27 ms·
Theater of Shame – The rise of online humiliation
- zmibes 4y agoPointing out the emperor has no clothes is both wrong and also humiliating for the emperor
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 4y agoIf that’s wrong I don’t want to be right. Respect for authority must be maintained. If current authorities can’t keep up then they should retire to save face. When they don’t they’ll get clowned.
- BiteCode_dev 4y agoYeah BS. I have been humiliated many times in my life, some times in life changing ways, and I'd still take it over real violence. People seeing it that way should spend some time with me in 3rd world countries to reset their value counter. I'll show you punishment. Shame is powerful and necessary, but it's very much a first step punishment, a warning, not an ultimate one. This mismatch between perceived intensity and the real thing is seen everywhere these days: insecurity, activism, political projections. It seems we solved so many important problems that humans have reset their baseline of comfort to confuse unease with danger. Loosing your job, your social status or your tweeter audience is not the greatest suffering you can endure. In fact, that's why exposed crooked politicians and companies keep getting away with things: shaming them just slow them down, not stop them.
- Ensorceled 4y ago> I'd still take it over real violence. Yeah, the article is a bit over the top here. I do think shame is at it's worst when coupled with real violence or intense threat of violence. > In fact, that's why exposed crooked politicians and companies keep getting away with things: shaming them just slow them down, not stop them. This is critical to the whole article: if a person is shameless and/or their community is ok with the "shameful" behaviour, then really there isn't any effect at all.
- causi 4y agoYeah, the article is a bit over the top here. I question whether it's genuinely over the top or if it's just a worrying symptom of society's increasing trend, on both sides of the aisle and every political corner, to equate speech with violence.
- LatteLazy 4y agoWhile I take your point, I think you might be over stating it a little: I would much rather take a punch in the face than lose my job for instance. A lot of men routinely get into fights over social status, I think their preference is pretty clear there.
- claudiawerner 4y ago>I have been humiliated many times in my life, some times in life changing ways, and I'd still take it over real violence. I would too, in most cases; that said, I'd rather get a literal slap on the wrist or even the face than be humiliated in an online sphere, especially as related to my real identity. It's not the case that shame and humiliation always trumps physical violence in my order of preferences, and I'd be surprised if it's not the same for you too. "Sticks and stones may break my bones but words will never hurt me" is a cute rhyme, but utterly disintegrates when one starts to consider degree and the importance of social standing in public daily life (from getting a job to the looks you get at Walmart).
- nullstyle 4y agoNah, any of the substantive physical violence I have suffered easily trumps the worst humiliation I've felt over the stupidest things I've expressed online. I'd rather be canceled than get knocked out any day of the week.
- incomingpain 4y ago>Shame is powerful and necessary, but it's very much a first step punishment, a warning, not an ultimate one. It's the dog growling to get you to back off so it doesn't have to bite you. >This mismatch between perceived intensity and the real thing is seen everywhere these days: insecurity, activism, political projections. This derives from the zero-tolerance policies in school. No bullying allowed and so people, millenials, never quite earnt or understand this. >It seems we solved so many important problems that humans have reset their baseline of comfort to confuse unease with danger. A common thing for humans. Right now it's like 18c outside and im freezing. But in the spring when it's 15c its soooo warm. the same goes for pleasure and pain. If you're always comfortable, you end up needing more and more pleasure heading to an extreme just to be happy. Societies even have this problem, when pleasure becomes imbalanced you end up throwing people to the lions.
- spoonjim 4y agoYes, Reddit's "watchpeopledie" forum was very instructive in just how damn good we have it in the West, and how precious it is and how much we need to protect our society from enemies foreign and domestic. On /r/watchpeopledie I saw a 16-year-old girl doused with gasoline and burned to death because she was accused of being with a gang that killed a local taxi driver in a mugging, a group of four young men bashed with rocks and set on fire because they were accused of stealing a laptop, and elementary-school children going around an abandoned building murdering tied up men in some kind of ISIS propaganda video. I've seen a woman in Iran hanged by being pulled up from a crane, starting to kick her feet slowly and then wildly and then stopping. A guy in Mexico having his heart cut out while he was alive in front of his son, and then the same happening to the son. A group of women stripped naked and shot in the head in some kind of cartel video. A guy told that he was being released and to turn away, and then used for target practice with some kind of heavy artillery - he essentially exploded when they hit him. All that shit is out there, and most Americans who have never seen anything worse than a mean Tweet have no idea about it.
