5 ms·
Tesla unveils its humanoid robot for 'less than $20k'
- nilespotter 4y agoCan't have sex with it.
- wmf 4y agoRepeating Elon's claims in a headline is journalistic malpractice at this point. It won't be $20K.
- addicted 4y agoEspecially now that he has publicly admitted that he deliberately makes up shit to prevent investment and interest going to potential competitors by lying. The whole hyperloop nonsense was nothing other than an effort to kill the CA HSR because it would potentially impact Tesla negatively. The good thing is that unlike the Hyperloop this was actually demoed, so other than the ElonCult most people are not gonna be impressed by a Honda Asimo circa 2011 knockoff. Especially not Boston Dynamics.
- fastball 4y agoWhen did he say that?
- tomp 4y agoIt's in quotes? Not repeating Tesla's claims is editorialising, which is fine if you're reading an opinion piece, but true journalism is about objectively reporting on things. Tesla says "less than $20k" so journalists should report "less than $20k"
- wmf 4y agoIt isn't an opinion that everything from Tesla has been late and priced higher than promised.
- aqsheehy 4y agoIsn't this less than Boston dynamics had in 2008?
- systemvoltage 4y agoYes, but they did it in 8 months with a completely different approach. BD spun off of MIT leg laboratory as an academic research project with different goals, methods and formalisms. Here is Dave Jones talking about how cool it was: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YIbQ3nudCA0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YIbQ3nudCA0 If you want actual engineering inspiration and positivity, HN isn't the place anymore. You'll mostly find cynicism.
- shapefrog 4y ago> HN isn't the place anymore. You'll mostly find cynicism That is such a cynical take I am not sure where to start.
- systemvoltage 4y agoYeah you’re right, there is some of it but when it comes to anything that slightly disturbs the political bias; cynicism prevails.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sschueller 4y ago"Yes, but they did it in 8 months with a completely different approach." These engineers do not work in a vacuum and you can not state that all that BD and others have done since 2008 hasn't moved the overall field forward.
- systemvoltage 4y agoWait… I didn’t say or imply that at all. I think BD is amazing.
- pelagicAustral 4y ago> Tesla CEO Elon Musk said that the new robot should be able to walk within the next few weeks Further down... > Tesla revealed that it had the first prototype in February of 2022, which led to this new version that is now supposedly about to walk in the next few days. I can see this yet another cybertruck/hyperloop/solarcity Muskery... guy is the saint patron of smokeware at this point.
- seanhunter 4y agoYup. To cherry-pick one example from the press coverage of this event. 'Musk has said he expects Tesla will achieve full self-driving this year and mass-produce a robotaxi with no steering wheel or pedal by 2024. At an “Autonomy” event in 2019, Musk promised 1m robotaxis by 2020 but has yet to deliver such a car.' https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2022/sep/30/tesla-optimus-humanoid-robot-elon-musk-ai-day https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2022/sep/30/tesla-opt...
- shapefrog 4y ago(2015) Elon Musk Says Tesla Vehicles Will Drive Themselves in Two Years https://fortune.com/2015/12/21/elon-musk-interview/ https://fortune.com/2015/12/21/elon-musk-interview/
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- fastball 4y agoFor Cybertruck they literally built a giant new factory first because they didn't have the existing capacity to build it, and existing factories were better tooled for the successors to their existing car designs (e.g. Model Y). That new factory (in Texas) is now finished, so... yeah, Cybertruck probably not "smokeware". Just delayed for various reasons, some of which all car manufacturers are experiencing right now. Elon Musk never said he was going to build a Hyperloop. He said "I had this idea, here is a blue paper". Some people (not him) ran with the idea. Solarcity was acquired by Tesla and Tesla (to this day) continues to operate in the Solar and energy storage space as Tesla Energy. You can order your own Tesla Solar Roof with a Tesla Powerwall today if you want.
- rgovostes 4y agoWhat is the argument for making (or buying) a humanoid robot, as opposed to another design?
- matthews2 4y agoNot a fan of Tesla, but it must have taken a lot of brilliant engineers to go from a dancing man in spandex to a walking robot in a year!
- leoh 4y agoGood grief, Elon can be incredibly dishonest. Although building an agile robot is impressive, training is the hard problem at this point, and I have little faith in his ability to execute safely based on Tesla’s “FSD” tech.
- siliconc0w 4y agoI think Elon deserves some cynicism but it seems they really are designing this thing for cost and given the timeline and resources it is reasonably impressive to be this far, and it really doesn't need to do too much to be useful. With aging demographics I think there is absolutely will be demand provided they can land in that pricing ballpark so I'm glad someone is working on it. I think year 2 or 3 will really tell us if this is real. With FSB they're in a tight spot, it can be pretty good is some scenarios but it's not clear it'll get to where it needs to be for L5 anytime soon. I think if they cut the price by maybe 1/3 to half and managed to smooth out the ride it'd be an excellent option for an already pretty good car and maybe in ten years we'd be closer to real car-without-steering-wheel FSD. But yeah it's hard to walk back all the hype on that.
- NalNezumi 4y agoI'm glad they're working on robotics but as someone that worked on a starup that set a price tag really early with mass production and RaaS (Robot as a Service concept), in mind, I'm really, really worried. Because the price tag we worked on was also around 20k$, and that price tag essentially killed the project from the design level. (durability and sensor quality / automation capacity tradeoff just was fiction) I hope Musk are more understanding when the engineers finally come and tell them those projections are over optimistic, and can bite the bitter pill, for the project. Ours wasn't, and the entire mechanical team quit, and so did the automation team.