6 ms·
Meet Silicon Valley’s rattled layoff ‘survivors’
- koinedad 4y agoThis is a real concern, reminds me of: https://technicallychallenged.substack.com/p/to-those-that-choose-to-stay-a-tech https://technicallychallenged.substack.com/p/to-those-that-c...
- bitlax 4y agohttps://archive.ph/cjSR4 https://archive.ph/cjSR4
- Overtonwindow 4y ago
- djohnston 4y agoWhy is getting better benefits and perks deemed worthy of derision rather than an admission that most employees in the world are treated like garbage? They aren't being completely exploited by their companies so they deserve to be taken down a peg to the sorry state you're in?
- sseagull 4y agoFor me, it's not necessarily derision, but lack of sympathy is natural. If someone in my community (say a teacher) is making 45k a year, and they get laid off through no fault of their own, I will feel sympathy. They were contributing to the community as best they could, they were important, and now they are possibly struggling financially. A developer making $300k? Working for an ad company? Not too much sympathy - they will probably be okay. People here usually brag about how much they make and how easy it is to find a job, anyway. On top of that, there is this perception (not necessarily reality, but there is a kernel of truth) that California in particular has an outsized influence on the rest of the country, and does not really respect the beliefs of large swaths of our culture. You have corporations making unfathomable amounts of money dictating communications, interactions, etc, all from the silicon tower in California. That is a recipe for derision, whether it's logical or not.
- kcplate 4y ago> A developer making $300k? Working for an ad company? Not too much sympathy I have no sympathy for the person laid off or the survivor if they are in a role commanding that level of wage. If you are pushing $300k in salary, you should be able to financially handle a layoff or if you survive the cut— just buck it up, put your head down, and power your way through a leaner operation. Honestly, I feel like anyone complaining about being a tech layoff survivor must have never worked outside of tech before. I worked in an industrial laundry in college, I can assure you the very worst day I had sitting at a desk typing code into a keyboard for a fat salary was exponentially better than the very best day I had loading dirty shop rags and diapers into a washing machine for minimum wage.
- yobbo 4y agoI think he's making the point that SV layoffs are not worthy of more sympathy than other layoffs, but maybe less.
- Firmwarrior 4y agoIf this were a Reddit thread or a Facebook thread I'd agree with him, but it's a thread on a site for those SV engineers to hang out. So I don't think every article and comment here should be required to kowtow to Overtonwindow and the Reddit/Twitter/Tumblr users' demands to apologize for our success Getting laid off or being in a company with layoffs sucks even if you're making a lot of money. Especially for younger engineers where this is their introduction to this particular harsh reality
- mmmpop 4y agoYeah but for whatever elite Stanford rich kid CS grad strawman you have invented for this uh... person experiencing laidoffness, have you considered that this imaginary person probably kept their job and the try-hards like basically all of the rest of us got the shaft? These are unlikely the spoiled brats you're envisioning.
- AtlasBarfed 4y agoThe current generation has been comprehensively screwed by the baby boomer generation, to perverse degrees. There should be rabid riots in the street over it, there sure as hell are ones in other parts of the world. But I don't shed tears for silicon valley workers that didn't ferret away money in the boom. These are not the people that got screwed by the modern American wealth distribution. You're allegedly the smartest people in the world, and you can't read the history of your industry going back even 20 years to the dot Bomb?
- djohnston 4y ago> You're allegedly the smartest people in the world, and you can't read the history of your industry going back even 20 years to the dot Bomb? Even the most intelligent person can't consistently predict the market. Even if you could, and you knew the market was going to pop, what are you going to do? Leave one of these behemoths for a smaller company that's less likely to survive a recession? Or are you suggesting they caused the current downtown?
- tjr225 4y ago
- AzzieElbab 4y agoWell, we should all be very very worried when companies with 1m profit per employee start laying people off. Excesses of SV aren’t really relevant from my point of view
- MikeTheRocker 4y agoAgreed. Tech workers at large companies often earn income commensurate with the economic value they produce. When each employee nets the company 7 figures on average, it's hard to make a case that they shouldn't earn some meaningful fraction of that IMO.
- dasil003 4y ago“Should” doesn’t really enter into it though. And in any case it’s impossible to attribute impact in that way since the money tends to come from a few huge engines that are not sensitive to individual hires. At the end of the day, tech salaries are a market like any other—driven by what competitors are willing to pay, not by what is “fair”
- lmeyerov 4y agoThe economic value isn't measured in revenue but the stock price, which you get paid your bigger bucks in. Their stock dropped 86% over the last year, so market value per engineer is not the same. Compensation was made with that in mind. I doubt existing salary compensation will go down -- the best will leave, or even ask for stock refreshers in stock side to stay -- so now it is dog eat dog. You are right wrt revenue focus though. Recent Series A/B unicorns will have 100+ employees, but at 20-100X valuation multiple on not that much revenue, so valuation coming down to levels of 5 years ago (which were still frothy!) hurts more bc little revenue to fall back on should a down/bridge round not work out. We are still a year out from many of these being forced, but many smart people at these shops are already (secretly) on the job market.
