3 ms·
While "authoritarian governments" would be better than "dictators", this is SO not news. A slightly less superficial article might note how such lies "naturall
by bell-cot 4y ago
While "authoritarian governments" would be better than "dictators", this is SO not news.
A slightly less superficial article might note how such lies "naturally" arise in autocratic systems - where local officials are both under pressure to report good economic results, and have enough power to lie. That is how tens of millions of Chinese starved to death in the Three Years of Great Famine ~1960. ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Chinese_Famine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Chinese_Famine ) Local officials reported excellent harvests of food crops, and Chairman Mao's central government generally tried to do the right things - but sustaining human life requires that the food "on the books" actually exists.
- alfiedotwtf 4y ago> this is so not news I originally read about this in the Potemkin Village Gazette :)
- drieddust 4y ago
- arcticbull 4y agoCurious your thinking as to how that relates to the Colorado River Compact's allocation of water [1]. The basis of the compact in 1922 mis-calculated the amount of water that was actually available to be drawn, and since then the states have found out that this was in fact very inaccurate. In recent renegotiations, this was solved by adding imaginary water onto the books instead of actually figuring out a meaningful solution and confronting reality. I recall the governor of Utah suggesting un-ironically praying for rain. I suspect that this kind of lie is more than just a 'free' vs 'authoritarian' issue, but rather some kind of artifact of human nature. It seems a little bit too easy to attribute this to the 'other' when there's plenty of examples at home where it's happening right out in the open. John McCain wanted this sorted in 2008 - 14 years ago. After all one would imagine that sustaining human life requires that the water "on the books" actually exists, too, no? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colorado_River_Compact https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colorado_River_Compact
- bell-cot 4y ago> this kind of lie is [...] some kind of artifact of human nature. Oh yes, agree. Whether it's the value of real estate in Pompeii (evidently somebody failed to properly perform the rituals which ensured the favor of Vulcan), or the size of annual catches in the Atlantic northwest cod fishery (over-fishing lead to catastrophic collapse in the early 1990's), or the permanence of land in large river delta systems, or... Humans love to get together, agree on some ideas about the real world which they all like, and pressure any nay-sayers to shut up and stop hurting anyone's feelings/social standing/anticipated profits/etc.
- im11btw 4y ago"A slightly less superficial article might note how such lies "naturally" arise in autocratic systems - where local officials are both under pressure to report good economic results, and have enough power to lie." From the article: "The explanation is probably simple: opportunity and motive. Part of what makes dictatorships dictatorships is that questioning the official line is dangerous. At the same time, autocratic regimes have a strong incentive to report healthy growth: its absence may be taken as a sign of incompetence or weakness, which dictators can ill afford. Autocrats’ subordinates face similar incentives. In a related study Jeremy Wallace, a researcher, found misreporting by Chinese provinces, too. As he notes, a leaked American diplomatic cable from 2007 revealed the view of Li Keqiang, the prime minister, then a provincial party secretary. He had said, with a smile, that gdp figures were “for reference only”: he relied instead on proxies, such as electricity use."
- 3pt14159 4y agoIt is news to me that the numbers could be this cooked. I, perhaps naively, thought that trade numbers would betray any meaningful difference in GDP versus the reported figure. I am in the top 1% of news consumption. This is real news if the numbers are truly this different. My main question on the graph relates to China. How much could pollution influence the makeup of this data?