3 ms·
This is an argument over not fair use, but transformative use. How much transformation of an old thing has to take place before it's a new thing? That's very mu
by Animats 4y ago
This is an argument over not fair use, but transformative use. How much transformation of an old thing has to take place before it's a new thing? That's very much an issue now, because ML systems have become very good at transforming old things into somewhat similar new things.
Classically, such transformation was a lot of work. A standard art-school exercise is to hand-copy a classic painting. Possibly with variations. Because that's quite a bit of work, it generally hasn't raised serious copyright issues. Now, though, it's very easy.
Much music litigation revolves around this. There are only so many note patterns that sound good. Someone has generated all 69 billion possible 8-note melodies and released them into the public domain, just to mess with any claims of melody originality.[1] Images are a bigger space, though.
[1] https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2020/02/whats-the-point-of-writing-every-possible-melody/607120/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2020/02/whats...
- gnicholas 4y agoYeah I was disappointed that the article didn't even mention the fair use factors, or discuss how the upcoming case would affect some but not others of them. For reference, these are the four factors: • the purpose and character of your use • the nature of the copyrighted work • the amount and substantiality of the portion taken • the effect of the use upon the potential market
- 6stringmerc 4y agoThe whole conclusion is putting forward a speculative chilling effect about a case that doesn’t matter to anybody but attorneys and hacks. It’s a tired argument and it’s not only lazy but easy to disprove.
- WalterBright 4y agoYeah, should probably give up on copyrighting sequences of notes. Copyright the arrangements instead. An awful lot of what makes a song good is the arrangement.
- jraph 4y agoI like the idea, but isn't an arrangement a set of sequences of notes assigned to instruments / voices? Fundamentally, a "documented" sequence of notes? (where a note has a duration, an instrument, a start time, a function defining the dynamic, a pitch (possibly a function), possibly an intent, possibly a part of the lyrics if applicable). Where to draw the line?
- egman_ekki 4y agoLet's not forget also about Library of Babel (https://libraryofbabel.info/ https://libraryofbabel.info/) which includes all texts ever written and that will ever be written up to 3200 characters. I truly wonder how that website is allowed to exist and why they don't claim copyright for every other website that has been created since. BTW, it also includes all images: http://babelia.libraryofbabel.info/ http://babelia.libraryofbabel.info/
- charcircuit 4y agoCopyright only protects against copying. Independently coming up with the same thing is not copyright infringement.
- throwie_wayward 4y agobut how do you prove that? seems like in practice it would boil down to whose lawyers are better which is just a proxy for which party has more money.
- PebblesRox 4y agoWhat Colour are your bits? is an interesting look into these concepts: "The scrambled file still has the copyright Colour because it came from the copyrighted input file. It doesn't matter that it looks like, or maybe even is bit-for-bit identical with, some other file that you could get from a random number generator. It happens that you didn't get it from a random number generator. You got it from copyrighted material; it is copyrighted. The randomly-generated file, even if bit-for-bit identical, would have a different Colour." https://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23 https://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23
- vlunkr 4y agoDo you truly wonder that? Unless someone takes legal action fair use doesn’t take effect. Why would anyone bother to take legal action against them? This is essentially an art project.
- egman_ekki 4y ago
- comex 4y ago> This is an argument over not fair use, but transformative use. I’m going to be pedantic, but: as far as US law goes, transformative use isn’t separate from fair use. Rather, transformativeness is a key test used to help establish whether something qualifies as fair use.