw in more precipitation in. We don't really understand the processes yet, but we do know it's not a zero sum game of delaying (or 'stealing') water versus total system flow. This is most easily demonstrated for watersheds on the windward sides of mountains, due to snow pack, but forests and microbes both fiddle around with cloud cover in general.
As for restoring watersheds, we systematically removed the engineers that created the lush river systems of the US and Canada, namely the beaver, which once numbered at somewhere between 60 and 300 million animals in North America. We blame long term changes in rain patterns for the reduced river flow, but I strongly suspect that is the '3 Whys' trap of the Five Whys Process.
- DavidPeiffer 4y agoNot only affecting the shrinking of the river systems, but also degrading the quality of the water. I live in Iowa, home of 3.15 million people and 24 million pigs. Tile in the fields and a complete lack of buffer between fields and streams sends massive amounts of fertilizer into the waterways and ultimately down the Mississippi. ~85% of the land in the state is dedicated to farming in one way or another, and the amount of manure which can be spread per acre is based on crop production per acre formulas from the 1970's. Breeding work has increased corn yield by about 65%, allowing that much more manure to be spread. I recently found this podcast which talks about water issues around the state, produced by University of Iowa professors. https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/we-all-want-clean-h2o/id1590059366 https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/we-all-want-clean-h2o/...
- dsfyu404ed 4y ago>If you ever have a friend or family member who is trying to get around wetland conservation laws, they are contributing to the shrinking of our river systems. If you ever read/hear a statement like this you can safely ignore it because nobody with any second or even third hand exposure to the true vastness of the scope of wetland conservation laws would say such a thing. Somebody's little construction project to replace their 25x30 cabin on a lake in the woods with one that's 24x32 isn't material in this context no matter how hard people may dishonestly try to imply otherwise. Furthermore, the overwhelming majority of cases of "skirting conservation laws" are cases of people who want to do a nearly like for like replacement of some existing thing that didn't need permission when it was done 40-140yr ago and don't want to pay some guy with a license thousands of dollars for the privilege of a stamped drawing.
- hinkley 4y agoYou say that like nobody of Hacker News knows anybody who is a land developer. > some existing thing that didn't need permission when it was done 40-140yr ago Not every law ever written has grandfather clauses, and where water rights are concerned we are quickly running out of patience for grandfather clauses. > no matter how hard people may dishonestly try to imply otherwise Hey you know what else is dishonest? Making a big conversation with wide ranging consequences have to pause to talk about one particular line item you have a problem with. Agenda or no (which you are projecting on others), the results are the same. Every city is worsening its watershed - through development - except for the few that are actively fighting against it. And so many families are getting burned out by wildfires because we keep increasing the density of cabins out in the woods. It's not isolated incidents when you have 5 million or even half a million people living in a county all trying to do their own thing without The Man trying to stop them. No single rain drop believes it is responsible for the flood.
- Turing_Machine 4y ago> we are quickly running out of patience for grandfather clauses. Who is "we"? Who put you in charge of speaking for everyone?
- hinkley 4y agoStart at the south end of the Colorado for the loudest voices, and then work your way north. So that's the entire country of Mexico who wonders where their river went, and the people upstream who are progressively less effected by the reduced flow. Then add in environmentalists and conservationists. You can't preserve wetland plants and animals when there's no wetland. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colorado_River_Delta https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colorado_River_Delta > The loss of freshwater flows to the delta over the twentieth century has reduced delta wetlands to about 5 percent of their original extent, and non-native species have compromised the ecological health of much of what remains. Stress on ecosystems has allowed invasive plants to out-compete native species along Colorado River riparian areas. Native forests of cottonwood and willow have yielded to sand and mudflats dominated by the nonnative tamarisk (also known as salt cedar), arrow-weed, and iodine bush, a transformation that has decreased the habitat value of the riparian forest.[7]
- fredrikholm 4y agoIt's painful how widespread this notion of 'nature steals precious water' is, and how quickly the practical implications of such a mindset leads to further destruction. The municipality where I live have an annual cycle of doing things like: * Scraping away every fallen leaf to be burned * Removing all twigs, branches and dead wood * Burning or spraying down all weeds * Cutting the grass, even in places no one walks * Aggressively cutting down bushes Every year the soil gets drier, compacts and washes away when rainfall comes in the spring and turns our parks into giant mudslides. Next year they spend hundreds of thousands trying to replant and reseed, only to lose it again in the words of 'maintenance'. Meanwhile, our smaller community decided to do the complete opposite: * Faux-compost everything (grass cuttings, leaves, twigs, weeds) by literally just throwing it into a pile and forgetting about it * Mulch everything with said compost * Let (non-invasive) weeds take over areas that were previously barren * Not trim down bushes before winter In nearly two seasons now, we've gone from watching a slow depressing death of what used to be a wonderful garden before the droughts started in ~2018, to a garden that is even more impressive and seems to grow stronger every year. We now have more birds than ever, as insects have started to bounce back. We're doing 1/10th of the work as our neighboring communities, and we're getting as good if not better results. I wish more people approached gardening/landscaping with this water-harvesting, nature mimicking way. It's cheap, takes extremely little resources and demonstrates how incredibly strong an ecosystem can be if you just work with it rather than against it, even on a small scale.
