3 ms·
Moral of the story: If you're on SVN right now, abandon it as soon as possible. Moving even a 2000 commit repo is no fun, especially when there are more develop
by whalesalad 15y ago
Moral of the story: If you're on SVN right now, abandon it as soon as possible. Moving even a 2000 commit repo is no fun, especially when there are more developers involved.
- jonstjohn 15y agoI read it as Moral of the story: don't switch from SVN unless you have good reason OR small team with not a lot of commits.
- urschrei 15y agoThe moral of any story involving SVN is: "Switch from SVN".
- mberning 15y agoDon't live in a black and white world.
- Semiapies 15y agoIndeed. SVN is far from the worst source control system out there, and even as we move on to better once, it's pointedly the system that got a lot of coders into using source control.
- JoshTriplett 15y agoI certainly like SVN's status as a "better CVS", and from that perspective they succeeded nicely. If nothing else, SVN has a much saner repository structure that makes it possible to migrate to a modern version control system, whereas the tools for migrating a CVS repository involve huge pain and sometimes guesswork, depending on how heavily people manually hacked the repo's RCS files and how deeply they used CVS's awful branching.
- nupark2 15y agoIt's not even a given that git is better than subversion for most non-OSS centralized development use cases.
- jordan0day 15y agoThat wasn't the moral of the story at all! "If you can deal with your current source code system, do not go through this pain. Seriously. This was a long, painful process for us. Over the years, many tools, systems, and processes had become deeply intertwined with our subversion installation. That said, if your team is small, or your source control system isn’t tied into anything, go for it! Just do it as soon as possible – the only time better than today was yesterday." The first half of that paragraph basically says that it very well might be more painful to switch to git than it is to keep using your existing system.
- JoshTriplett 15y agoIt also says, though, that if you want to switch, switch now, not later.
- oinksoft 15y agoHm, I've run many a 5000+ revision subversion repository through git-svn and had no issues. I'm not a git evangelist, but the tools for migrating from subversion are pretty good.
- Tobu 15y agoMy usual way of interacting with any svn repository is to run the entire history through git-svn, a command which takes all of five seconds to issue. There are a few extra niceties to consider when the switch is permanent, like setting up an AUTHORS identity map for the import and maybe gathering public keys for a gitolite, but the tooling side is entirely painless.