5 ms·
It's ridiculous to me that with so many legal services and songs at .99, people still pirate music. But it does show that it was all just an excuse. People that
by jrockway 15y ago
It's ridiculous to me that with so many legal services and songs at .99, people still pirate music. But it does show that it was all just an excuse. People that pirate just want free stuff.
Not true at all. Say I have a US credit card but want to buy Japanese music. Too bad, it's not for sale to me unless I trek to Japan and buy a CD with cash. So I pirate it instead.
Also, most $0.99 music stores sell compressed music, which is not acceptable to me. The pirates provide this to me for free, which makes the $0.99 song an inferior product. I do buy music that's distributed in FLAC format, however, like all of Jonathan Coulton's music. (There are also stores that cater to audiophiles and sell music at better than 44.1kHz/16-bit resolution. I buy music from them happily. The problem is they don't sell much music I like.)
- antr 15y ago100% agree. totally have the same issue with movies. if we are not catered for, why should we pay for a product that does not fit our needs. we are not the customers.
- res0nat0r 15y agoThis seems to be the fundamental shift in thinking since mp3's have become so ubiquitous in the last 15 years. The thinking that, if this isn't offered the way I want (mainly priced at whatever I choose, or as close $0.00 as possible, or if it isn't available), then I am rightly justified to steal it. Doesn't anyone else think this is a problem? I'm not saying I don't do the same, but I don't justify it in any other way than saying that I want stuff for free.
- jarek 15y agoI personally don't think it's a problem, because I don't agree with your classification of the action as "stealing." It's problematic enough with content I do actually want (copying is not directly analogous to stealing just like potential income is not the same as income), but when the business doesn't offer a product you want (so there isn't even lost potential income), obtaining such a product in a way that doesn't cost the business anything (such as copying a file) from a third party is not stealing.
- res0nat0r 15y agoThis argument comes up over and over again and it doesn't make any sense. If you are consuming the content then it does have value to you, therefore you should be paying for it.
- jarek 15y ago> If you are consuming the content then it does have value to you, therefore you should be paying for it. Who do I pay? What if the value it has to me is less than what anyone would like me to pay for it?
- res0nat0r 15y agoThe content creator? Can't pay them, don't want to pay them, don't like the price? Then you don't have the right to consume the content.
- jarek 15y ago> The content creator? Can't pay them, don't want to pay them, don't like the price? Then you don't have the right to consume the content. What kind of "right" are we talking about here? Moral, whose? Legal, in which jurisdiction? Under your definition of right, do they have the right to deny me their content they won't sell to me, if my consumption causes them no loss? If a bar won't let me in because I'm underage, but they position their TVs to be perfectly viewable by someone standing on the street, do I have no right to stand around and watch the TVs?
- res0nat0r 15y agoYour consumption does cause them a loss, this fallacy needs to quit being repeated. You value the content enough to consume it, so it is not 'free'. Why is it everyone thinks music is exempt from payment when value is derived from it? You don't expect to get a pair of jeans for free just because they are too expensive to afford do you? By this standard you will happily then give me your paycheck for this coming week correct? I believe the output of your work to have zero value, therefore your work entitles you to zero compensation. This is essentially your argument. Why would an artist want to produce music if they can't afford to pay their bills because you deem it your obligation to have their work for free?
- comex 15y agoDo you consider even, say, iTunes' 256kbps AAC unacceptable?
- jrockway 15y agoI probably can't hear the difference. It's nice to have a lossless source so that you can re-encode to a low bitrate for your portable player, though. 256kbps lossy audio sounds good, but 256kbps lossy audio re-encoded to 128kbps audio does not. (Right now, I have enough "legacy" 128kbps MP3s to make re-encoding unworthwhile; everything fits on my 16GB micro SD card. But that will not last forever, and who wants to carry around a hard drive over a micro SD card :) The real problem is that the people mixing the music probably don't have as nice a listening setup as most audiophiles do, so when you listen to that music you are listening to the inadequacies in the setup of the person who did the mixing. I still have brand-new albums in 2011 that are clipped! (Not to mention, more bass and treble than there should be. Cymbals do not make your ears bleed in real life.)
- loxs 15y agoYes. Not to mention that some "pirates" release recordings of such qualities, that you cannot buy on a CD/DVD (at least in my part of the world - Eastern Europe). For someone with a decent sound system these things DO matter, and 256kbps tracks are quite bad. Some 320kbps pirated mp3 albums are (almost) indistinguishable from a CD, and I would gladly pay to the people who ripped them :)
- loxs 15y agoAlso, have a look at this phenomenon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loudness_war https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loudness_war Digitally mastered recordings DO SOUND BETTER on low-grade sound systems (that's the reason for their existence after all). But on a quality hi-fi system, those only make your ears bleed (as jockway mentioned). So every time I spend 15 Euro for an album, I'm virtually playing the lottery, as I have no idea what will I hear from it. There are regions (Japan mostly) where they sell way better (not digitally mastered) recordings, but as mentioned, I can't buy if I don't go there. So now guess why piratebay is the best source of music... (I can at least hear it before dumping it - if it's no good).