6 ms·
Supreme Court will hear challenge to legal immunity for tech sites
- jqpabc123 4y agoThe most amazing part of this is the failure to recognize the effects that lack of immunity will have across the political spectrum --- left, center and right. In it's new push for partisanship, I have confidence that the Supreme Court will issue some arbitrary, abjectly stupid ruling with far reaching and unintended consequences.
- theandrewbailey 4y agoIf it can be proven that big tech is already partisan in rule enforcement, then they should not have these protections.
- triceratops 4y agoWhy?
- jqpabc123 4y agoSo what you're saying is Donald Trump should have no right to moderate content on Truth Social but he must bear full responsibility for lies that get posted there? And the same should apply to this forum that you obviously enjoy using free of charge? What you and these ultra-partisans are proposing is a set of contradictory mandates that will effectively kill off everything about the internet except apps, shopping and advertising --- and even the advertising may be in jeopardy too.
- theandrewbailey 4y agoIf you don't have the power to take down lies[0], you can't be held responsible for them. That's what Section 230 is supposed to do. [0] Who is deciding what is a lie and what isn't? Too often, what appears to be a lie to someone is someone else's lived experience. The internet doesn't have an oath. Social network randos aren't obligated to post the truth.
- jqpabc123 4y agoIf you don't have the power to take down lies[0], you can't be held responsible for them. LOL! Thank you for illustrating my point. The first victims of any such mandate will be the ultra-partisans promoting this case --- they have zero tolerance for dissent. Do you honestly think Truth Social will continue to operate without Trump having the ability to ban and remove people and posts he disagrees with? He is very definition of intolerant --- the only tolerance he has any interest in is that afforded himself. The job for this biased court will be to craft a decision that impacts one side but not the other. I'm skeptical that this can be achieved in a fair and consistent and workable manner.
- LatteLazy 4y agoTo prove that, you will need a rigorous definition of what partisan means covering every situation and set of events and then Scotus will need to assess the whole of a social media company to evaluate whether the standard is met. Also, you won't be allowed to chat with your family unless you can prove to the same definition that you're impartial as a group.
- fardo 4y agoOr, more likely, you can do what the supreme court has done in the past with the Roth test [1], argue “you know it when you see it”, and dodge the challenge of rigorously defining the topic while still allowing for some prosecutions to occur. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roth_v._United_States https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roth_v._United_States
- triceratops 4y ago"For my friends, anything. For my enemies, the law".
- LatteLazy 4y agoOf course, that just requires people to agree whether something is "patently obscene". Now get people to agree on whether something is fair in a political situation...
- elpool2 4y agoWhy would you think that? The law (230) has no requirement that moderation be non-partisan. Or are you making an argument about what the law should be?
- bediger4000 4y agoDrat! It's been proven! https://mashable.com/article/facebook-mark-zuckerberg-conservative-pages https://mashable.com/article/facebook-mark-zuckerberg-conser... https://news.yahoo.com/twitter-algorithms-amplify-conservative-content-185825857.html https://news.yahoo.com/twitter-algorithms-amplify-conservati... https://www.inputmag.com/tech/twitter-anti-conservative-bias-misinformation-study-mit-yale https://www.inputmag.com/tech/twitter-anti-conservative-bias... https://arstechnica.com/science/2020/02/researchers-have-already-tested-googles-algorithms-for-political-bias/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2020/02/researchers-have-alr... I read the above links as showing that there's a mild-to-pronounced pro-conservative bias in almost all "big tech" social media. Yes, you can find Dennis Prager or Ben Shapiro claiming anti-conservative bias, but what's their methodology? I think the above studies have a methodology, they attempted to be non-partisan. Prager and Shapiro don't even pretend to be objective.
- jleyank 4y agoA stupid ruling here might/will end free social media as the risk of litigation and liability would be a big burden. This kind of bs should do wonders for the nasdaq 100. And I think the supremes are stupid enough or biased enough to do it.
- ActorNightly 4y agoOn some levels, I hope this actually happens, because it would at least contribute to making decentralized alternatives viable.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jdhn 4y ago>A stupid ruling here might/will end free social media There are some who would say that this is a good thing.