- autoexec 4y agoThere's something very chilling about watching a video of a mob stoning someone to death and noticing some of the people cheering and filming are using iphones. It seems like a horrifying anachronism but it's just how things are now.
- meany 4y agoWhile there are experiences worse than death, there are instances where shaming leads to suicide. So at least in those instances the person apparently prefers death to shame. It’s likely that we all experience mental pain differently so the balance between the pain caused by shame and violence may vary by individual and culture. Also, the source of shame in one culture may elicit a “meh” response and in another drive someone to suicide.
- hdjjhhvvhga 4y ago> Tressie McMillan Cottom recently argued in The New York Times that shaming is a corrective to a white-dominated culture: against the backdrop of a more open and diverse public square, “shame is evidence of a democratic society operating democratically.” ...except that when the person being shamed is from your camp.
- neonsunset 4y agoIt is anti-democractic and bypasses justice mechanisms we worked hundreds of years to put in place. It is almost irrelevant what the group of people who experience disdain towards themselves think. Because subconsciously they are engaging in status-seeking behavior, which playing the victim card is very useful for.
- shadowgovt 4y agoSorry, I fail to see how reputational injury is anti-democratic. It is the people who decide if various attributes make a virtuous reputation. If anything, it can be more democratic than the law (with all of the unfortunate consequences that entails... The reason we bind force with rule of law and not rule of democracy directly is that we know the danger of the mob).
- neonsunset 4y agoThe issue I see with that there seems to be no middle ground. An issue is either largely unnoticed or it turns into crusade affecting everyone involved and leaving no winning move for participants in {dramaName}.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 4y agoWelcome to the internet, that’s the price of admission. Don’t want to play? Don’t chase status and unless you’re really awful you won’t be incorrectly dragged online. If someone does something fucked to they need to be accountable for that. That takes actually putting in work and being repentant. There’s no faking that.
- gadders 4y ago[flagged]
- pavlov 4y agoJust on the surface of it, it’s hard to believe that a Twitter account called “Libs of TikTok” is in fact engaging in well-intentioned discourse about medical treatment for minors. > “Trump never knowingly mocked a disabled reporter.” Is “knowingly” the operative word here? Because there’s a video of him doing just that.
- gadders 4y ago[flagged]
- revolvingocelot 4y ago>He didn't the reporter was disabled Ah yes, ignorance as a defence. Apropos for Trump. Anyone interested in the truth can read this: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/fact-checker/wp/2016/08/02/donald-trumps-revisionist-history-of-mocking-a-disabled-reporter/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/fact-checker/wp/2016/08/... The video of Trump mocking the disabled reporter is right there in the article. For anyone interested in the truth.
- bryanrasmussen 4y agoI mean I have to be honest here and there is a pretty good chance Trump isn't smart enough to realize the mannerisms he is mocking are in any way related to common disabilities.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 4y agoFrom its fake news to apologist in a few comments. If you apologized for being wrong instead of defending a buffoon.
- RalfWausE 4y agoShame... who is interested in shame? "Ist der Ruf erst ruiniert, lebt es sich ganz ungeniert" ("once the reputation is ruined, life is unabashed")
- microtherion 4y agoCoincidentally, another HN story today (https://www.wired.com/story/i-uncovered-an-army-of-fake-men-on-hinge/ https://www.wired.com/story/i-uncovered-an-army-of-fake-men-...) featured a brief quote from a company spokesperson Justine S... who, I assume, was the person of that name who had her own 15 minutes of infamy a few years ago. So the good news is that stories like this can eventually fade away.
- samatman 4y agoOf course this is laundered through Yale, the center of the cyclone of struggle-session insanity. Framing this around shame is of course misplaced, it is about threat: threat to one's comfortable use of the internet, one's social network, one's livelihood, and you'd love to believe these maniacs would stop there, wouldn't you. Did they ever before? Shame is used as a weapon and a warning. It isn't that those lucky souls this doesn't work on are shameless: rather, they are protected from mob violence against their character wreaking havoc on their livelihood. Young Adult authors have no such protection.
