2 ms·
>wanted it against the law for people to cover his songs without his permission IANAL but note that covering a song is not fair use. However, with music specif
by ghaff 4y ago
>wanted it against the law for people to cover his songs without his permission
IANAL but note that covering a song is not fair use. However, with music specifically, it is (normally/always?) possible to pay for a mechanical license [1] which allows a musician to pay to cover a song. The same concept does not apply to many other types of creative works. For example, a playwright can (and many do) refuse to allow their work to be performed by amateur theater companies or to have the content modified.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mechanical_license https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mechanical_license
- aliqot 4y agoYou are correct however there is a grey area if they claim it is parody. As a cover it is not fair use.
- ghaff 4y agoYes, parody/satire is often a difficult case, e.g. https://constitutioncenter.org/blog/dr.-seuss-in-the-land-of-fair-use-lawsuits https://constitutioncenter.org/blog/dr.-seuss-in-the-land-of... Just playing off some well-known characters or some defining characteristic of a work doesn't necessarily constitute fair use although judges seem to often disagree on the particulars.
- 6stringmerc 4y agoCorrect, but Prince also denied each request by Weird Al - Weird Al had every legal right to release them but he chose not to because he is a class act, unlike doctor shopping selfish Prince Rogers Nelson.
- 6stringmerc 4y agoPrince wanted the mechanical license mechanism to go away completely for everyone because he didn’t like it. That’s what I’m talking about - he sued over the dancing baby which helped build support for fair use. This article is the same crap Masnik said about Blurred Lines that it would kill creativity and the author should be admonished for such easily disproven pearl clutching FUD.
- jsmith45 4y agoIt is also worth remembering that a mechanical license is limited. It allows you to perform a work yourself (privately) to create a new audio recording of that work[1]. What is known as a "cover". But other than sell the new cover audio as CD, mp3, etc, or have it get played on the radio or audio streaming services, there is not much more you can do. It does not allow your cover band to perform the work publicly. (Normally this gets covered by the venue, either via ASCPA/BMI licensing, or via individual negotiation with the rights-holder, but in some cases, like temporary venue fully orgnaized by the band, the band may need to acquire such rights.) Remember that any form of live-streaming is also public performance. It does not allow your cover band to create a music video, or to use your cover recording as background music in a video you create. (For either of these you need a "synchronization license" that the work holder can simply refuse, and there is no simplified ASCAP-like mechanism for handling these negotiations) It may also surprise many to learn that recording artists are not technically entitled to royalties for use of their songs over the radio. Indeed, recording artists of any kind[2] only get royalties for digital music transmission when certain exemptions don't apply, and get no protection at all for non-digital transmission.[3] The whole music copyright system is basically a giant mess, and does not work how a reasonable person would expect it to work. Footnotes: [1] Or to duplicate an existing audio recording if you also have permission of owner of the copyright for that particular audio recording. [2] unless they happen to be the musical work copyright holder as well, which is not uncommon, but hardly universal. [3] Realistically they were only granted this digital public performance right, because a digital transmission of a digitally recorded phonorecord is hard to distinguish from copying said phonorecord.