5 ms·
"Lew ended up returning Adelstein his chips, saying she had been "threatened" - something Adelstein denied." This seems like a very suspect thing to do in my o
by dylan604 4y ago
"Lew ended up returning Adelstein his chips, saying she had been "threatened" - something Adelstein denied."
This seems like a very suspect thing to do in my opinion. The threats must have been very specific and meaningful for me to even consider returning chips that I was claiming to have fairly won. Returning them just seems like a guilty move.
- indigodaddy 4y agoI disagree. A cheater would desperately attempt to latch on to anything they can to show they are not a cheater. So they would generally refuse even more to give back any money and just repeat the “not cheating” mantra ever more and more— and would definitely never give back the money that they cheated so hard to get… just my opinion. The fact that she gives back the money (and I see no reason to disbelieve that she was likely cornered and intimidated in the hallway) shows that she’s not really that concerned about it and doesn’t really even care that much. A cheater would be grasping on to those chips at all costs/odds.
- jstx1 4y agoUnless you're bad at cheating and get caught and then panic. Not everyone has the personality to double down.
- late2part 4y agoI've probably played around 10k hours of poker. On the one hand, crazy shit happens all the time, and folks win by sucking out or by insane bluffs. On the other hand, it's not considered honorable to win by mistake. Winning by catching a 3% is luck - but just screwing up isn't cool. So, even though $130k (or whatever it was) seems like a lot of money - there is honor among (some/most) poker players, so it seems totally honorable to me that she gave him the money, as she doesn't feel she deserves it. I don't know how she would have cheated. Maybe she did but it doesn't seem to me like she did.
- jstx1 4y agoThe honor thing doesn't play - she doesn't claim that she won by mistake. She claimed that 1) she thought he had ace high (still doesn't make sense to call with j high) 2) she thought she had a 3 (that's when she changed her story after the game) > I don't know how she would have cheated. It's a streamed game, there's an RFID system that reads everyone's cards. You don't need magic to cheat, you just need an inside person.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ScoobleDoodle 4y agoAt the time of calling the all-in, she was more likely to lose. So she would also need to know the next cards to be played. It seems even less likely the house or dealer are in on it. How would RFID know the top cards yet to come? They are still in the deck.
- jstx1 4y ago> At the time of calling the all-in, she was more likely to lose. This is based on the equity shown on the stream which takes into account the dead cards, if you only know the board and their hole cards, she has 54.55% equity. Either way she should call because she needs 40.3% equity to break even (109/(109+161)), any equity more than that is a call and she doesn't need to know what cards will come for that call to be profitable.
- late2part 4y agoTrue - but what a hero call if right!
- dkjaudyeqooe 4y agoThe RFID only works at a few millimeters distance. It's useless when trying to read a deck of cards since you'd get multiple responses and would be unable to determine the order of cards. The inside person doesn't bear scrutiny either. What would this inside person do to pull this off exactly?
- dylan604 4y agoAdmitedly, I have zero experience of this level of cheating, so I honestly don't know what someone would do. However, "from the movies" (ha!) professional cheaters expect to be caught on occasion and consider it cost of doing business. For cards, I'm thinking about Rounders as an example. Hollywood wouldn't lie to us, right?
- thereare5lights 4y agoWoman is confronted by an enraged man threatening her with the “crazy eyes”. How you would react is no where near the standard she would have used.
- dylan604 4y agosadly, yes, this is something I did not consider.
- mellosouls 4y agoIt's also the sort of thing somebody in a panic or under severe stress just because of the pressure of the spotlight and the thought of being thought dishonest might do. Don't underestimate the power of mental self-sabotage of the innocent. Even more so given the power dynamics here.
- dkjaudyeqooe 4y agoThis sort of attitude is how people are wrongly convicted. A person's behaviour can reflect any number of things. Where is there any actual hard evidence of cheating? Or even a practical explanation of how it could be done. Personally, I feel guilty when I'm (wrongly) accused of something merely if it's possible that I could have done it. It makes no sense but that's how my mind works. If it were up to you I'd be convicted every time.
- dylan604 4y agoI'm just saying it looks like a guilty move that would beg for more investigating, so that someone would be convicted on the looks of guilt. People are jumping to conclusions here.
- dkjaudyeqooe 4y agoWhy is it guilty? Someone acts awkward after winning a hand and the answer, or even suggestion, is cheating? Why? That all the skips that she's a woman and the guy who lost was salty as hell and had a menacing attitude. I would not be surprised if this incident ends up with the guy being charged with theft, or coercion, or whatever the relevant crime is.