- shadowgovt 4y agoAuthors exist in an ecosystem where they make money based on the popularity of their work. It's an ecosystem more sensitive to public perception of the author than others. But that means an author simply has to be more protective of their private lives than other professions. There's a reason so many in history have written under pseudonyms; the effect of losing your audience if the public discovers you don't fit the mould is not new.
- spoonjim 4y agoBut there's a disproportionate power wielded by the "cancellers" that isn't really dependent on the public's willingness to buy the books. Note that the cancellers never go on a big publicity campaign to get people to stop buying a certain book - they target the gatekeepers in the system, like the publishers, who are staffed by Oberlin and Wesleyan alumnae who don't want to be ostracized as "bigots" at their college reunion. With the founder gone, Amazon is also a suitable target because the management of Amazon got their jobs through currying favor with their seniors rather than the approval of customers like Bezos did.
- shadowgovt 4y agoYes, that has not changed. It isn't like authors sold their books door-to-door in the past. If anything, self-publishing is easier now than in the past. ... But authors who have tried that have also found the public isn't receptive.
- bubblematrix 4y agoSuper PAC's such as Share Blue (now known as The American Independent) weaponized online shaming through troll farms. David Brock of Share Blue had a confidential memo leaked that outlined how weak Democratic support was in online comment sections, hence - they used troll farms to counter negative comments towards them. It annoyed Share Blue how Conservative comments were mostly grass-root. A similar Super PAC for online comment trolling was known as CTR (Correct the Record) - backed by Hillary Clinton. So if you posted a negative comment about her online back before the election, you would often see these blank troll accounts leave you a friendly little reply. It's hard to talk about this in tech because we, as a blob, enable it. It helps our companies growth and bottom line. Dark truth.
- causi 4y ago[flagged]
- vorpalhex 4y ago
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 4y agohttps://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/turning-point-teens-disinformation-trump/2020/09/15/c84091ae-f20a-11ea-b796-2dd09962649c_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/turning-point-teens-... Until such behaviors are made too expensive, illegal, or difficult, both parties and well enough funded organizations and individuals (see reputation management agencies) will all engage in this astro turfing. If you don’t like it when the other political party does but you don’t care when it’s your own political party, there are words for that.
- bubblematrix 4y agoI'm not interested in what-aboutism, I'm simply outlining the $100+ million dollars invested by DNC Super PAC's into weaponized shaming/trolling.
- thenerdhead 4y agoI've always been confused of how the word "shame" and "guilt" should be used. Also "humiliation" and "embarrassment" I thought shame was more associated to one's future "self". Guilt on the other hand is more associated to one's present "self". So when you don't live up to the expectations of your future self, you are ashamed. When you don't live up to your current expectations, you are found guilty. There's various examples in this article that seems to use shame as the catch-all. It feels like many of these online examples are rather guilt than shame? Humiliation is typically an underserved feeling. Shame on the other hand is internalized and thus deserved. Shame = I am bad Guilt = I did something bad Humiliation = I didn't deserve that Embarrassment = I deserved that https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6143989/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6143989/
- marcus_holmes 4y agoI abandoned my Twitter and FB accounts. Oh look, I don't have to worry about this crap any more. Yay :)
- spoonjim 4y agoLOL. Yale is five years behind the trend as usual. Online shame, and shame of all forms, is in fact now in precipitous decline, where people proudly or at least unashamedly do things that would have once invited shame (scream at retail employees, exhibit themselves nude on the Internet, default on their debts, etc.)
- 7373737373 4y agoI feel one disadvantage of globalization ("de-localization", "de-tribalization"?) is that the (potential) positive effect of shame - putting attention on and collectively (de)valuing antisocial acts and individuals (but not outright expelling them) doesn't work anymore. Abusers, scammers, grifters can just move on to the next community that knows nothing about their behavior, and restart the cycle of abuse without consequence. And the scalability of such schemes, and the lack of granularity and affordability of the legal system prevents any negative consequences for the perpetrators "in the small".
- kelseyfrog 4y agoIf someone doesn't want to be shamed online, then simply don't go online. It's a very simple solution. Being online is consenting to the risk of being shamed. For some people it's an easy choice to make: the benefits clearly out weight the risk, or vice-versa. For whatever reason, some people decide that they wish to be online, but don't agree with the risk of being shamed - a fool's errand. It's easier to move the world than to reshape the social order. Simply wishing for something to be true is the product of an immature mind.