- nytesky 4y agoI thought a company like Snap didn’t make a profit, so I dont think the employees are netting 7 figures for the company? That probably only applies to Google, FB, Apple, Amazon?
- dzink 4y agoAfter a layoff, a lot of the best people among the remaining staff end up leaving as well. In addition to the extra work, the workplace acquires a bunch of mental tombstones of a time that would never repeat itself. If you are any good, that lowers the threshold of reasons not to quit, and the upside of quitting remains untouched (higher salary, new experiences, better title elsewhere, more learning). The reasons to stay have to increase to compensate - equity, vesting, higher title, etc. The people who stay have to be the ones you actually want to work with as well.
- SanjayMehta 4y agoThe best people leave first, triggering the death spiral.
- 300bps 4y agoAfter a layoff, a lot of the best people among the remaining staff end up leaving as well Agreed. But I was always the one that stayed. I remember in 1999 when our company got acquired by another company and started doing layoffs - I had a very good friend that chose to leave the company at that point because things were going to be very difficult for a while. The company they went to turned out to be so much worse though while I made out very well by staying. This pattern has repeated several times in my career.
- angarg12 4y agoPeople have had 10 year careers in tech thinking the world is a permanent bull market. I can imagine how this feels like the world is collapsing around them. For those of us who have weathered previous recessions, we know the world moves on. Things will be rough, for a while, we will rebound, and hopefully we will thrive again. I feel the current situation is more representative of the long term job market than the last few exuberant years.
- bitexploder 4y agoYoung, bright, engineers fresh out of college sliding into a big tech firm making 300k-500k / year and being told they are the most important resource in the universe. If you started this train 3-5 years ago you probably just assumed the gravy train would never stop. I really hope they squirreled away some of those $$ and then moved to a low cost of living area during the pandemic. I have some sympathy, but it made the tech universe warp around their stock prices. It was very hard to recruit when all the best and above average talent just got sucked up into the giant companies that build advertising machines in SV.
- NeverFade 4y agoFresh-out-of-college engineers weren't making $300k, let alone $500k. I'm not sure where you got these numbers. Even at the highest paying BigN, fresh grads don't typically get over $200k. > It was very hard to recruit when all the best and above average talent just got sucked up into the giant companies that build advertising machines in SV. The talent crunch has been getting worse for the past couple of decades. Don't expect this bear market to be some sort of cataclysmic change that would reverse the trend permanently, not anymore than 2008 was. Even 2001 only lasted for a fairly short while, and demand for top tech talent back then was a tiny fraction of what it is now. That, essentially, is why this crunch exists: the number of highly talented engineers has remained about the same for decades, while demand skyrocketed. Also, what other companies stand ready to receive all this "above average" talent? Small companies, which in this market, are having an even tougher time? BigN by and large haven't gone through massive layoffs, while small and medium-sized companies are getting massacred. Like Snap which lost 90% of its value. Startups are in an even worse spot. Funding is going to be very tough for the next couple of years, and startups have been extremely stingy with their equity. That's why they're having trouble recruiting: BigN are paying far better, while startup are much riskier, and if they do succeed, there's very little upside for engineers who are granted ridiculously small amounts of equity. I wouldn't hold my breath for all these "above average" talents being desperate enough to accept bad deals from startups that don't want to give out equity, nor is that a desirable outcome of this situation. Startups should either start granting more equity, or start gasp targeting less talented people.
- boffinism 4y ago> The situation is bad enough that the Snap employee said they’d considered quitting since then. So, only bad enough that an employee might consider quitting? That... really suggests it's not a particularly bad situation.
- nathanvanfleet 4y agoOr that... people don't have many other opportunities in this economy?
- dasil003 4y ago> from a Snap survivor: ”So it’s frustrating; they expect us to still go out and win with these products, yet we have fewer resources.” I don’t know what function this is it their manager is telling them, but this quote really reflects a bull market mentality that success is a function of resources applied without acknowledging the inefficiency of throwing money at a problem. People who want to be successful over the next 5 years really should be thinking in terms of how to operate efficiently and leverage what they do have. I think a lot of young VC-funded tech workers misunderstand how elastic resourcing actually can be in the software world, and how much past resourcing was speculative and incremental-not essential.
- darkerside 4y agoThis is so well said.
- duxup 4y agoAmen. I work at a small shop, 3.5 devs. That presents limits to some extent. And yet we were faster and more flexible than a company who had wads of cash thrown at them by some parent company who is now shutting them down.