- krapp 4y agoYes, unfortunately the tech community is full of people who cannot see the forest for the trees.
- carlosdp 4y agoWoah, this is very dangerous. We'd basically have to go back to web 1 (no user-generated content) if Section 230 were struck down.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoDepends on what replaces it. If it's replaced by "you are liable for everything on your site, even if it's user generated", then yes. If it's something in between that and the current Section 230, then... maybe we wind up somewhere in between? (But I don't know what that "something in between" would be, and I can't predict what the effects would be...)
- ajhurliman 4y agoOr you’d end up with a lot of smaller publishers who can vouch for the content of their community to a single, meta-publisher. This is basically in-place already, if your subreddit becomes toxic they ban it. And the moderators on each sub aren’t Reddit employees (for the most part). Facebook has the same thing with groups and pages, individuals moderate it and FB bans it if it goes off the rails. The logical next step would be trying to hold the page/ community owners legally liable for their content. This new responsibility would imply ownership of the content, which would mean more ability to directly monetize it and possibly cut out the meta organizer (FB, Reddit, etc) by moving the community to another platform if there’s any friction. Obviously the platforms don’t want a looser connection with their participants, they want all of the money and none of the responsibilities.
- hirundo 4y agoActual question: The U.S. has many laws that prohibit discrimination against or require common carriers to do business with members of various groups. Among those groups are races, genders, religions and nationalities. Why would groups defined by partisanship or other values be exempt from such laws? Freedom of association is a perfectly good answer for a partisan group, in my mind. But why is it a less good answer, constitutionally, for those other groups? Under current law the constitutional line between things a business may and must not discriminate against does not appear to be very bright.
- LatteLazy 4y agoI agree. But will a conservative-appointed, computer illiterate SCOTUS see it that way?
- triceratops 4y agoBecause race, gender, and nationality are unchangeable. Religion seems like it is changeable, but it isn't really*. And in any case, none of them are actions. Speech is an action. Saying you can't be banned from a private venue for your speech (or any other action) runs contrary to everything we currently hold true about private property. You always have the choice to not do or say something if you wish to continue enjoying access to that private property. But you can't stop being X nationality or Y religion. * Go on, go change your religion right now. Like for real. With actual, deeply-held, genuine faith. Did it work?
- hirundo 4y agoGo on, go change your ideology right now. Like for real. With actual, deeply-held genuine belief. Did it work? You can't distinguish ideology from religion so easily. Religion is just what we call ideology on a theological topic.
- triceratops 4y agoWhat "ideology"? I don't have an ideology. I have a bunch of opinions on various topics that I've formed based on what I've read, seen, heard, or been taught. Show me new data or give me different experiences, and I'd change my mind on those specific issues. People stick with the same religion through trials and tribulations. They change their political affiliation and vote for candidates of different parties pretty frequently. Don't treat politics like religion.
- thoughtstheseus 4y agoI would love to see a market for content moderation. Publish what you want but AI + human agents will curate info for me.
- Kye 4y agoThere have been numerous attempts at personalized automated and human curation over the years.
- bwestergard 4y agoCan someone legally knowledgeable explain the legal theory of the plaintiff?
- xenospn 4y agoThis will be worse than citizens United. What will end up happening is most big US websites will just relocate to Europe, or another country without such liability.
- polski-g 4y agoEurope has hoster liability for user-generated posts.
- p49k 4y agoThat’s not what will happen, because the US is by far the most lucrative market for advertising, and serving ads to users in the US means that they will have to adhere to US laws, even if they’re not physically located there, just as Twitter is forced to censor content according to the laws of every other country where it does business (e.g. censoring Nazi material in Germany)
- exabrial 4y agoI have an alternate suggestion: Break up the monopolies of Apple, Google, amd Facebook into smithereens. This preserves the spirit of free speech AND allows companies to both: not be forced to being responsible for user content AND allows them to moderate to whatever bias they want on their platforms.
- krapp 4y agoNone of those companies are monopolies. You just want the government to force companies you don't like to be less popular than they are.
