15 ms·
AI experts pan Tesla’s humanoid robot reveal: ‘next level cringeworthy’
- mort96 4y agoI wish this was a good critique of Optimus. But this is repeating a couple of witty quips from random people on Twitter. Is this journalism?
- ramblerman 4y agoIt was written by media experts so it must be.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- _ph_ 4y agoI really don't get all the critique of the Tesla bot. Yes, it isn't even close to a finished product. But it isn't meant to be. Not yet. But it is the development platform for an upcoming product. And like with software production, there is nothing as valuable as a working prototype which you can use to test all the aspects of the ongoing development. They also showed the second generation robot, with a lot of improvements. Most of all, in house designed actuators which are fit for industrial production. Because that is the goal for Tesla: to eventually sell it. In numbers, at a reasonable price. Part of the purpose of the event was to attract new developers. So any of the Ph.Ds who think they can do better: apply at Tesla! Also the comments about the finger count were revealing. They don't grasp the ambition of Tesla. They are not trying to quickly get a new warehouse robot to the market, their end-game is the fully humanoid robot. That means 5 fingers. And a real AI for guiding the actions. Like with FSD, Tesla is betting big time that they can get reasonably close.
- V__ 4y agoThe goal is to tingle the next shiny thing in front of investors to somehow keep the stock evaluation.
- DoesntMatter22 4y agoIt's such a silly complaint. They've only had a working model for 6 months. Boston dynamics been at it 30 years almost. Also Tesla bot doesn't ever need to do backflips so they are closer than ppl realize already
- iudqnolq 4y ago> They've only had a working model for 6 months. Why should I take that into account? This isn't school.
- mwint 4y agoVelocity is relevant.
- iudqnolq 4y agoLet's discuss it then, then. Velocity at outliers has little explanatory value.
- DoesntMatter22 4y agoWhat does school have to do with anything? In a short time they have made tremendous progress which will obviously only continue.
- dragontamer 4y agoThe Tesla bot was wheeled out on stage by three people, because the team wasn't sure if it could walk on its own. Meanwhile, Boston Dynamics bot is doing backflips, and Disney's superhero bot is doing stunts for it's movies / theme parks live. Tesla bot can't even walk, but there are two robotics groups (Disney Theme parks and Boston Dynamics) who were ahead years ago. -------- If you wanna impress people who have been looking at bots for the last 10 years, you have to at least have the thing walk out on stage on its own feet.
- _ph_ 4y agoNo, it wasn't. That was the second gen bot which isn't fully operational yet. The first gen model walked onto the stage without support.
- dragontamer 4y ago> So any of the Ph.Ds who think they can do better: apply at Tesla! Why not Boston Dynamics, who are clearly much further in this process and have much more expertise? There's Boston Dynamics "Spot" that's clearing mines in Ukraine right now. How long will it be before this Tesla-bot can do what Spot does today? Why would a Ph.D join a group with only a few months of experience, when a true expert is making revolutionary robots exists elsewhere? Ph.D want to learn from others, not be the smartest person in the room. ------- Lets look at a 2018-era (4 years ago) demo from Spot: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wXxrmussq4E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wXxrmussq4E Spot, years ago, could open a door by itself. How long before the Tesla-bot can do that? Why would any Ph.D want to be working on an already solved problem (solved years ago by Boston Dynamics), when they could just join Boston Dynamics and learn from the experts directly?
- iancmceachern 4y agoOr Honda, they already made one of these, and did it well. Then they canned the project because there is no commercial value. There is no need for a humanoid robot, a regular wheeled one will do and is 10% of the cost.
- neither_color 4y agoBoston Dynamics clearly has talent but it doesn't seem they've found that market fit yet. Softbank and Google both sold Boston Dynamics. It's not some scrappy startup, it's on its third multinational acquisition by now.
- aaron695 4y ago
- JediLuke 4y ago
- panick21_ 4y agoThis is kind of an absurd premise? There are not that many companies working on this kind of Robotics, are you seriously suggest all US talent in the field should go to Boston Dynamics? Boston Dynamics simply has a different focus. They focus is not mass production of humanoid robots for everyday use. Their primary concern is not using their mass manufacture and self driving expertise to mass produce robots. Tesla is expert in electronics and their robot is driven by electric actuators while Boston Dynamics seems to use a lot of hydraulics. Hydraulics are like better in some ways but also likely harder to mass produce. Multiple companies working on these topics is a good thing in my opinion. > Ph.D want to learn from others, not be the smartest person in the room. If Tesla has the funding to heir people, do research and build many robots then what's the issue? You don't get people with experience and you don't get teams with experience unless you start building things. I'm sure there are people who would like an opportunity to be in a leading position in such a project. Even when in theory there are other projects that are 'more advanced'.
