3 ms·
It’s hard to do a direct comparison as government jobs tend to inherently be more risky and accident reporting rates vary. An Air Force pilot isn’t directly an
by Retric 4y ago
It’s hard to do a direct comparison as government jobs tend to inherently be more risky and accident reporting rates vary. An Air Force pilot isn’t directly analogous to an airline pilot nor is a police officer even vaguely equivalent to private security.
Private sector hospitals, which are arguably the closest direct analog with public sector counterparts, have higher rates of workplace injury than public sector hospitals. By comparison private teachers have lower rates, but work with less at risk populations etc.
PS: Reports of illness are noticeably higher in the public sector, but that likely relates to differences in PTO etc.
- eru 4y agoThanks. I was more thinking of industrial accidents, for example. In any case, when given the right incentives, profit seeking companies are excellent at promoting safety. Similarly, bureaucrats working for organisations without a profit-motive don't magically follow the same preferences we might dream up in our armchairs. They also need to be given the right incentives.
- redanddead 4y agogive examples, I'm really not convinced. If anything public sector industries are far far larger in terms of scale, so it's likely that 1 single public disaster trumps many private ones. However, private sector has shown time and time again that it can create huge issues, for example take the forever chemicals inside you right now that you didn't consent to having inside you. I want to believe private and corporate is better. It's hard for me.