3 ms·
It is not about art per se. Art happens to be covered under the same umbrella that researching medicine, writing software, drawing schematics, etc. When the i
by lotsofpulp 4y ago
It is not about art per se. Art happens to be covered under the same umbrella that researching medicine, writing software, drawing schematics, etc.
When the initial cost of production is very, very high and the marginal cost of each additional unit very, very low, copyright is the solution that has so far been found to “work” to incentivize investment- assuming you agree it works. Not that the current implementation is best, especially the length, but the concept.
- WalterBright 4y agoIf copyright laws were removed, would we still have movies that cost $200 million to make? Probably not. Do we really need them? Not really. Cheaper movies would still be made, though. I've seen a lot of low budget movies that were better than the $200m ones. I don't need special effects to enjoy a movie, I need a plot. Check out "Dark Star", made for $50,000. It's far, far better than 95% of the scifi movies out there. Because it had an interesting plot. "Primer" is another example.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoSurely the people that made Primer appreciate that they were able to get some compensation due to anyone not simply being able to copy and distribute it? Otherwise, what is the incentive to do all the work and take the risk to make Primer if it is just going to be on YouTube for the benefit of Alphabet’s ad revenue?
- 8note 4y agoThis assumes that without copyrights, they couldn't get any compensation. However, even today, there are plenty of ways to make money from a creative work. Eg. Product placement, patronage, or a subscription service
- WalterBright 4y agoYoutube hosts a billion videos where 99.9999999999% of the creators had no hope of recompense. The same goes for books and music. Here's a good reason: the movie itself is an advertisement. For example, Michael Jackson hired a famous movie director to create his music videos. What where those videos for? Advertising for his live concerts which were huge money makers.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoAnd 99.999999999% of YouTube is not worth my time. Quality takes effort and talent, and putting a carrot at the end of the stick makes sense to me to incentivize expending effort and developing talent. Especially for media where the probability of success is very low. Movies might be advertisements in conjunction with just being a movie, but the creators’ multiple intentions do not seem relevant in this case.
- WalterBright 4y agoThe "advertisement" in the movie may be simply promoting the careers of those involved in its production. For a related example, my dad wrote a book. The royalties were well into "not worth it", but he wrote the book to advance his professional prestige, and it worked for that. Most authors of technical books, for example, fall into that category. A director might want to make a movie to raise his market value in producing media for corporations, who have a constant need of such. Actors will do it for free just to be famous, which leads to all kinds of opportunities. Just look how the Star Trek TOS actors made a living off of their fame, and ST was a really low budget operation.
- hakfoo 4y agoIt probably also gets favoured because it tends to fit into the Western mindset of "bottom-up" and "self-bootstrapped" decision making. An alternative, for example: we could take the same amount of money being spent on creative works, absorb it through taxes instead, and redistribute it through a state-managed endowment system. The amount of money we spend for one Mick Jagger would probably fund quite a few musicians with a 70k/year stipend and an obligation to perform shows/generate recordings/etc. But to pull that off, you'd need some sort of formal arbitrator to decide who is "enough" of an artist/scientist/etc. to qualify for an endowment. I know there's a very strong attitude of 'you can't regulate what art is', seemingly used to justify charging seven figure prices for products that look suspiciously like they were fished out of the local preschool's recycling bin.