- vxNsr 4y agoI’d love to meet this half person
- luckylion 4y agoI'm overweight and count as 1.5 developers.
- HomeDeLaPot 4y agoI gained 80 pounds last year and got a 50% raise!
- hotpotamus 4y agoThe phrase "half-assed job" must have come from somewhere.
- orzig 4y agoExperienced 'survivor' here: You're going to feel (and sometimes be explicitly told) that your stress is not valid, because others have it worse. Both these things can be true. Others have it worse, and the stress you're feeling is real. If you don't acknowledge the effects and act on them (in whatever way works for you), you will undergo entirely avoidable suffering. Again, others might be suffering more, but nobody wins when you self-flagellate. If, in addition to taking care of your health, you want to take action on suffering, there are many options. I recommend considering an expansive moral circle and checking out: https://www.givewell.org/ https://www.givewell.org/
- mancerayder 4y agoI've met, lately, a really massive number of people who work in tech companies but say they work in "marketing" or "branding." I'm not really sure what they do exactly, but I think it's to do with the amount of money in the ad tech business that drives profit for the likes of G, FB, etc. I guess decisions have to be made on product strategy, I suppose meetings with clients to discuss ad spend. Question is doesn't that capital spend dry during recessionary times?
- chevman 4y agoMarketing, sales, branding, etc are the ones who largely are doing the work to scale these companies. Ad dollars are one mechanism to grow reach across audiences, and those teams are the ones helping to make it actually happen. And yes, marketing/ad budgets will likely get cut across all sectors (some more than others) during a recession. It's one line item among many that companies will flex up or down depending on macroeconomic conditions, as well as the position/health of their individual firm.
- b1gnasty 4y agoLayoffs aren't what are "rattling" folks in this industry, at least not the tech folks outside of FAANG. If you've worked in startup land, you've experienced layoffs. Probably multiple rounds. You anticipate them, and they aren't scary because the market for your skills is so competitive. Our "Job Security" comes from the overall state of the hiring market, not finding a job at the most stable company and putting in 30 before retiring. If folks are rattled, its because of the state of the job market, something I'm actually curious about. Reporting on this would have actual value, as I'm still getting recruiter emails from many of the recent companies that have publicly said they are freezing/slowing down hiring and from many, many startups. This article just reads like schadenfreude for the majority of tech workers who have never experienced the job security of being at a giant engine growth that never stalled once for 10-15 years.
- hotpotamus 4y ago> I'm still getting recruiter emails from many of the recent companies that have publicly said they are freezing/slowing down hiring I wonder what a recruiter at a company with a hiring freeze in place is expected to do? I'd be inclined to say, "well then I'll be on vacation until you need me, thanks for keeping the paychecks coming", but I suspect that wouldn't work so well. I think they would want to "keep the pipeline flowing" or however you'd want to say it for a mix of practical as well as BS reasons.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- fragmede 4y agoFired, probably. Recruiting, as a department, is unfortunately seen as expendable and the pipeline doesn't need to flow. Not that I think that's a smart decision.
- paleotrope 4y agoMost tech recruiters seem to be recent college grades that have a string of a couple 6-12 month gigs before they move on. I am not really sure how any of these provide any value to the companies that hire them.
- perfecthjrjth 4y agohttps://archive.ph/LF895 https://archive.ph/LF895
- pyuser583 4y agoWhen I was let go, I had to go through a whole procedure of giving back IDs, being debriefed, etc. It was emotionally hard. After it was over I found myself, outside the entrance to the building, with no way in. I reached into my pocket, and realized I left my keys inside at my old desk. There’s a procedure for letting in visitors, but it takes a long time. When I went to the receptionist to explain the situation, I was immediately buzzed in, and walked back to my desk to receive the keys. That meant a lot. I’m sure there was a security person watching me on video, but that’s a resource intensive courtesy. Now is the time to be nice. It’s a time for empathy. Make it a point to get together outside work. Invite folks laid off. Invite contractors. Make it clear they’re still “part of the club.” People appreciate this, and in the long run it pays off.
- five82 4y agoFive years ago I was working for a large tech company and things were going downhill quickly in our division due to a failed acquisition. We were a very tight knit team that made a point to stick together, meet up regularly outside work, and help each other out through layoffs, departures, and other chaos. I owe my former co-workers a huge debt of gratitude for their help in getting my current job.
- sys_64738 4y ago> Twilio, which laid off roughly 800 employees in September, took steps to ease the blow for employees being let go. Laid off employees received 12 weeks of severance pay, plus an additional week for every year worked at Twilio, and their stock will vest for one more scheduled vesting period. For a lot of folk, this type of severance will make them leave with a smile.