15 ms·
> No, they also need a platform to make people aware of their existence, their views, and to recast their censorship to be in their favour. The whole point of n
by pessimizer 4y ago
> No, they also need a platform to make people aware of their existence, their views, and to recast their censorship to be in their favour. The whole point of no-platforming individuals is to make a statement that their views are seen as reprehensible and to stop them from being able to air those views to an audience.
The only way that this works is to exert total control of the content of all communications.
Otherwise, as in the real world until now, people find each other and network. You're talking about destroying freedom of association and expression in order to root out reprehensible people with the wrong values who could speak to people who want to listen to them.
- wcerfgba 4y agoDoesn't freedom of association also entail freedom of non-association? If an organisation doesn't want to provide an individual with a platform, then they are executing their freedom of association. I'm not advocating for some global censorship entity.
- zdragnar 4y agoFreedom of (non) association does not extend to protected groups in public spaces. Businesses can no longer exclusively serve white people, for example, since their stores are considered public accomodations. Ideology is not a protected class, however. In the case of Haidt, they are free to not present any research at conferences unless it advances their definition of equity, and he has no choice but to go along with it or walk away. It's worth pointing out that they are not explicitly turning down non-equity-focused research, but that the existence of the question is his interpretation of an ideological pressure to conform.
- dillondoyle 4y agoThat freedom of public accommodation is under attack. If it even existed in the first place; there are plenty of laws that expressly allow discrimination in deference to 'religious beliefs.' Courts, & the Supreme Court in particular, are giving far more weight to 'christian freedom' at the expense of the rest of us. Cases include recent PrEP ruling, insane football prayer ruling that willfully ignored facts, bathroom & sports laws targeting kids. crazy ruling on prayers in court. Adoption discrimination (de-facto govt by transitive property. we have to stop outsourcing government to contractors, especially when it makes religious orgs the only avenue). Upcoming ruling from CO which will probably allow even more queer discrimination. that 'pressure to conform' is and has historically been one way, giving one class the legal go ahead to discriminate in the name of some skewed idea of christian ideals
- zdragnar 4y agoReligious (non) belief is itself a protected class. If it were not, mosques would be legally compelled to hire rabbis and churches would have to consider hiring druids for services. Where the line ought to be drawn is nowhere near as obvious as you seem to think it should be.
- dillondoyle 4y agoI'm referencing the many other classes that are perfectly legal to discriminate against. and the allowable discrimination is becoming broader. But this disagreement highlights this major problem the US faces. We live in two increasingly separate realities with different 'facts', where obvious is totally different based on your identity. the one religious non-belief class example I gave is the football coach prayer case. to me it's an obvious overreach and clearly breaks secular education norms (and past scotus rulings). to such an obvious degree that the minority (on the court, majority in public opinion) broke precedence and put photos directly refuting the 'facts' the majority claim are truth. that's also a bit spurious. i don't think anyone is arguing that churches must be forced to interview (or hire) other religions. but the majority does believe that the state & courts shouldn't create laws that expressly allows someone to discriminate or refuse to provide service to someone else just because they are gay or trans or use different pronouns. or deny an adoption. or disallow kids from playing incredibly low states high school sports. or ban books. or not talk about gender & sexuality. i keep using queer-centric issues because that's my identity and I can speak to it better than race/trans issues. there are plenty of examples there too. it's minority religion dictating laws that affect our lives and explicitly allowing those beliefs to take away rights from the rest of us.
- hackerlight 4y ago
- thisiscorrect 4y ago>Ideas, especially those that stoke resentments, are like viruses. The problem is that people make statements like this but apply them selectively. E.g., platforms like major news networks are happy to give airtime to the claim that people alive today, who never owned slaves and are very likely not descended from anyone who did, must pay reparations to others alive today who were never enslaved and may well not be descended from slaves. These same platforms also give airtime to those claiming all societal ills stem from one ethnic group or another (as long as it's the "right" ethnic group being blamed). This incredibly skewed double standard isn't fooling anyone.
- hackerlight 4y agoHow is this relevant to the question of whether censorship is effective?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gadflyinyoureye 4y agoBecause one measure of effectiveness can be equality of application.
- ovao 4y agoAnother measure might be the extent to which it leads to an unequal distribution of knowledge. Censorship can be seen as means of preventing misinformation, and sometimes quite effective at that, but a potential negative byproduct is limiting the output of (interpretable) factual information.
- tsol 4y ago>I'm not saying that censorship is just or desirable. Just that it works. Does it though? Ideas are hard to kill. Just because you stop people from saying something in public, does not mean they aren't talking about it in private. In fact, oftentimes people even assume the thing you can't talk about must be really important or else they'd let you talk about it. And in turn, it holds more powerful and spreads further. I don't think censorship is really effective at stopping ideas You say ideas are like viruses. Since when has trying to stop viruses worked?
- lkrubner 4y ago> You're talking about destroying freedom of association and expression in order to root out reprehensible people with the wrong values We all have a strong moral obligation to root out "reprehensible people with the wrong values." If you think otherwise then you don't understand what the word "reprehensible" means.
- sneak 4y agoFundamental attribution error. There are no reprehensible people, there are only reprehensible deeds.
- lkrubner 4y agoI envy your innocence, but sadly, the world has many reprehensible people in it.
- mqnfred 4y agoThere are indeed people who repeatedly perform reprehensible deeds.
- Slava_Propanei 4y ago
- pessimizer 4y agoThat's an excuse to dehumanize people. Labeling people rather than deeds is simply an announcement that you're willing to compromise your own ethics in order to attack that person. It's what's really happening when we label people as terrorists.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pharrington 4y agoDo you believe terrorists exist? If no, would you say that Osama Bin Laden was not a terrorist?
- deepl_derber 4y ago>The only way that this works is to exert total control of the content of all communications. Not true! Just being banned from significant swaths of social media has frequently forced many prominent Nazis/alt-righters out of business. Before Kiwifarms recently had all of their major issues, they were already finding it difficult to keep the site running as a result of continued pressure on every host they switched to.
- LawTalkingGuy 4y agoRegardless of the accuracy of your classification of KiwiFarms, they aren't gone, just moved into the onion. And for conspiracy-minded people that's not a negative sign. It also introduces readers to the entirety of the uncensored internet all at once, the most 4-chan thing imaginable, which is somewhat counter to the "limit exposure to disinformation" goal being claimed by the original deplatformers.
- deepl_derber 4y ago>Regardless of the accuracy of your classification of KiwiFarms, they aren't gone, just moved into the onion. And that substantially reduces their reach and ability to disseminate their garbage. It's good. And yes, they're a bunch of Nazi stooges.