3 ms·
https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2022/09/chromes-new-ad-blocker-limiting-extension-platform-will-launch-in-2023/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2022/09/chromes-
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y ago
https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2022/09/chromes-new-ad-blocker-limiting-extension-platform-will-launch-in-2023/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2022/09/chromes-new-ad-block...
"Google says Manifest V3 is "one of the most significant shifts in the extensions platform since it launched a decade ago." The company claims that the more limited platform is meant to bring "enhancements in security, privacy, and performance.""
Big Tech is not exactly known for its honesty. If it does not also increase profits and/or decrease losses then there is no sense in pursuing it. There is literally nothing Google does that is not sold as being for the benefit of its data sources and ad targets, i.e., "users". Doing things that help lure in or retain the data sources and ad targets is not not the same as doing thing that actually benefit them. At best, what Google does is make compromises, but the announcements never acknowledge any compromise. Everything is a win for the data sources and ad targets. If we are to believe their rhetoric Google's interests and "users'" interests are always exactly the same. Impossible.
"Privacy groups like the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) dispute this description and say that if Google really cared about the security of the extension store, it could just police the store more actively using actual humans instead of limiting the capabilities of all extensions."
As if anyone else, besides people obligated to support Google, would not "dispute this description". We do not know because those other people are never asked. None of them asked for an update. They have no choice in the matter. Ambivalence does equate to agreement.
It makes one wonder why does Google even bother to purportedly disclose the motivation or justification for an "update". No one has a choice to reject it. We never see any evaluations fo the source code changes. So-called "users" are not the stakeholders in this project.
"The EFF poked holes in most of Google's justifications for Manifest V3 changes, saying that malicious extensions are mostly interested in stealing data and that Manifest V3 only stops extensions from blocking data, not inspecting it, so Google isn't doing much to stop bad actors. The report says performance also isn't a valid excuse, citing a study showing that ad downloading and rendering degrades browser performance."
Tell us something we do not already know. Google's customers are not "users", they are advertisers. As such, statements about the advantages of an "update" really should relate to the advantanges for advertisers. Any other statements are just meant to lure in or retain the data sources and ad targets.
- shadowgovt 4y ago> it could just police the store more actively EFF, I love you dearly, but on what planet. There are 135,000 extensions in the Chrome Web Store. If Google hired 1,000 people to vet the store (a staggering number), each person would have a portfolio of 100 extensions to care for.