- bombcar 4y agoThe absolute amount of effort we spend fighting nature instead of just guiding and living with it is frightening.
- hinkley 4y agoIllusion of Control. We need group therapy and nobody who has successfully accomplished that at such scales has any formal training in the subject.
- mc32 4y agoIf you don't manage it (fight it) you get the buried and re-discovered pyramids of southern Mexico (and Cambodia). Yes, there is a balance, however, the other extreme is also not viable for habitation.
- CharlesW 4y ago> …I strongly suspect that is the '3 Whys' trap of the Five Whys Process. My search-fu fails me. What is this?
- routerl 4y agoI'm guessing it means "stop asking why before discovering the root cause". I.e. the analysis stops at a symptom rather than the cause.
- hinkley 4y agoWhat routerl said. Skipping out on root cause analysis by stopping as soon as you find something actionable. Those shallow analyses often result in a much bigger cleanup project that is also much less effective. Great for empire building, not so great for progress. It just so happens that I usually catch people at this when they only have 3 Whys mapped out. There's something going on there but I'm not sure I understand the mechanics.
- CharlesW 4y agoGotcha, thanks! AFAICT you coined "3 Whys trap", which is a great name for it.
- wsinks 4y agoI really appreciated this! I've heard of the five whys earlier in life, and later on I've heard of 'the 3 whys', part of the selling technique that everyone has to answer: - Why buy anything? - Why buy from you? - Why buy now? I knew it wasn't that, and the idea of the 5 Whys funnel crapping out at 3 Whys does make sense!
- makestuff 4y agopretty popular for root cause analysis technique at AWS. They published an article on it here https://wa.aws.amazon.com/wellarchitected/2020-07-02T19-33-23/wat.concept.fivewhys.en.html https://wa.aws.amazon.com/wellarchitected/2020-07-02T19-33-2....
- 4y ago
- bcrosby95 4y agoYour post reminds me of this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kSctr0aQOso https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kSctr0aQOso
- hinkley 4y agoThere's a group working in the Columbia River basin, and they've seen good results both from just setting beavers loose. They've seen positive but lesser results from man-made bespoke beaver dams, but of note is that in some cases the beavers adopted a man-made dam and completed it, which may help smooth the path for reintroduction in places where Illusion of Control sufferers paint beavers as anarchists. We would prefer the beaver dams be here, here and here, so we will try to coax them into doing just that. Part of my statements above come from their work, and if memory serves, they made an off-hand comment in one of their reports about wanting to try the same thing in the Colorado. The Columbia is in good enough shape that we've removed dams to restore salmon spawning grounds. The Colorado is a fucking mess, but it's not in 'hippy dippy' states where funding is easier to come by.
- Metacelsus 4y agoAnd the Supreme Court will probably gut those laws in the near future.
- zip1234 4y agoHow would wetlands conservation laws not be constitutional?
- rayrey 4y agoTakings and violation of property rights
- drewm1980 4y agoEnvironmental conservation laws should be considered a matter of national security. We need to mobilize the military industrial complex on the side of the environment before everything dies.
- rayiner 4y agoAh yes, “we need to bend the procedures for the stuff I think is important.”
- tptacek 4y agoI think they're just advocating for more conservation laws, right? That is the procedures, not a bending of them.
- rayiner 4y agoInvocation of “national security” generally implies some sort of bending or exceptions to the ordinary rules. “We can’t reveal those documents because of national security.” “We need to indefinitely detain those terrorists because of national security.”
- rayiner 4y ago