2 ms·
> in cases like this the judgment relies on a subjective analysis by the person(s) doing the judging and that everyone's subjective judgement is different, more
by pessimizer 4y ago
> in cases like this the judgment relies on a subjective analysis by the person(s) doing the judging and that everyone's subjective judgement is different, moreover, to further complicate matters, such differences are likely to alter over time.
I agree with you 100%. My judgement of lack of resemblance is based more on whether I imagine that the same person would want to use both in the same context, not on anything that I think anyone should respect. I just don't think you can draw a line. We need to move to a model where we are openly, explicitly granting and enforcing monopolies on the production of certain works in return for some societal benefit. Not just assuming that society always benefits when monopolies on reproduction are granted.
If we don't want whales to rush in and capture all of the profits when somebody produces a creative work, we can target that situation explicitly, rather than pretending that qualifications for being worth protecting are inherent in the work, rather than a legal construct. A pretension that creates a situation where a defense of the series of disposable Warhols can be to denigrate the photograph that they chose to base the series on. Judges and juries as art critics, trying to figure out how much of Blurred Lines is Marvin Gaye.
- hilbert42 4y ago"We need to move to a model where we are openly, explicitly granting and enforcing monopolies on the production of certain works in return for some societal benefit. Not just assuming that society always benefits when monopolies on reproduction are granted." Yeah, right. See my reply to Worldblender, it's my more detailed and pessimistic take on things.