6 ms·
DVD drives turned into microscopes
- mechanical_bear 4y agoObsolete technology. :-|
- avastmick 4y agoGreat STEAM project for schools (who likely have the needed DVD players).
- PostOnce 4y agoWho is the asshole who snuck the A into STEM? Kids have too much Art and not enough Science as it is, thats why we developed a STEM focus. STEM is science, A is everything else. "The arts and sciences", they are separate for a reason, and the reason is that Art won't feed you and Technology will. STEAM is a bastardization, a dilution of STEM and of the education of children. There is room for Art, but if you lump it in with engineering, suddenly the focus is all art and we're right back where we started before we had STEM as an acronym.
- rzzzt 4y agoThe "and" in "arts and sciences" is not a logical operator, it already suggests a union of the sets. The "arts" portion allows one to communicate clearly, understand motives, etc.
- uoaei 4y agoArt and science have their similarities. For instance, art is the exploration of the space of possible emotional truths, while science is the exploration of the space of possible statistical truths. Design and engineering are opposed to both art and science, in that the latter are open-ended explorations that by construction do not pre-suppose an end goal. Design is teleological, and engineering is just a means to bring designs to fruition. So examining the acronym closer we notice that even design is excluded from STEM which seems like a huge oversight -- you don't want engineers who are not practiced in designing functional, reliable systems... Art is a very important part of the development of people as positive forces in society and civilization, and so presumably, if we assume good faith to explore this question, we could posit that people are reacting to the exclusion or at least de-emphasis of art education in conjunction with the typical STEM curriculum. The intention and goal is I believe best summarized in the famous quote from Jurassic Park: "your scientists were so preoccupied with whether or not they could, that they didn't stop to think if they should".
- wisty 4y agoJust as often, arts gets the short shift. Art in a "STEAM" program is likely to be more like design (Photoshop, logo design, etc). I think it's a bunch of enthusiastic education administrators who don't spend much time in schools, but think they can make science fun and art more business friendly if they find a bit of synergy.
- gilded-lilly 4y agoYeah, it’s pretty dumb. Science is fundamentally objective, art is fundamentally subjective. That’s a solid distinction. I think the idea of studying art is wrong in and of itself. It’s interesting and possibly useful from a technical/historical standpoint, but the idea that you can go to school to learn how to be a good artist is silly, in my opinion.
- thornic 4y agoThat's an odd take. Studying art, like studying any subject, is a great way to be exposed to new ideas and fresh perspectives, which in turn informs and inspires one's own creativity and understanding.
- gilded-lilly 4y agoSure, but I think it’s like being a sports commentator vs a competitor, or a film critic vs a director. Tarantino, Van Gough, Jimi Hendrix (and the like) all achieved greatness without any institutional backing or education, as far as I’m aware.
- swores 4y agoI was going to just write a vague comment that many of the world's best painters, musicians and film makers have studied before they became great, and cherry picking a few who haven't doesn't prove otherwise. But actually I remembered Van Gogh already is the opposite example than you think. Van Gogh: "He traveled to Brussels later in the year, to follow Theo's recommendation that he study with the Dutch artist Willem Roelofs, who persuaded him – in spite of his dislike of formal schools of art – to attend the Académie Royale des Beaux-Arts. He registered at the Académie in November 1880, where he studied anatomy and the standard rules of modelling and perspective." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vincent_van_Gogh https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vincent_van_Gogh edit 2: If interested in other examples, check out alumni lists of places such as London's Royal Academy of Arts (where for example, J. M. W. Turner, one of the most famous British painters of the 19th century, enrolled as a student at the age of 14; and where actors such as Alan Rickman, Tom Hiddleston, and Anthony Hopkins - among many others - studied). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Royal_Academicians https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Royal_Academicians And the RA is far from the only place with a history of teaching some fantastic artists. You'll find a few, or many, famously successful people who've studied at pretty much any of the best places to study arts in the US (https://www.artsy.net/article/artsy-editorial-15-top-art-schools-united-states https://www.artsy.net/article/artsy-editorial-15-top-art-sch...), or at the École des Beaux-Arts, Paris (students including impressionist painter Edgar Degas, or American architect John Russell Pope who designed the National Archives and Records Administration building as well as the Jefferson Memorial, among others), etc etc. (You can stop reading this comment here probably, unless you're interested enough to go on - it's quite long after two edited additions...) Absolutely there are plenty of people, both in creative areas and in business and science etc, who've got to the top of their game without formal education, thanks to talent and self-driven learning. It wouldn't be hard to pick a handful of cities from around the world and name from each just as many examples as I've given of extremely talented, and famous for it, artists who didn't have formal education. But there's plenty who did have either personal mentors/tutors, or degrees in their field, and while nobody would suggest that their education was 100% (or close) of what made them a great artist, plenty of them do attribute it (either institutionally or just their mentor) partly to thank - just as some consider it wasted time with hindsight. edit: Anecdotally, in my youth I was a professional singer - nothing fancy or famous but salaried for a few years of recordings and tours. Not only did I keep working with a singing teacher who helped me on any issues I had (early on most issues would be ones pointed out to me, in my last year or two nearly all sessions were focussed on whatever I wanted to work on), but pretty much everyone I sang with who was either early in their career, or who sometimes / often sang solos rather than just in a choir chorus, had lessons from some sort of mentor (or more than one). As far as I'm aware, even those I sang with more than a decade ago who didn't move on and are still singing, in some cases as somewhat well known soloists in their areas, still have a coach/mentor to help keep their voices in good shape and even to keep getting better and better. I'm also one of many, many people who, as kids, were lucky enough to have the chance to not only have a musical instrument but to have weekly lessons for it. I would guess that if you look at the most successful pop/rock stars, maybe it's less common to have had those sorts of lessons growing up, if you look at classical music greats it would be the opposite way around, Jazz somewhere in the middle... etc. (I could be way off). Which isn't to say there aren't pop/rock artists who had a good musical education (a couple of people who shared teachers with me have had chart hits here in the UK), nor that there aren't classical music performers who taught themselves everything they know (/ learning by watching greats who inspired them). There's really no right or wrong way to become a great artist.