- Cornelius267 4y agoWhy does a company need to be a monopoly in order to break them up? In an "ought to" sense, that is. Facebook has facilitated/amplified quite a bit of awful things that have lead to real world violence, most particularly outside of the United States. Which is saying something, considering their contribution to political polarization in the US. Whether or not they are a monopoly is orthogonal to the question put forward in this case.
- krapp 4y agoIf you're arguing the government should be able to break up any company it likes, for any reason it decides, then you're basically arguing against capitalism, private property, freedom of speech and association, and most of the separation of powers and concerns that democracies are supposed to be built upon. "ought to" is a dangerous cudgel to put in the hands of a government or a self-righteous mob, and "monopoly" was what everyone was arguing should be the standard, but I guess now it's open season.
- Cornelius267 4y ago> If you're arguing the government should be able to break up any company it likes, for any reason it decides That's great, because I'm not arguing that. My post does not imply as such either. You are creating a fake argument that is easier for you to argue against. "Ought to" is the basis of rule of law. By what measure do you decide that a "monopoly" is bad? It has certain outcomes, some positive, some negative, but on balance government in previous generations decided that they are negative. But once you know that the outcome is negative, what do you do about it? You only take another step and break it apart if you decide that you "ought to" do so. Because you place value in a healthy society, or you place value in non-monopolistic market competition, or you place value in something else. But whatever you choose, in order to justify actually action you inevitably rely on an "ought to." If the reason for breaking up monopolies is to improve society, in some broad sense, then you could use a similar reason to break up companies that are harmful to society. We do sanction companies that damage the environment, or lie to consumers with false claims, etc. There is always an "ought to."
- yokem55 4y agoWhere the court might split hairs here is drawing a line between 'moderation' of content and 'recommendation' of content, and find google liable for the reccomendations that generated the feed. But I suspect no one is particularly interested that level of subtlety.
- bediger4000 4y agoI think we can predict what will happen based on what happened to Usenet. No single authority "censored" usenet articles. People posted what they wanted. It ended up as an ocean of spam, abuse and off-topic articles. That's what the Texas law will entail. I think Abbott and Paxton didn't understand the consequences, or are gambling on a situation like what happened to radio, TV and newspapers in the 1990s after the "Fairness Doctrine" went away. Abbott and Paxton may hope that an informal cartel of conservative owners will let conservative/Republic viewpoints run wild, while behind the scenes or under the table manipulation suppresses liberal/other viewpoints, just like what happened to broadcast TV, radio and newspapers.
- elpool2 4y agoI agree, but this is Gonzalez v. Google, which has nothing to do with the Texas law.
- fhfyrke4ffy 4y agoI don't really understand the criticism when the alternative is letting the dems continue to censor conservative opinions freely by having the lgbt crowd and the race warriors call everything hatespeech or racist.
- Kye 4y agoEssential reading: https://www.techdirt.com/2020/06/23/hello-youve-been-referred-here-because-youre-wrong-about-section-230-communications-decency-act/ https://www.techdirt.com/2020/06/23/hello-youve-been-referre... Previous discussion on it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25697823 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25697823
- elpool2 4y agoIt seems like even if they rule that 230 doesn’t protect this recommended content then it would still be protected by the first amendment (youtube videos unlikely to be “imminent” enough to qualify as incitement). So what would happen then? Content is still protected by 230, but only if there's no recommendation algorithm, but what about an algorithm that only culls content from an otherwise chronological timeline?
- cetahfh14615 4y agoFWIW Gonzalez v Google might not have as much of an impact as what the comments here indicate. > The case — Gonzalez v. Google — seeks to hold Google legally liable for a deadly 2015 Paris terrorist attack, alleging the tech giant recommended ISIS videos to users and boosted the terrorist group's recruitment. If the focus is on the recommendation of content and not on the hosting of content (I know they're both related, but bear with me), then the effect of the ruling might have a narrower scope. If a company like Google is recommending terrorist content in such a way that affects many people, that's a problem with the recommendation engine. If the problem is broader and about hosting the content (as opposed to just recommending), the effect might be more extreme Notwithstanding this ruling could have a catastrophic effect and turn social media sites into lawsuit piñatas, it could be the single most significant fuck up of this court to date