3 ms·
Just a couple, as well, and my grandfather did neuroscience research. I guess it's true that things like the IAT show a strong and easily replicable cognitive
by kragen 4y ago
Just a couple, as well, and my grandfather did neuroscience research.
I guess it's true that things like the IAT show a strong and easily replicable cognitive priming effect, I just hadn't thought of it that way. But the replicability problem isn't limited to social priming; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Priming_%28psychology%29#Replicability_controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Priming_%28psychology%29#Repli... talks about other forms of priming that have experienced replication problems.
Several of the Big Five predictive effects mentioned in the WP page do go beyond self-report instruments, even though it's true that there are many more correlations with other self-report instruments. A few of them are large effects.
- runarberg 4y agoFor what its worth the source for the statement in the Wikipedia article claiming that Priming studies suffer from the replication crisis is from Bowers (2012) is actually a short non-peer reviewed opinion piece from a magazine called Science News with 0 references, and is actually talking about the replication problem in social psychology, using social-priming as an example. This Wikipedia article probably needs to be edited to reflect that. That said I do admit that I’ve read some claims from cognitive psychologists about priming which probably needs to be replicated, that is cognitive psychology also suffers from the same replication crisis as social psychology. However cognitive priming never reached the same hype as social priming (and why would it; the claims are about some boring reaction times and proportions of false positives after a 1000 trials, etc; unlike social psychology where the claims are all „work faster and more accurate by changing this one thing“)
- kragen 4y agoMaybe you should fix it. I think Gladwell wrote a pretty sensationalist article about the IAT.