2 ms·
Specifically, aluminum might replace steel because steel is being moved to an electrically reduced metal, with electricity separating oxygen from the oxide (ind
by pfdietz 4y ago
Specifically, aluminum might replace steel because steel is being moved to an electrically reduced metal, with electricity separating oxygen from the oxide (indirectly perhaps, using electrolytic hydrogen). But aluminum is already electrically reduced. The cost advantage of using cheaper coke to make iron goes away.
- kragen 4y agoSteel moving to being electrically reduced could happen for regulatory reasons, as you seem to be suggesting, or it could happen because the electricity becomes cheaper than the coke, at least during the daytime.
- pfdietz 4y agoEven so, this reduces the cost difference between iron and aluminum, so we'd see more applications shift to aluminum.
- kragen 4y agoAgreed! To be more specific, the volume electrochemical equivalent of trivalent iron is 8.83 μm dm²/A/hour (and that's the form of iron in hematite), and for aluminum it's 12.4 μm dm²/A/hour, calculated in units(1) as 26.982 dalton / (2.70 g/cc) / 3 e. Usually metal prices are quoted per kg, not per liter, so it might be better to calculate these as 190 μg per coulomb for iron and 93 μg per coulomb for aluminum: iron would still be cheaper, costing 49% as much (assuming the Faradaic efficiencies are comparable and the other aspects of the processes are of insignificant cost, which are obviously wrong assumptions), but right now aluminum costs US$3.10/kg (USGS MCS 2022) and steel is more like US$1.30/kg (same source: US$110 billion ÷ 87 million tonnes raw steel). This is a much smaller gap than I had expected, so maybe the switch to electrically reduced iron (directly, as in electrolytic iron, or indirectly) won't be as big a change as I thought.