5 ms·
I come bringing good news about hydrogen: The fourth big green energy technology
- rini17 4y agoHydrogen as seasonal storage will have to compete with thermal storage, which does not suffer from electrolyzer losses and challenges from storage of vast amounts of volatile flammable gas. Consider NASA Artemis leaks.
- tuatoru 4y agoI agree with everything in that report except for using hydrogen for long term storage. Hydrogen has a very wide range of air concentrations in which it's flammable, a very high flame speed, and it burns very hot. It also gets everywhere if there's a small defect in the seals of its containers. To me, that's...not safe. Since PV produced energy is going to be so incredibly cheap, I'd trade some energy to make stored hydrogen a lot safer, by reacting it with air captured carbon to make hydrocarbons. Hydrocarbons are much safer in all four aspects I listed above. We already have the storage structures built, and we have many decades' experience with storing and handling them and dealing with emergency situations involving them. It'll probably take a few disasters before regulators come around to this way of thinking, though.
- rini17 4y agoI doubt it will be economical at all, as the efficiency losses multiply with every step: - electrolysis - synthesis of hydrocarbons - burning them
- TheSpiceIsLife 4y agoThe article almost nearly hints at it by talking about ammonia and hydrocarbons, then goes on to talk about hydrogen storage tanks near solar farms. Hydrogen has a very low volumetric energy density, and it embritles steel.
- hoseja 4y agoIt embrittles mostly everything. But ammonia might be viable. But we certainly don't need even cheaper fertilizer; Haber-Bosch process has been a disaster for the human race.
- jonnycomputer 4y agoFertilizer saved the human race from starvation. Probably one of the most important inventions ever. That doesn't mean fertilizer use has no costs, but there is a reason that famines only happen now because of war.
- hoseja 4y agoOn the contrary, it doomed the human race to obesity and multibillion population.
- carlsborg 4y agoWhy hydrocarbons. They only need to solve Hyrdogen + X, such that the mixture is less flammable and there exists a cheap way to filter out the Hydrogen again.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoThe article was implicitly including hydrogen derived molecules like ammonia, methanol or dimethyl ether under the same category as they become extremely viable even with current technology if you can get the hydrogen at 95% electric efficiency with $200/kW of capital.
- ZeroGravitas 4y ago> The reason people think this is that hydrogen cars, which some had predicted would replace gas cars, turned out not to be very viable. It's worth always highlighting that Fuel Cell cars were and are better than ICE, they're just not as good as Battery EVs (and they are basically BEVs with a fuel cell range extender, so have no real way to improve without also improving BEVs as well). If you could wave a wand and replace all ICE and gas hybrids with Fuel Cell cars it would be a good move. Since in reality it involves rolling out a whole infrastructure and there's a better option for cars, it's not the best option. But still better than ICE. Most of the ill feeling comes from lies about BEVs and attempts to use Hydrogen to just continue business as usual for fossil fuel companies, with Blue Hydrogen.
- ZeroGravitas 4y ago> Liebrich is surprisingly cautious about hydrogen’s prospects here, writing: > > Low-and mid-temperature industrial heat - up to 160C and perhaps higher - will be much more cheaply and precisely supplied by heat pumps. Burning stuff really isn't efficient, even if it's Hydrogen. If you are burning something and thinking about replacing it with Hydrogen to decarbonise, 99 of 100 times you'd be better off electrifying directly. Even for ships and planes, where the transport part is important electrolysers and fuel cells are the long term answer, not burning hydrogen in turbines. (And incedentally, that why batteries are more important here than this techno-optimist realises and will account for more shipping/flying than you think. That extra efficiency matters and will act to reduce ship size and travel distance, especially combined with autonomous craft).
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoI don't quite agree with the long term storage point. You can store hydrogen (or Ammonia) which is good. But that doesn't mean you need to turn it all back into electricity. Just build extra wind and solar and for 99% of the year use it to make green hydrogen that you use for stuff. That industrial process acts as "storage". On that cold, dark, windless night, first you use hydro and biomass and batteries and imports and demand response and only then, if still you really need to, use hydrogen, but ideally it's just there as a backup and will be used for chemical feedstock to make cheaper materials. The subtler but more impactful thing is that for the rest of the year you can divert 1% of the energy to the grid via demand response, to integrate more cheap variable renewables.