3 ms·
From IBM management's point of view, I think, the easy win was that even though they discovered RISC in 01974 and shipped it in ROMP in 01981, their competition
by kragen 4y ago
From IBM management's point of view, I think, the easy win was that even though they discovered RISC in 01974 and shipped it in ROMP in 01981, their competition didn't ship RISC until 01985, in the form of the janky MIPS R2000; ARM 2 and Fujitsu's SPARC MB86900 didn't ship until 01986.
Frank T. Cary and John R. Opel, who led IBM at the time, couldn't care less who young engineers in 02022 revere. Not only are they both dead, but also even at the time their objective was making a lot of money, not fostering engineering excellence, or garnering admiration for their minions.
- sennight 4y agoI won't pretend to have enough familiarity with the goings on in long past IBM management to be able to state with any authority what they may or may not have thought, but I'd be surprised if your single-minded characterization was close to accurate. If you read through the very long list of IBM published papers - you'll see that a lot of them covered novel solutions to real problems of the day that IBM was selling solutions for, in enough detail to save potential competitors a lot of time. That is a calculated risk that they've made for a long time (until pretty recently). It isn't difficult making the business case for what I've proposed... rumor has it that even Intel has recognized how badly they screwed themselves over by treating senior engineers as poorly as they did in the late 90s. The whole imperative to recruit motivated talent isn't a new thing that started with Google's masseuses and sous-chefs, R&D heavy industries have been mindful of the advertising value in publishing for a long time.
- kragen 4y agoOh, I absolutely believe that IBM researchers wanted to share their findings, and that IBM's management was to some extent willing to tolerate them doing so. But I don't think IBM's management (post-Watson at least) saw that as a benefit of having researchers, but rather a necessary cost, one they successfully curtailed during the 01970s. And I don't think IBM's management cared one way or the other what engineers outside IBM thought of it. But none of them were my personal friends, so I might be inferring wrongly from their behavior. Their behavior was pretty egregious, though!