3 ms·

None of the text-to-image tools seem to really understand 3D geometry, so I feel safe for now. Look at examples for icosahedron [1] vs dodecahedron [2] vs octa

None of the text-to-image tools seem to really understand 3D geometry, so I feel safe for now. Look at examples for icosahedron [1] vs dodecahedron [2] vs octahedron [3] None of the images were actually geometrically correct - is that quibbling? Maybe, but sometimes for some audience words actually mean something, not just some vague evocation of the angular aesthetic of something. Has someone delineated the words that will not appear in a stock photography prompt? If there was some feedback like "I'm confident in this" to "I'm guessing here, user beware", it would be a lot more usable. [1] https://replicate.com/api/models/stability-ai/stable-diffusion/files/57984014-0580-47ee-acc4-da03fe84a8bd/out-2.png https://replicate.com/api/models/stability-ai/stable-diffusi... [2] https://replicate.com/api/models/stability-ai/stable-diffusion/files/a04b3d89-5e74-4adf-beb6-96861a72676a/out-1.png https://replicate.com/api/models/stability-ai/stable-diffusi... [3] https://replicate.com/api/models/stability-ai/stable-diffusion/files/14f94681-185a-43bc-9a45-2e75e0d855c1/out-3.png https://replicate.com/api/models/stability-ai/stable-diffusi...

jarrenae 4y ago
That's one of the things I've found deeply interesting about the current generation of tools, there's little (if any) comprehension going on, it's really just trying to "enhance" a blur/bit of noise to make the image it was told to make. And I'm not sure I completely know what you mean, but we are planning to add voting and tagging to improve filtering for images.
londons_explore 4y ago
You saw this right: https://dreamfusion3d.github.io/ https://dreamfusion3d.github.io/ That's the same type of diffusion model used here, and without any further training, it is constrained to generate something that is consistent from all angles when viewed in 3d.
- an1sotropy 4y ago
  Thanks for pointing that out, maybe I’ll try it. The question is, if I say “icosahedron” will it actually make a (3D) icosahedron

jarrenae 4y ago

That's one of the things I've found deeply interesting about the current generation of tools, there's little (if any) comprehension going on, it's really just trying to "enhance" a blur/bit of noise to make the image it was told to make. And I'm not sure I completely know what you mean, but we are planning to add voting and tagging to improve filtering for images.

londons_explore 4y ago

You saw this right: https://dreamfusion3d.github.io/ https://dreamfusion3d.github.io/ That's the same type of diffusion model used here, and without any further training, it is constrained to generate something that is consistent from all angles when viewed in 3d.

an1sotropy 4y ago
Thanks for pointing that out, maybe I’ll try it. The question is, if I say “icosahedron” will it actually make a (3D) icosahedron