- rcxdude 4y agoReally? I would say that it is art which is suffering in education at the moment. And much as many people leave high school with a lack of understanding of basic maths and science they also leave with a lack of capability to engage with media in anything but the surface level. Fundamentally everything in STEAM is a creative endeavour of some form or another and I think they are a lot more alike in the skills and techniques that let you succeed than people like to pretend.
- adhesive_wombat 4y agoReminds me of the Copenhagen Design Museum. Full of completely useless modern-art-esque "takes" on various items (one specific highly practical item notwithstanding: a specific chair design). "Design" means achieving an optimum in a highly multivariate requirements space: functionalities, ease of use, aesthetics[1], cost, material use, robustness, longevity of the design[2], scalability, cost to the user, cost to manufacture or provide, ease of marketing[3], etc etc. Which basically none of the exhibits actually showed. If you focus only on the form, it's "just" art. A worthy endeavour, certainly, but it's not the same thing. [1]: extremely variable among people so an optimum that many people agree on in this axis is very hard to reach. "Great designers" often are famous specifically for excelling here without major impairment of other requirements. [2] can you still make it next year, next decade? Will people still want it even if you can? [3] it can be easier to market a lesser product, say, that's cheaper, even if it's disproportionately worse for that lower price
- fuckHNtho 4y agoagh yes! i agree, i was very disappointed when i made a trip there ten years ago
- dotancohen 4y agoI've never seen the STEAM acronym, and agree that art as colloquially used certainly has no place in the STEM acronym for that acronym's intended usage. That said, how do you interpret the phrase "state of the art"? What does "art" mean in that context?
- jimbob45 4y agoSTEAM seems like a pointless acronym. There’s nothing left that it doesn’t cover. You might as well just say “school subjects”.
- wlindley 4y agoAgreed. "Arts and Sciences" covers it. What part of technology and mathematics are not already part of science? (Signed, Department of Redundancy Dept.)
- midoridensha 4y ago>The entire device is controlled by an Analog Discovery 2, although this principle could be ported to other microcontroller platforms. Good thing they didn't use a Raspberry Pi...
- boltzmann-brain 4y agoYou're getting down voted, I think because people think you're hating on the Raspberry Pi, but I believe you might be talking about the current scarcity of it.
- midoridensha 4y agoThat's exactly it: there was an article about this here on HN just today. I guess I should have linked to it.
- jetbalsa 4y agoI wonder if you did this with a Blu-ray Drive how the resolution would increase.
- ars 4y agoAround 2.6 times: "This allows a reduction of the pit size from 400 nm for DVD to 150 nm for Blu-ray Disc, and of the track pitch from 740 nm to 320 nm".
- nomel 4y agoDon’t miss the very informative comment there by Edwin Hwu , detailing other uses: https://hackaday.com/2022/10/01/dvd-drives-turned-into-microscopes/#comment-6518111 https://hackaday.com/2022/10/01/dvd-drives-turned-into-micro...
- boltzmann-brain 4y agoPersonally I'm extremely psyched for what comes out of it. As optical drive manufacture is winding down, there are some excellent manufacturing facilities out there that could easily be repurposed to making microscopes like these, as well as micro-scale 3D printers. If we can catch the wind there, we'll have these capabilities available for the tiniest amounts of money, available to every school and every school child. Who's going to make the kickstarter happen?
- Venkatesh10 4y agoI tried this once when my DVD player died. I used it on top of my main camera to use it as a macro camera. It was surprisingly good.
- geon 4y agoAre you talking about using the dvd lens on a camera? That’s not at all what the article is about.
- denton-scratch 4y ago> with resolutions higher than can typically be obtained with visible light microscopes But DVD lasers use visible light! The constraint on the resolution of an optical microscope is the wavelength of light, right? A scanning electron microscope has higher resolution because it doesn't suffer that constraint. The article doesn't explain this improved resolution. In fact at no point does the article definitively say that this type of microscope can resolve things that no optical microscope can resolve.
- actionfromafar 4y agoWell, it says typically.
- denton-scratch 4y agoYes, I used the word "definitively" on purpose. I'm saying the article's claims for superior resolution use weasel words. "Typically" is such a weasel word.
- rolph 4y agohttps://www.textcompare.org/readability/weasel-words https://www.textcompare.org/readability/weasel-words
- raverbashing 4y agoA laser would be better than regular light, even at visible wavelengths "Regular light" is wideband and acts more erratically at the smallest dimensions
- denton-scratch 4y agoMakes sense.
- terramex 4y agoHere's another take at DVD laser scanning microscope from 2 years ago with open source Arduino code and PCB design: http://www.gaudi.ch/GaudiLabs/?page_id=652 http://www.gaudi.ch/GaudiLabs/?page_id=652
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- xnorswap 4y agore: "Wasn't this posted 3 days ago?" as someone just asked in a now deleted comment. OP's profile shows submitted 3 days ago. Front page shows submitted 9 hours ago. Both link back to the same story. HN does sometimes boost stories that didn't get attention they felt they deserved. It looks like that may have happened here because the story ID is consistent with having been posted 3 days ago. Edit: And if you mouse over "9 hours ago" it shows the date 2022-10-01.
- _Microft 4y agoThis is an official feature of HN. The posts that will be re-upped can be found at https://news.ycombinator.com/pool https://news.ycombinator.com/pool