4 ms·
Found the pictures thanks to the link elsethread. To me, the Warhol images are substantially different - the only common element is Prince's features, and pres
by lelanthran 4y ago
Found the pictures thanks to the link elsethread.
To me, the Warhol images are substantially different - the only common element is Prince's features, and presumably that likeness belongs to Prince, not the photographer.
Consider that the photographer isn't the owner of the likeness, and that everything besides the likeness is different, I'd call the Warhol image a substantially different work from the photographer's image.
If the ruling comes down on the side of the photographer there's definitely a chilling effect on the creation of new art.
Other than the likeness (which belongs to Prince), there are no similarities between the images.
- sbuk 4y agoThe problem here is that the likeness is not what is in dispute, and the copyright of a photograph belongs to the photographer. The ruling, like it or not, is entirely correct. It is plain that the Warhol piece is derivative of the photograph.
- lelanthran 4y agoThe argument is not whether it is a derivative (it clearly is), but whether it is so substantially different that fair use applies. Since there are no similarities other than the likeness, I find it hard to sympathise with the photographer's point of view. The difference between the two images is substantial, to me. As a thought experiment, if this was a painting of a disembodied Eiffel tower, would you say that the photographer of an Eiffel tower photo was ripped off? The subject of the image clearly does not belong to the photographer, all the elements in the photo that do were omitted from the painting.
- sbuk 4y agoIt's not that simple. If, like this image, the framing (or in this case, pose), disembodied or not, were identical, the answer is 'yes' the photographer was 'ripped-off'. To counter your thought experiment and your assertion that "...there are no similarities other than the likeness", try super-imposing the images. The framing is identical. See https://ibb.co/wyMdvvd https://ibb.co/wyMdvvd, posted elsewhere in this thread.
- enkrs 4y agoIf I look at the Warhols image I can say: “That’s clearly a Warhol image” I would not say “That’s clearly a pose, framing and likeness done by Goldsmith“. The source photo for the work was just another photo of Prince. To me that is fair use
- sbuk 4y agoThat doesn't mean that there is no value in the original work. It just shows that you are ignorant of the photographers work. That's not meant to be derogatory, just a simple fact. Doesn't change that Warhol should have sought permission either.
- lelanthran 4y ago> That doesn't mean that there is no value in the original work. That's not a claim anyone is making.
- lelanthran 4y ago> It's not that simple. I agree that it isn't that simple. If it were, it would have been settled decades ago. > The framing is identical. Firstly, that isn't what framing means (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Framing_(visual_arts) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Framing_(visual_arts)), and in this case the framing isn't the same, it's radically different. Secondly, assuming it were, then what? There are maybe 25 or so elements of a photo that make a photo unique (framing, composition, lighting, color, grain, etc). Arguing that because one of them (framing) is matched in a painting means that the entire painting needs to license the original doesn't make any sense to me. The only similarity is that the subject is copied very closely, but that element of the photo doesn't belong to the photographer anyway. The only identical bits between the two images is the single thing that isn't owned by either party. When it comes to courts examining copyright infringement (which this would be), they tend to do so very objectively: Each element is examined in isolation, and if there are many identical elements, only then does it make sense to examine the image as a whole. In this case, when it finally gets to trial (if it already hasn't done so), the defense lawyer is going to systematically go through every single element that makes up a photo, and compare that element (hue, for example) to the alleged infringement. The other party is going to stick to the argument that the article presented, namely that it was used as a basis for the painting.
- Aerroon 4y agoPerhaps we should change copyright to only last 5-10 years then.
- etrautmann 4y agoThis is a good idea
- rikroots 4y agoWhile I broadly agree (my view: copyright lifetimes should be more in line with patent lifetimes), most other people who create work - in particular those who create work to help them pay their bills - would disagree. Fortunately there's a solution for mavericks like me: Creative Commons licenses[1]. While they don't change the fundamentals of copyright, they do offer us the chance to practice what we preach[2]. None of this touches the doctrine of Fair Use, of course. I like Fair Use - as long as the person/organisation claiming it remembers to cite the original work ... something I doubt Mr Warhol bothered to do. [1] - https://creativecommons.org/ https://creativecommons.org/ [2] - https://rikverse2020.rikweb.org.uk/blog/copyrights https://rikverse2020.rikweb.org.uk/blog/copyrights
- ghaff 4y agoIy's easy to lay it all at the feet of Disney. But, yeah, there are plenty of relatively small-time writers who support their families by cranking out some genre fiction book once a year (or whatever) who aren't all that anxious to just casually cut off some level of already modest back catalog sales. I don't care for myself. My writing translates into money through other paths. But there are a fair number of people for whom writing is their primary income source and it's not a huge one as it is.
- jeroenhd 4y agoI'm all for changing copyright to allow the stuff Warhol did, but I don't think this is substantially different at all. It's a direct copy of a picture with a coloured background. The angle, lighting, position, and expression, all probably directed by the photographer, are identical. This is the manual equivalent of an Instagram filter. The two images don't compete in the same market, but that's not relevant for copyright. I think it perhaps should be, but as it stands, the law shouldn't be interpreted like this. Imagine another type of copyrighted work, such as open source software, being reproduced against the terms of its license but with all names (variables etc.) changed, perhaps translated into another language or capitalised. The style of the work has definitely been changed, much like Warhol's style is very different from a photograph, but the product is very much a derivative that should be used in the terms set forth by the original author. Also consider the effect this would have on the internet: if Google/Facebook/Bytedance were to be allowed to just scrape images online and sell them as their own after applying a black-and-white filter, any photographer would probably be up in arms.
- XorNot 4y ago> The two images don't compete in the same market, but that's not relevant for copyright. That is actually extremely relevant for Fair Use though.[1] Note Factor 4: The Effect of the Use on the Potential Market for or Value of the Work [1] https://copyright.columbia.edu/basics/fair-use.html https://copyright.columbia.edu/basics/fair-use.html
- telotortium 4y agoThe hook for the case is that both images were available to be licensed as magazine covers for an article written for Prince's death, and Goldsmith's lawyers argued that made both pictures part of the same market: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33056773 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33056773
- towaway15463 4y agoI don’t think your analogy is correct. Colour and alteration of angle and shadow/lines produces a functionally distinct effect ie those who like the Warhol may dislike and the original for a variety of reasons including taste or whether it would match the decor where they would hang it. So it is not the same software with the variable names and casing or language changed, that would be invisible or relatively inconsequential to the end user. At worst it is a reskinned application but I think the effect is deeper than that.
- itronitron 4y ago>> If the ruling comes down on the side of the photographer there's definitely a chilling effect on the creation of new art. I actually think a ruling in favor of the photographer will favor creation of new art, because artists will have stronger protections. Warhol could have just taken his own photograph and there wouldn't be any argument to be made.
- indymike 4y ago> To me, the Warhol images are substantially different - the only common element is Prince's features, and presumably that likeness belongs to Prince, not the photographer. Depends on if Prince signed off on a model release.
- ghaff 4y agoModel releases are about using images in marketing/advertising/etc. I can use images of you for other purposes without a release.