- lm28469 4y agoThe thing is of all the things Musk promised over the last decade literally nothing happened. Remember the fully autonomous vehicle "by next year" in 2013 ? The boring company solving your commute issues by 2020 ? The 500 000 first fully autonomous tesla S of 2020 that were supposed to be sold to uber ? The cyber truck which is "just around the corner" ? This guy is selling dreams, I can guarantee you in 10 years we still won't have fully autonomous teslas, anything close to a proper robot or underground highways made by the boring company other than a few demos to milk the last investors who still believe in him
- uup 4y agoI agree that it’d be nice if he could deliver on more of his promises, but selling dreams is basically the job of upper management. Also, most other companies promise really mundane and uninteresting things. Sure, they deliver, but it’s still not much fun.
- dragontamer 4y ago> but selling dreams is basically the job of upper management. And evaluating the dreams and funding them is the job of investors. Just following the hype betrays your own money, your own agency, and possibly makes the world a worse place. (The Hyperloop myth has only served to hamper high-speed rail adoption) We all know this is a big advertisement for Tesla's stock, and maybe advertisements for workers to join Tesla. Now we can discuss if its worthwhile for shareholders and/or engineers to consider what was seen here.
- panick21_ 4y ago> The Hyperloop myth has only served to hamper high-speed rail adoption One guy wrote a badly sourced article claiming this and now its a proven fact. Its total nonsense. Even if you believe that Hyperloop was some 4D chess against HDR (and it wasn't) then its still insane to suggest it has anything to do with the problems of HSR. The HSR project started in the 90s and has been struggling the whole time. Blaming a few statements by Musk made in 2014 that 99% of the population no nothing about is delusional. HSR funding wasn't cut because of Hyperloop. Literally no California government action happened because of Hyperloop. I seriously think you are letting your dislike for Musk overwhelm basic logic.
- bergenty 4y agoWhat a stupid article. To be honest I was impressed considering this is less than 1 year of work.
- sidcool 4y agoIt was experimental unveiling for attracting talent. The article is more "cringey".
- mumumu 4y agoPeople are missing the point. The robot is a plataform to evaluate the generalization of their new ML architecture. The benchmark shouldn't be BD or Honda, but Google and Disney who have shown (non humanoid) robots doing similar things. Of course, it is ok to discuss the mechatronics, but as many pointed out, making them is a solved problem.
- dragontamer 4y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ENa98h7M7qY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ENa98h7M7qY https://la.disneyresearch.com/stuntronics/ https://la.disneyresearch.com/stuntronics/ Okay, lets compare this bot to Disney's bot. From 4 years ago, which is used to make movies and/or Disney Theme Park attractions.
- microtherion 4y agoThe way that making self driving cars was a "solved problem" according to Musk in (checks notes) 2015? https://fortune.com/2015/03/18/tesla-elon-musk-and-nvidia-ceoself-driving-cars/ https://fortune.com/2015/03/18/tesla-elon-musk-and-nvidia-ce...
- ozzythecat 4y ago> “None of this is cutting edge,” tweeted robotics expert Cynthia Yeung. “Hire some PhDs and go to some robotics conferences Tesla.” And this is exactly the problem created by social media. I don’t care for Musk or any other tech celebrity, visionary, billionaire, or however you want to describe them. But why does some demo have to be so extremely impressive? How is this newsworthy? The real problem here is social media. Every toxic, awful loon is out getting their negativity and grievances amplified 1000x.
- fastball 4y agoThe biggest element I think people are underestimating is Tesla's level of vertical integration in 2022. Boston Dynamics has no large scale production facilities to speak of. They have not invested millions in ML hardware/software/training architecture. They have not developed their own electric actuators designed to be produced cheaply and at scale (in factories they already own). They are not sourcing their own lithium for batteries. etc. etc. A big reason Tesla is entering this space is because a huge amount of the things needed to make a functional android that can work in a factory they are/were already doing. There are so many synergies it would be stupid for them not to try something like this. And this is a decent amount of progress for less than a year, to the point where I'd be surprised if this didn't cause some BD people to swap teams. And BD being "ahead" isn't the dig people seem to think it is. BD being ahead just means there is a benchmark Tesla knows they can get to with current technology and (probably) surpass. Saying BD is ahead is like saying Lockheed Martin/Boeing were ahead of SpaceX in 2009 – trivially true but woefully shortsighted.
- microtherion 4y agoActual robotics experts seem to think that the design, particularly the actuators, is fundamentally flawed and cut some corners that won't be particularly easy to un-cut on the way to an actual product: https://twitter.com/_brohrer_/status/1576368293719736320 https://twitter.com/_brohrer_/status/1576368293719736320
- fastball 4y agoI dunno, SpaceX's Starship was gonna be composite/carbon fiber and then they decided "actually maybe stainless steel is better" and went with that. Which in my humble opinion dwarf's "our actuators need to be better/different" as an engineering decision. If there is one thing Musk's companies seem to have it is a combination of both velocity but also a willingness to go against the resulting momentum if it seems like that velocity is in the wrong direction.