3 ms·
If the title chosen by The Atlantic author is so objectionable that HN submitter/moderator must change it completely, then why not find a different source with
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y ago
If the title chosen by The Atlantic author is so objectionable that HN submitter/moderator must change it completely, then why not find a different source with a more agreeable title on the same topic. There is no shortage of articles on this case from a variety of sources.
Alternatively, HN could include both the author's title and the "HN title" in its HTML but only display the HN title.
When I extract URLs from HN HTML I tend to ignore the titles and this is one reason why.^1 I am interested in objective identifiers. HN can change the title, but it cannot change the URL.
Someone searching HN by title for an article from a particular publication may not be able to find it as easily as they should. Similarly, someone browsing all submissions from a particular source, looking for a particular title may miss it because the original title has been editorialised.
1. When I retrieve www search results into a custom SERP format, I actually drop everything except the URL. I never see "objectionable" titles.